Biological sex and gender identity: differences and overlaps

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
But I think the way this argument always sticks on sports quietly outlines what's really at stake in these arguments: the high value placed on masculine-coded values like competition, toughness, raw physical power, the domination of ranking winners and losers, and hierarchy within and between genders that it creates. Sport is the church in which we worship these values, and gender trangression is a fundamental blasphemy of them.

I see truth in this, but what consequences does this attitude have for your perspective on women's sports in general? Is there value in women working in the framework of masculine aggression if, as I infer from your post, the value system of athletics is damaging in some sense to larger society?
 
I don't have a problem with sports per se or with gender separation in sports. But I think that our society has accepted competition and the resultant rankings as inherently good things, as values of their own, and that I don't agree with. Competition can provide some good some times, but it's not inherently good. It's just one way of human relating. Partnership and collaboration are models of relationship that don't receive the same structural support and praise even though we quietly depend on them much, much more. I think our preoccupation with competition reveals how much our society is organized around what Rhiane Eisler calls the model of domination, as opposed to that one she calls a partnership model.

And really, that's what the biggest thing about cultural conservatism is, the deep conviction that someone needs to be in charge; there has to be an order of importance and we all have to know what it is, or else chaos will ensue. I know that we've relied on that model of social organization for thousands of years, but I think it's pretty unimaginative and stultifying to human beings. I think we can do better.
 
Interesting, but it doesn't really answer my question. If women are partaking in a social institution built on masculine aggression (and that I grant you, as sports developed essentially as war games), does that serve to tear down gender distinctions or reinforce them?
 
I think it can do both. It's important to realize that since gender is a social construct, activities and qualities are coded masculine and feminine rather than being inherently one or the other. So competitiveness is no more inherently related to males than empathy is to females--and studies show than men and women are in fact equally empathetic.

Sports, like most things, can cut both ways. We in the west often associate strength, sweat, competition, toughness, stamina and vigorous physical exertion with masculinity. Allowing women to these qualities definitely expands our understanding of gender and weakens the binary. On the other hand, when we say that the only way to be successful at anything is to do it in the masculine way, we reinforce the binary. For example many coaches have found that girls thrive under different coaching techniques than boys do, likely because of the way boys and girls are socialized differently. So if even within a given sport if we praise and prioritize 'masculine' ways of doing and achieving (even when these masculine forms are expressed by women) then we reinforce the binary.

For example, think of the way we think of women's hockey vs regular men's "real" hockey. Should women be allowed to get out the skates and whoop it up? Most of us would say sure. But is women's hockey "real" hockey if it doesn't include checking? Is it inherently boring and inferior if it's not as intentional about hurting people? Is it the soft lady kind, or does it emphasize a different skill set? Would women players prefer to check if they could, and what would that mean to them? How do male players feel about the violence encoded in the sport? If little boys have to be trained to be aggressive on the ice (and they do) and if adult men have to suppress their own fear of violence on the ice (and they do) then is how the aggression of the sport more appropriate to men than women? You can see the fluidity here. Gender expression, coding and policing shift all the time. That's why within academics gender expression is commonly referred to as a "performance": because we have a script but we're always revising and improvising.
 
Dammit. You're right. You equated fascism and socialism.

http://www.u2interference.com/forums/f199/socialism-fascism-200375-2.html#post6324720


And I posted my original post before I had a Pacifico with my carne asada tacos and guacamole.

I didn't, Mussolini did. But feel free to start a thread on the totalitarian nature of the Left.

6435522_f260.jpg
 
People like INDY are a big reason why suicide attempt rates among young trans people (perhaps the figure isn't all that different in older trans people) are at 45-50%.

Russia has second worst suicide rate in the world | SOCIETY | The Moscow News

Russia has second worst suicide rate in the world

The Serbsky State Research Center for Social and Forensic Psychology announced that Russia reached second place in the world in suicide rates, behind only Lithuania.
Psychologists are worried about death rate that emerged in the last 20 years and say that only decisive measures by the state can help limit the number of suicides.
Almost a million in 20 years
The data suggest that “in the years between 1990 and 2010 about 800,000 Russians killed themselves, which is close to a million – a whole city,” head of epidemiology and social problems of psychological health Boris Polozhy was quoted as saying by Interfax.

And people like Vlad are the reason for the suicides in Mother Russia?

Of course not. Not only does my philosophy recognize inherent biological sex as true human nature but also the dichotomous flesh/spiritual nature of man. The latter which gives us, ALL OF US, freewill.

Vlad of course must reject that.
 
You know, at a certain point this starts to look like trolling, Indy.

Who dragged Nazis into this? Who is blaming others for suicides? Or for lacking empathy and compassion for that matter Dieman?

