jick
Refugee
From a pure sales standpoint (this means opinion on the music and songwriting is irrelevant), what figures would be deemed a success for U2 and a failure?
My take is this:
Success>7 million worldwide<Failure
Success>2 million USA<Failure
I think we have to take into consideration U2's age and their previous album. ATYCLB sold over 3 million (or even 4) in the USA, and something like 10 million worldwide - that's not close to Joshua Tree but it was a success considering U2's age and the musical trends during the time it was released. On the other hand, POP was a failure because it came after a huge album/tour and did not live up to the expected sales --- less than 2 million USA and 6-7 million worldwide.
I think at this late in the ballgame in U2's career, 2 million USA and 7 million worldwide would be considered a successful album. Anything less would be a dud and anything much much more would be a bonus. I don't expect the new album to reach ATYCLB heights, that would surely be hard to top for a band that age.
I really hope they can also have a hit single like Beautiful Day was, in that it got the airplay and MTV rotation which Electrical Storm failed miserable in.
What do you guys think are the sales figures that are needed to declare the new album a dud or a success?
Cheers,
J
My take is this:
Success>7 million worldwide<Failure
Success>2 million USA<Failure
I think we have to take into consideration U2's age and their previous album. ATYCLB sold over 3 million (or even 4) in the USA, and something like 10 million worldwide - that's not close to Joshua Tree but it was a success considering U2's age and the musical trends during the time it was released. On the other hand, POP was a failure because it came after a huge album/tour and did not live up to the expected sales --- less than 2 million USA and 6-7 million worldwide.
I think at this late in the ballgame in U2's career, 2 million USA and 7 million worldwide would be considered a successful album. Anything less would be a dud and anything much much more would be a bonus. I don't expect the new album to reach ATYCLB heights, that would surely be hard to top for a band that age.
I really hope they can also have a hit single like Beautiful Day was, in that it got the airplay and MTV rotation which Electrical Storm failed miserable in.
What do you guys think are the sales figures that are needed to declare the new album a dud or a success?
Cheers,
J