Elvis Presley
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
Who would you rather have as your franchise QB?
Carson Palmer vs. Eli Manning
- Thread starter Elvis Presley
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
nbcrusader
Blue Crack Addict
OP
OP
Elvis Presley
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
Wow, what a debate!
Hewson
Blue Crack Supplier
Rosie Palmer
Hewson said:
we have a winner.
right now carson palmer is the better QB. eli has shown signs of being just as good, but he still struggles with his accuracy.
palmer may be the better QB now... but i'm more than happy with eli's potential.
Last edited:
UltraVioletMofo
The Fly
Would have to go with Palmer.
OP
OP
Elvis Presley
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
Headache in a Suitcase said:
Do you think Eli has more potential? Or are you just happy with his potential since you are a Giant fan? I guess I ask because Ive heard lots of commentators say theyd take Manning earlier this year, then he started throwing lots of INTs and they all shut up.....
trojanchick99
Rock n' Roll Doggie FOB
Carson Palmer in a heartbeat. Yes, I'm biased.
Elvis Presley said:
Do you think Eli has more potential? Or are you just happy with his potential since you are a Giant fan? I guess I ask because Ive heard lots of commentators say theyd take Manning earlier this year, then he started throwing lots of INTs and they all shut up.....
frankly i'm just happy with his potential. wether he has more potential than carson or not? who the hell knows... i'm happy, as a giants fan, that he has the potential to be a franchise quarterback for many many yeas... the same way you're thrilled with carson palmer.
frankly i would be happy as a pig in shit with either one of them... as opposed to if i had, say, chad pennington.
Got Philk?
Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
Kyle Orton???
OP
OP
Elvis Presley
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
Headache in a Suitcase said:
Yeah, I hear that, makes sense. Palmer has been unreal this year so far, so Cincy is in a sweaty fervor over him. As for Eli, I think he has lots of potential, but dont expect him to ever be the QB his brother is.....
phanan
Blue Crack Addict
Elvis Presley said:
My question is, why?
Does anyone here remember how Peyton Manning was his first year? He wasn't exactly tearing up the league yet. And while this is Eli's second year, keep in mind he started about half the games his first year, so he's really just wrapping up his rookie season, and you know what? He's done pretty much as well as his older brother did when he started out.
Will he end up doing as well as Peyton five years from now? Time will tell, but I certainly wouldn't be surprised if he did.
eli's stats and total wins after 16 games were better/higher than peyton's were after 16 games.
does that mean eli will be better than peyton? of course not... if he's even in the same ballpark as his brother i'll be one happy mofo.
does that mean eli will be better than peyton? of course not... if he's even in the same ballpark as his brother i'll be one happy mofo.
OP
OP
Elvis Presley
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
Headache in a Suitcase said:eli's stats and total wins after 16 games were better/higher than peyton's were after 16 games.
does that mean eli will be better than peyton? of course not... if he's even in the same ballpark as his brother i'll be one happy mofo.
I think Eli has a better supporting cast than Manning did early, and a much much better defense than those old Colts teams. Which would attribute to more wins.....
dommer96
The Fly
Carson Palmer
Mr. BAW
ONE love, blood, life
Archie Manning must be having trouble sleeping...both Eli and Peyton have lost to the same team this year.......San Diego; the same Chargers that Eli refused to play for....!
Mr. BAW said:
i didn't even think of that
Mr. BAW
ONE love, blood, life
:itjustoccurredtomeaswell: 
Mr. BAW said::itjustoccurredtomeaswell:
you should call mort and give him the tip
Mr. BAW
ONE love, blood, life
Did you know Mort's son is the back-up QB for the Arkansas Razorbacks...when 'SC trashed them earlier this year, they threw him to the fire! it was sad to see him get trampled....! 
i did not know that
trojanchick99
Rock n' Roll Doggie FOB
Mr. BAW said:Did you know Mort's son is the back-up QB for the Arkansas Razorbacks...when 'SC trashed them earlier this year, they threw him to the fire! it was sad to see him get trampled....!
No wonder he's so keen on trying to prove Pete Carroll is going to the NFL.
Mr. BAW
ONE love, blood, life
Maybe....
Hewson
Blue Crack Supplier
I heard Mort on the radio a few weeks ago talking about his son playing QB at Arkansas.Mr. BAW said:Did you know Mort's son is the back-up QB for the Arkansas Razorbacks...when 'SC trashed them earlier this year, they threw him to the fire! it was sad to see him get trampled....!
Mr. BAW
ONE love, blood, life
Here's another tid-bit you didn't know...another of Mr. BAW's alumni played at BYU before being a 3rd round draft of the NY Jets..Chris Farasopolous....played during the early 70's...Headache in a Suitcase said:
Hewson
Blue Crack Supplier
I'm willing to bet nobody outside of you and the Farasopalooza family knew that tidbit.
Mr. BAW
ONE love, blood, life
Hewson said:I'm willing to bet nobody outside of you and the Farasopalooza family knew that tidbit.
YOU WANNA PIECE OF ME????? YOU GOT IT!!!!!!
Similar threads
