LemonMelon
More 5G Than Man
Evermore is fine. It doesn't reinvent the wheel, and there's nothing in it I haven't heard a hundred times before, but Taylor brought some of her better songwriting to the table. I like it slightly more than Folklore but less than Fearless, Speak Now or Red. Indie-courting Taylor is not as interesting to me as country Taylor.
Planet Her is a hot mess with a handful of highlights. Kiss Me More is great, of course.
The Bieber album is slightly better than the last one but is still incredibly weak. He samples an MLK speech on it and it comes off about as well as one would expect.
Happier Than Ever is either my second or third favorite in the group; it has an interesting narrative throughline and good production. Still, the highlights aren't that high. It's a nice album but I think she's capable of more.
Montero is a modern pop product with a unique point of view to carry it. Some songs are inspired, many are filler. I didn't dislike it but nothing blew me away and sometimes it felt like he was going through the motions to pad the album. Probably worth a listen if you want to catch up on what radio pop sounds like in 2021 but it's slightly disappointing.
Sour is a worthy AOTY pick because of its impact but I don't enjoy it all the way through. It gets redundant because Olivia has nothing to say about her breakup that couldn't be said in 3 songs but I like her voice and the highlights are excellent. It's a quality work of creative expression that happened to catch on with the public. That's a great thing. But it would have been better as an EP.
Didn't listen to HER, Gaga/Bennett or Jon Batiste. Do not care at all.
So that leaves Donda, which for me is by far the most raw, insightful and interesting work that I've heard from this group of albums. The level of talent involved is off the charts with excellent features that bring the best out of everyone involved a la MBDTF. There's an impressive level of polish to the production, though the listener is really required to craft their own sequencing in order to bring the polish out of the whole experience. I have my own personal version of the album that I absolutely love.
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4...i=h4AuIWeMTqesY5q2U9HoBQ&utm_source=copy-link
Kanye is one of the only truly mainstream artists putting their entire life, external and internal, into their music in such a transparent way. Never Abandon Your Family? Come to Life? Hurricane? Moon? Life of the Party? Heartbreaking. Andre 3000 has the best verse I've heard all year. Fivio on Off the Grid is not far behind. And Kanye himself on Come to Life is about as good as I've ever heard him.
Not that any of this matters to the public because he's persona non grata at this point, but as someone who loves music, particularly music that reveals something new about an artist in a creative way, Donda is really something special and worth the time. It's a shame that the troll tactics were brought out to sell the record because it's super heartfelt and inoffensive outside of one track that didn't need to be on there anyway and isn't on my tracklisting.
Rating what I've heard:
Donda 8.5
Evermore 7.5
Happier Than Ever 7.5
Sour 6
Montero 6
Planet Her 5
Justice 4.5
Planet Her is a hot mess with a handful of highlights. Kiss Me More is great, of course.
The Bieber album is slightly better than the last one but is still incredibly weak. He samples an MLK speech on it and it comes off about as well as one would expect.
Happier Than Ever is either my second or third favorite in the group; it has an interesting narrative throughline and good production. Still, the highlights aren't that high. It's a nice album but I think she's capable of more.
Montero is a modern pop product with a unique point of view to carry it. Some songs are inspired, many are filler. I didn't dislike it but nothing blew me away and sometimes it felt like he was going through the motions to pad the album. Probably worth a listen if you want to catch up on what radio pop sounds like in 2021 but it's slightly disappointing.
Sour is a worthy AOTY pick because of its impact but I don't enjoy it all the way through. It gets redundant because Olivia has nothing to say about her breakup that couldn't be said in 3 songs but I like her voice and the highlights are excellent. It's a quality work of creative expression that happened to catch on with the public. That's a great thing. But it would have been better as an EP.
Didn't listen to HER, Gaga/Bennett or Jon Batiste. Do not care at all.
So that leaves Donda, which for me is by far the most raw, insightful and interesting work that I've heard from this group of albums. The level of talent involved is off the charts with excellent features that bring the best out of everyone involved a la MBDTF. There's an impressive level of polish to the production, though the listener is really required to craft their own sequencing in order to bring the polish out of the whole experience. I have my own personal version of the album that I absolutely love.
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4...i=h4AuIWeMTqesY5q2U9HoBQ&utm_source=copy-link
Kanye is one of the only truly mainstream artists putting their entire life, external and internal, into their music in such a transparent way. Never Abandon Your Family? Come to Life? Hurricane? Moon? Life of the Party? Heartbreaking. Andre 3000 has the best verse I've heard all year. Fivio on Off the Grid is not far behind. And Kanye himself on Come to Life is about as good as I've ever heard him.
Not that any of this matters to the public because he's persona non grata at this point, but as someone who loves music, particularly music that reveals something new about an artist in a creative way, Donda is really something special and worth the time. It's a shame that the troll tactics were brought out to sell the record because it's super heartfelt and inoffensive outside of one track that didn't need to be on there anyway and isn't on my tracklisting.
Rating what I've heard:
Donda 8.5
Evermore 7.5
Happier Than Ever 7.5
Sour 6
Montero 6
Planet Her 5
Justice 4.5
Last edited: