My thoughts:
i) Corporations are not people. However, I fail to understand why a group of people organizing themselves as a corporation would collectively lose first amendment protection in doing so. And all that this decision applies to is corporations held closely enough to enable their owners' religious beliefs to be easily ascertained.
One may argue that businesses of any form, including sole proprietorships, should be required to provide contraceptive coverage, to their full time employees. Perhaps that is true, but then the line here should be either "people's free religious rights can be curtailed at the point when they try to make money from business ownership" or "requiring a person to pay for medical treatment against which he or she has religious objections is not a violation of religious freedom".
ii) On the surface, the scope of this decision seems to be narrow to nearly the point of uselessness. It covers only closely-held companies, and only salaried employees thereof, and only four types of contraception (somewhat absurdly, as some have pointed out), and Kennedy's concurrence opened the door for insurers to still be required to cover the contraception without the companies paying (on the government's dime, I think, but I'm not sure).
However, I don't understand how the majority is claiming to not be setting precedent for other religious objections. It seems like either this is a precedent, opening up the door for all that Ginsberg brought up, or it's a first amendment violation insofar as it protects some absurd beliefs by evangelical Christians and not much else.
iii) My libertarian instincts, which I can't decide if I like or not, think that all companies should be free to set whatever terms of labor they see fit (and, likewise, employees should be able to seek out whatever employers they see fit). However, it's difficult to apply those to such a rabidly un-libertarian industry as healthcare.
iv) I wonder if the Democratic Party paid Kennedy off to vote as he did, because this is absolute fundraising gold for them.
Sent from my iPhone using U2 Interference