The performance was mediocre and uninspired, but I don't think it's worth running off a cliff over, en masse.
Perhaps it's because I went in with low expectations, but U2 fucking up their hits is nothing new whatsoever. It was an off night that they'll recover from. I hope the fans can do the same (and, believe me, they will) because it's really no big deal. There's no revealing lack of relevance to ascribe to the venue being half full or Bono forgetting the outro of Beautiful Day.
I watched at least half of the I+E tour either in person or through periscope. I've followed the news and heard the crappy song with Kygo that everyone was clamoring for. I've seen the band at their lowest (SOI release week IMO). This is just another day in the life of a band that should either hang it up or carry on making music they believe in and drastically reconsider the way they approach their promotion and release schedules.
It's not pretty right now, not for the fans and not for the band. But consider the stakes. They aren't the biggest band in the world and never will be again. The average twenty-something consumer comes to see Drake and goes home when U2 hits the stage. But...they're still the respected headliner. They still have the ear of the people if only through the legacy they crafted and I hope that they take advantage of that. It's a damn shame that they played a poor show tonight because there were probably some people on the fence at this show that came away unimpressed. There's a whole generation of new listeners that are being exposed to U2 at their worst because they are - creatively and performance-wise - freezing in the spotlight.
Maybe I'm being overly optimistic but I think that, absent commercial expectations, U2 is still capable of putting out intriguing music. They certainly can still kill it onstage. Fans jumping ship now in light of the band's present (ill-advised) choices may, perhaps, miss out on an exciting late-career chapter for the band. But it's going to take a total paradigm shift in the way they approach the studio and their interactions with the public. As such, off nights like tonight don't really mean anything from U2's perspective. It's just another bump on a shitty road they picked.
Nonetheless, it does make me sad to see dejected, long-suffering fans throw their hands up in the air. I feel for them. I felt the same way they do now during the Vertigo era and that awful U218 period, but I stuck around and got some songs I loved in return. I think we all reach a point with our favorite bands where our expectations change and we accept the good while mostly tuning out the bad. Musicians are as flawed as the rest of us and while we joke about how unnervingly obsessive the posters in the Other Place are, they are fellow humans that simply have too many of their eggs in one basket.
Roll on, Dreamforce. Hopefully it's a lot better.