bloodysunday972
War Child
opinions should they have been ?
should the ground beneath her feet and summer rain should have been on atyclb?
- Thread starter bloodysunday972
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
a-mole
War Child
dancing barefoot would really have been nice on the album... I soooooo 
that song!!
But I am glad they at least put it on the B-Side.. so we are still blessed with it
Personally I would have substituted it for "Grace" but.. is cool the way it is ^_^
shame one me.. I have never listened to Ground beneath her Feet.. I completely forgot about that song
gonna change that right NOW!
that song!! But I am glad they at least put it on the B-Side.. so we are still blessed with it
Personally I would have substituted it for "Grace" but.. is cool the way it is ^_^
shame one me.. I have never listened to Ground beneath her Feet.. I completely forgot about that song
gonna change that right NOW!
Last edited:
Jack In The Box
Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
The Ground Beneath Her Feet... yes, it's a great song, it should have been not only in the European ATYCLB
Summer Rain it's fine as a b-side, a beautiful song, but only a b-side
Summer Rain it's fine as a b-side, a beautiful song, but only a b-side
Liesje
Blue Crack Addict
TGBHF, yes definitely. In my top 10 U2 songs. Summer Rain is alright, a fine B-side, I wouldn't replace it for any of the songs already on ATYCLB though.
~*Buffalo*~
War Child
Lucky me! I got Ground Beneath Her Feet on my ATYCLB. And I got Summer Rain on my 1990-2000 B-sides, so I am a happy camper
I agree with U2Kitten, though ... something should have been in place of Grace ~ not one of my favourites! I actually like Dirty Day better than Summer Rain.
I agree with U2Kitten, though ... something should have been in place of Grace ~ not one of my favourites! I actually like Dirty Day better than Summer Rain.
teehee
Refugee
The Ground Beneath Her Feet is one of my fave songs. It is just... wonderful. It shouldn't have been just in the English version of ATYCLB It's sooo unfair.
ATYCLB was the first U2 album I bought and I became completely crazy searching the song through the record because the lyrics of TGBHF were on the booklet but there was no song! At first I thought it was a bonus track or something and when I found out it was just a mistake I downloaded the song, fell in love and bought the Million Dollar Hotel OST and The Ground Beneath Her Feet book!
The ground beneath her feet
It's sooo unfair.ATYCLB was the first U2 album I bought and I became completely crazy searching the song through the record because the lyrics of TGBHF were on the booklet but there was no song! At first I thought it was a bonus track or something and when I found out it was just a mistake I downloaded the song, fell in love and bought the Million Dollar Hotel OST and The Ground Beneath Her Feet book!
The ground beneath her feet 
teehee
Refugee
I liked it though it is a bit of a mess, you know. It is not easiest thing I've read.
It's the story of Vina Apsara and Ormus Cama, two rock stars with a weird relationship between them.
It's the story of Vina Apsara and Ormus Cama, two rock stars with a weird relationship between them.
Last edited:
FallingStar
Rock n' Roll Doggie FOB
- Joined
- Nov 5, 2001
- Messages
- 8,800
Love the book. 
I used to love TGBHF more in fromer times, but not so much anymore, so it's good that it's not on the regular album.
But Summer Rain should definitely been on ATYCLB!
I used to love TGBHF more in fromer times, but not so much anymore, so it's good that it's not on the regular album.
But Summer Rain should definitely been on ATYCLB!
Moonlit_Angel
Blue Crack Addict
"Summer Rain" definitely should've been included on there (if I had to pick a song to replace "Summer Rain" with from there, I'd say take "New York" out and put "Summer Rain" in instead-I'd leave "Grace" there).
I dunno if "The Ground Beneath Her Feet" really would've fit with the whole vibe of the album. It would have seemed a little out of place or something. I wouldn't have complained if it were included, though...
I do know that I am in love with that song. Dear god, it's an awesome song.
Angela
I dunno if "The Ground Beneath Her Feet" really would've fit with the whole vibe of the album. It would have seemed a little out of place or something. I wouldn't have complained if it were included, though...
I do know that I am in love with that song. Dear god, it's an awesome song.
Angela
shaun vox
New Yorker
im not a huge fan of atyclb but i love GRACE it has a bluesy sound to it and some nice guitar work from edge i love it.i also keep it on repeat.
also at the end of any elevation show they played grace(pre recorded, from the album)
they could have had a loud jam at the end of the song like stair way to heaven that would have rocked.
also at the end of any elevation show they played grace(pre recorded, from the album)
they could have had a loud jam at the end of the song like stair way to heaven that would have rocked.
mad1
ONE love, blood, life
Yea, thats right, mine has Ground Beneath!
I have not listened to this album for one and a half years now...........
just recently listened to MDH and found myself lying calm and drifting off to the soft sounds in it.
I have not listened to this album for one and a half years now...........
just recently listened to MDH and found myself lying calm and drifting off to the soft sounds in it.
flaming june
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
I love TGBHF!!!
Question: Is the ATYCLB version the same as the one from the MDH soundtrack?
Question: Is the ATYCLB version the same as the one from the MDH soundtrack?
mad1
ONE love, blood, life
er I tink there is a slight diff with the intro.....I must check that one out!
Similar threads
- Sticky
