Bomb v Stadium arcadium

[vaz02]

Can we compare weekly sales of RHCP stadium arcadium to u2's bomb ?

i think Sa be this years biggest seller.

[STING2]

Originally posted by vaz02
Can we compare weekly sales of RHCP stadium arcadium to u2's bomb ?

i think Sa be this years biggest seller.

BOMB sold nearly 2 million copies in its first week and over 800,000 copies of that were from the United States. RHCP looks set to sell less than half those numbers. I don't think stadium arcadium will be this years biggest seller, and I doubt it will sell in numbers that would make it competitive with BOMB.

[ybird3k]

both 200k + in UK 1st week
but US U2 850000, RHCP set to sell 400k.
and i always thought they were bigger in the US than the UK.

P.S. the new RHCP single IMO is nothing special, and yet again similar to all their others. it's certainly no Vertigo

[blueyedpoet]

When I was living in London I found, per capita, more RHCP fans than in the US. Their mid-tempo songs register more sonically and lyrically in the UK. I think it has something to do with the weather =)
Since it's a double album, do they get credit for 2 album sales each purchase?

[STING2]

Originally posted by blueyedpoet
When I was living in London I found, per capita, more RHCP fans than in the US. Their mid-tempo songs register more sonically and lyrically in the UK. I think it has something to do with the weather =)
Since it's a double album, do they get credit for 2 album sales each purchase?

When RIAA certifies the album, they will get the credit for the second disk, but its not a reflection of the number of people who have actually bought the album. That is why the IFPI in Europe and other certifying organizations do not count both disc in the package.

[STING2]

Here in the United States, only 3 RHCP shows have soldout on the new tour in arena's. Canada has soldout most of theirs but not all. I'd say Coldplay is definitely the more popular band worldwide based on album sales and ticket sales currently.

[bsp77]

RHCP certainly compete with U2 in terms of radio airplay - often surpassing U2 in the US. They are definitely one of the biggest rock radio acts today, with everything they release shooting up the charts. However, they have never been able to compete with U2 in terms of album sales or tours.

The first week sales for this album (about 450K) are huge for them. If they can keep spitting out singles as popular as Dani California, the album could potentially outsell HTDAAB in the US. Not predicting it to happen but it is certainly possible considering the rumors of them releasing 7 singles.

[MJDangerous]

Originally posted by ybird3k
both 200k + in UK 1st week
but US U2 850000, RHCP set to sell 400k.
and i always thought they were bigger in the US than the UK.

P.S. the new RHCP single IMO is nothing special, and yet again similar to all their others. it's certainly no Vertigo

The Bomb has outsold easily SA in USA, but Stadium Arcadium sold more in other countries than the Bomb, it sold for example 139000 copies in Japan and 120000 in Italia.
They are also #1 in Germany, Switzerland, France (39k), Netherland, Canada (64k) and a lot more places.

It will not at all sold as well as the Bomb in his first week thought.

The biggest selling album of the year will certainly be "Back To Bedlam" and not Stadium Arcadium.

PS : Yeah "Dani California" is a real disapointment, but the album is very consistant yet with many good songs, DC is a bad choice of single.

[edge3]

Bomb vrs S.A 1st week sales so far...

Bomb
USA : 842,930
UK : 200,863
Japan : 84,000
Germany : 130,000
France : 90,000
Italy : ? (350k in 1st few wks)
Canada : 95,000
Australia : 48,000
Total = 2,000,000 (incl. Jap, 1.854m at MediaTraffic)

Stadium Arcadium
USA : 443,088
UK : 202,499
Japan : 139,000
Germany : ?
France : 39,000
Italy : 120,000 (really ?)
Canada : 64,000
Australia : ?
Total = ? (i reckon about 1.4m)

S.A has the disadvantage of being a double album (so costs more) & being released in the middle of the year (when album sales are lower). Still, i very much doubt it could do 2m...1.5m at most.

ps - U2 win again with total sales for their previous 2 albums (28m to 23m) though Best Of 80-90 perhaps has the advantage, over Californication, of being just that (a Best Of collection) :

ATYCLB : 12,000,000 (1.1m UK, 4.2m US)
By The Way : 8,000,000 (1.9m UK, 1.9m US)

Best Of 80-90 (both versions) : 16,000,000 (1.8m UK, 4.2m US)
Californication : 15,000,000 (1.1m UK, 5.2m US)

[MJDangerous]

Originally posted by edge3
Bomb Stadium Arcadium
Italy : ? (350k in 1st few wks) 120,000 (really ?) [/B]

Californication sold 1 million copies in Italia.

[edge3]

Originally posted by MJDangerous

Californication sold 1 million copies in Italia.

I heard 700k... anyway i think BTW's only done 300k so 120k seems v.high (esp. with just 39k in France).

[Needle_Chill]

I think Dani California is an awesome song. Not the most original song in the world (neither was Vertigo), but it's a rocker, it's catchy, and the video is fun. I think a straightforward song like DC is perfect to get the RHCP on the radio right off the bat, and therefore on people's minds. This will pave the way for the wide variety of potential, and perhaps more ambitious single material on the album.

