I guess I'll share my updated custom LIB after exploring the Super Deluxe on Spotify.
There are multiple approaches one can take to this - you can try to make a version of the album that is most true to the original spirit and intent of the sessions, or you can try to make a version of the album that is simply the way you most want to listen to it. I know Laz's custom version attempts the former. I've gone back and forth, but ultimately I try to find a balance between the two. The Spector stuff never, ever bothered me the way it bothered others, and too much of the Naked album feels sterile and overproduced(in its own way) to me. So the Glyn Johns mixes are a great substitute to use in place of the Naked versions. So without further ado:
Side A
1. Get Back(Album Version)
There are a number of songs on the album that never had much if any Spectorization on them and thus never needed to be stripped down or fixed at all. This is one of them. I love it as an opener, so much energy.
2. I've Got A Feeling(Album Version)
Ditto the above.
3. One After 909(Album Version)
Ditto the above. This is the song on LIB I've liked least over the years, and I've never had it in my custom versions before, but it's growing on me as I listen to the Super Deluxe version, so I'm putting back here. There's a pattern of the 'rockier' songs being on Side A.
4. Dig A Pony(Glyn Johns Version)
I don't feel that strongly about which version to use, but I do think the guitar solo sounds a little cleaner in this one vs the album version.
5. I Me Mine(Album Version)
Glyn Johns Version is much shorter, and I like the way the guitar is mixed here better than the Naked version.
6. Let It Be(Album Version)
We've had this debate before, but I have always preferred the 'big' guitar solo in the album version, and I like George having that moment to shine on an album where he doesn't have a big presence. Every other version - Single, Naked, Glyn Johns - has the more subdued solo. I know a number of you disagree with this, and I know it's like an 80s power ballad lighter waving solo, but I love it.
The song itself is an epic way to close out Side A.
Side B
7. Two Of Us(Album Version or Glyn Johns Version)
This is the opener on the original album and I think it does a great job opening either side. Either version is fine, but I do think the dual vocals between McCartney and Lennon or more clearly audible on the Glyn Johns version, whereas there's other instrumentation drowning the harmony out a little on the album version.
8. For You Blue(Album Version)
Another one of those that never needed to be fixed. Not much difference between this and the Glyn Johns version, but this one is a bit cleaner.
9. Dig It(Glyn Johns long version)
I'd never heard this until this new set came out, but I like it, even if it does a go on a bit too long. I'd never bothered including the short version on any of my custom versions, but I'm putting it here.
10. Don't Let Me Down(Glyn Johns Single EP Version)
So, last week I said something a guitar solo being here that wasn't on any other version - I was wrong about that. I misheard it, and I forgot about the studio chatter adding length. My bad. This is still the best sounding version of it I've heard, as it's a 2021 mix. It's got studio chatter at the beginning, which makes it sound more like a part of the album, the sound and mixing is fantastic, but the studio chatter that's at the end of the original Glyn Johns version is removed, which makes it segue better into...
11. The Long And Winding Road(Glyn Johns Version)
Once again, we reach perhaps the most polarizing of all Beatles topics.
There's a bunch of different versions, but I think there's actually just two versions.
There's the Glyn Johns version, which sounds to me exactly like the take captured in the Anthology 3 version, which in turn, I think, is the same take that made the final album(with Spector's stuff added to it).
Then there's the Naked version, and this 'Take 19' version that you guys are singing the praises of, sounds nearly identical to the Naked version to my ears, though the Naked version is more polished up.
I always liked the Spectorization of TLAWR, but Spector aside, I still prefer that take - the Johns/Anthology/Album take - by a lot. I always though it was one of McCartney's greatest vocals ever, and I just think it's a better vocal performance than what's in the Take 19/Naked take. Especially at the end. On the Johns/Anthology/Album take, the last 'lead me to your door' ends on what sounds to me like a major note, followed by that soft 'yeah yeah yeah yeah'; on the Take 19/Naked take, 'your door' ends on what sounds to me like a minor note, and there is no 'yeah yeah yeah yeah'.
I know this seems pedantic, but I'm just trying explain why I so strongly have a preference here. Additionally, the toy-sounding piano interlude towards the end of the Naked version is there in Take 19 as well, and I just never cared for it.
Anyway, the song itself is the epic show-stopping conclusion, and this is the only place I could ever put it.
Moving on.
12. Across The Universe(Glyn Johns version)
There are now four versions of this.
A. The Album version, which is Spectorized.
B. The Wildlife/Past Masters version, which has the most involved backing vocals of any version.
C. The Naked version
D. This version
The Naked version is almost too naked. I like both the album version and the Past Masters version a lot, but I think the Glyn Johns version fits my 'balance' approach best for right now. I'm really enjoying the tambura or sitar or whatever it is that's so prominent in this mix.
It's a gorgeous song and acts as the sort of encore after the big climax.
Last thing - a word about Old Brown Shoe and The Ballad Of John And Yoko.
I had them in some previous versions of my LIB, but my decision to add One After 909 and the long version of Dig It this time, combined with the fact that those songs weren't recorded during the Get Back sessions, have led me to remove them.
The initial Get Back sessions were in January of 1969. Wikipedia says that Abbey Road was recorded from 22 February to 20 August 1969, and that Old Brown Shoe and Ballad were recorded on 16/18 April 1969 and 14 April 1969 respectively. This, along with the fact that demos of the two songs were included on the Abbey Road Super Deluxe, have led me to conclude that they should go there, if anywhere, even if they sound more like LIB. An Abbey Road running order I'm experimenting with that fits them in reasonably well is
1. Come Together
2. Something
3. Maxwell's Silver Hammer
4. Oh Darling
5. Old Brown Shoe
6. Octopus's Garden
7. I Want You
8. The Ballad Of John And Yoko
9. Here Comes The Sun
10. Because
(album order from there onwards)
I don't know. AR is the hardest Beatles album to mess with but this is probably the way to do it that screws with the flow the least.