I'm not going to give an opinion on which album is better, cause I know this is a sales comparison thread.

[MJDangerous]

Originally posted by edge3


I heard 700k... anyway i think BTW's only done 300k so 120k seems v.high (esp. with just 39k in France).

Red Hot Chili Peppers are not so huge in France. Surprisingly SA is only their first #1 here and Californication sold half in France than in Italia.

700k sales figure was the sales of the album Californication in Italia during the 18 first months only as well as 300k sales figure of BTW concern only the 6 first months.

[STING2]

Originally posted by bsp77
RHCP certainly compete with U2 in terms of radio airplay - often surpassing U2 in the US. They are definitely one of the biggest rock radio acts today, with everything they release shooting up the charts. However, they have never been able to compete with U2 in terms of album sales or tours.

The first week sales for this album (about 450K) are huge for them. If they can keep spitting out singles as popular as Dani California, the album could potentially outsell HTDAAB in the US. Not predicting it to happen but it is certainly possible considering the rumors of them releasing 7 singles.

Radio Airplay means nothing if it does not translate into large sales. Radio Airplay is determined by many factors other than just what the population wants to hear on the radio. Sales of tickets and albums though are determined totally by the choices of the population. That is what really counts and determines popularity.

They may have a shot at outselling the BOMB in the United States, but I doubt they will be able to equal it worldwide. Whats more, RHCP are a veteran group with 9 studio albums and career that goes back to 1983, but their current Arena tour in the USA has only soldout 3 shows at ticket prices that are half of U2's. I thought demand to see them live at this point would be a lot higher.

[vaz02]

Originally posted by STING2
Here in the United States, only 3 RHCP shows have soldout on the new tour in arena's. Canada has soldout most of theirs but not all. I'd say Coldplay is definitely the more popular band worldwide based on album sales and ticket sales currently.

i wouldnt say ticket sales though. im sure coldplay would never be able to complete a sell out tour even if they go on for 20 years.

btw how many shows are RHCP playing to this year and how will that rate against some of the other tours this year. In the Uk they seem to be playing at a couple of medium sized stadiums.

[STING2]

Originally posted by vaz02


i wouldnt say ticket sales though. im sure coldplay would never be able to complete a sell out tour even if they go on for 20 years.

btw how many shows are RHCP playing to this year and how will that rate against some of the other tours this year. In the Uk they seem to be playing at a couple of medium sized stadiums.

Coldplay soldout several medium sized stadium shows in the UK last year, and Coldplay did sellout several shows on their tour of large amphitheaters in North America in 2005, and their return dates in January and February in Arena's. The average ticket price on their arena shows in January and February is equal to what RHCP are charging for their new arena tour. At best, it appears that the RHCP are only equal to Coldplay in selling tickets, at least in North America. If RHCP can't sellout some of these shows in large cities eventually, then Coldplay is definitely ahead of them in this area.

U2 soldout "multiple" arena shows in the same city on the Unforgettable Fire tour. The RHCP 20 years later are struggling to sellout "single" Arena shows in large cities.

I find it surprising that the current number of arena shows in the United States did not sellout, even in most large cities. Most cities only have one show. Many of these shows may eventually sellout, depending on whether or not the Chili Peppers attempt to sell seats behind the stage.

[edge3]

Looking at album & single sales alone Chili Peppers are way bigger in UK than US since Californication (BTW's sold the same, 1.9m = to 6xPlat in UK, Greatest Hits more).

[edge3]

Originally posted by MJDangerous


700k sales figure was the sales of the album Californication in Italia during the 18 first months only as well as 300k sales figure of BTW concern only the 6 first months.

350k in ' 99 for Calif. + another 350k in ' 00... it's still 7xPlat (= 700k)...1m is now poss i s'pose (in UK it was still certified 1xPlat with sales of 900k+ for a long time)...

BTW did 150k in ' 03...it's still 3xPlat (= 300k) though i guess it too could now be well above that (450-500k)...

Right now @UKMIX 120k does indeed seem to be the 1st week Italy figure - impressive. I'm sure Bomb must have done a similar amount though.

[edge3]

Originally posted by edge3


ps - U2 win again with total sales for their previous 2 albums (28m to 23m) though Best Of 80-90 perhaps has the advantage, over Californication, of being just that (a Best Of collection) :

ATYCLB : 12,000,000 (1.1m UK, 4.2m US)
By The Way : 8,000,000 (1.9m UK, 1.9m US)

Best Of 80-90 (both versions) : 16,000,000 (1.8m UK, 4.2m US)
Californication : 15,000,000 (1.1m UK, 5.2m US)

I actually forgot about Best Of 90-00 & Greatest Hits...well i'd put them both on about 5m :

Best Of 90-00 : 5m (3.063m MediaTraffic, 2m IFPI Europe, 1m US, 850k UK, definitely shipped over 6m - most likely about 6.3m)
Greatest Hits : 5m (3.631m MediaTraffic, 2m IFPI Europe, still certified Gold for 500k in US, 1m UK)

[ChargedVT]

the 120k for Italy, could that be the amount SHIPPED? Because 120k in a market the size of Italy would be staggering.