It would be nice if we could argue ideas without questioning the motives and character of each other.
 
Of course not. Not only does my philosophy recognize inherent biological sex as true human nature but also the dichotomous flesh/spiritual nature of man. The latter which gives us, ALL OF US, freewill.



what are you even talking about? what kind of nonsense pseudointellectual know-nothing crap is this?
 
For the record, I totally reject the flesh/spirit dichotomy. Also for the record, free will is not dependent on that dogma at all.
 
I can't believe Islam is listed under the left, but not Christianity...both would be theocracies. Shows you how biased and wrong this chart is.
 
I didn't, Mussolini did. But feel free to start a thread on the totalitarian nature of the Left.

6435522_f260.jpg

I've defended you somewhat on a couple of occasions. But when you post crap like this you look like a complete moron. Anyone with even an extremely basic knowledge of political ideology sees through it in half a second.

Unless you're trying to be funny, which proves my theory that right-wing people are inherently incapable of being funny.
 
Russia has second worst suicide rate in the world | SOCIETY | The Moscow News



And people like Vlad are the reason for the suicides in Mother Russia?

Of course not. Not only does my philosophy recognize inherent biological sex as true human nature but also the dichotomous flesh/spiritual nature of man. The latter which gives us, ALL OF US, freewill.

Vlad of course must reject that.

Eh what exactly does this have to do with the rate of suicides amongst young trans kids in the US?
 
What I find baffling about INDY's post is that I'm not from Russia, I have never set foot inside Russian borders and have never claimed to support the Russian government. That post had no point. :laugh:

But I'm just going to safely assume he's trolling here.
 
I just don't get the comparison... I mean, your post was on the consequences of the mental pressure on transgender teenagers, whom already suffer from a lot of peer pressure already and are likely bullied... what does that have to do with the amount of suicides in a country like Russia? Of which a lot are probably stupidity suicides due to badly homemade vodka, but that's a whole other case. As far as I can see it, the two things simply have nothing to do with each other? :scratch:
 
A bit of salty jibe given I come from that region and speak the language, with the assumption that I don't recognise the vast problems facing Russia (and Eastern Europe as an extension) today? Otherwise, I really have no clue. :shrug: It's not worth getting off topic for though.
 
A bit of salty jibe given I come from that region and speak the language, with the assumption that I don't recognise the vast problems facing Russia (and Eastern Europe as an extension) today? Otherwise, I really have no clue. :shrug: It's not worth getting off topic for though.
I think what he was trying to say was that if you're not going to blame yourself for the problems in Russia, then he shouldn't have to blame himself for the problems facing trans* youths.
 
I just don't get the comparison... I mean, your post was on the consequences of the mental pressure on transgender teenagers, whom already suffer from a lot of peer pressure already and are likely bullied... what does that have to do with the amount of suicides in a country like Russia? Of which a lot are probably stupidity suicides due to badly homemade vodka, but that's a whole other case. As far as I can see it, the two things simply have nothing to do with each other? :scratch:

Vlad wants to blame others (folks like me) for the suicides of gender questioning youths. I'm no more the cause of their suicides than Vlad is of Russian suicides. Shame that the absurdity of both is lost to FYM.
 
Vlad wants to blame others (folks like me) for the suicides of gender questioning youths. I'm no more the cause of their suicides than Vlad is of Russian suicides. Shame that the absurdity of both is lost to FYM.



Yes you are.

You support politicians who actively work to destroy anyone in the LGBT community.

You are absolutely part of the problem.
 
Just for the record guys, I would like to confirm that I haven't lead any Russians to attempt suicide.
 
Vlad wants to blame others (folks like me) for the suicides of gender questioning youths. I'm no more the cause of their suicides than Vlad is of Russian suicides. Shame that the absurdity of both is lost to FYM.

Actually, there is little absurdity in the first case. The main reason most LGBT youth kill themselves is because they cannot accept themselves, or others cannot accept them. And it's mainly the latter. So by keeping your views alive and supporting politicians who openly hate on LGBT people, yes, you do in fact contribute to them wanting to kill themselves. tolerance is all we're looking for here, rather than hatred and lack of understanding. Didn't you say something about compassion earlier?
 
Actually, there is little absurdity in the first case. The main reason most LGBT youth kill themselves is because they cannot accept themselves, or others cannot accept them. And it's mainly the latter. So by keeping your views alive and supporting politicians who openly hate on LGBT people, yes, you do in fact contribute to them wanting to kill themselves. tolerance is all we're looking for here, rather than hatred and lack of understanding. Didn't you say something about compassion earlier?

Sorry but that's BS. Suicide is always a tragedy but always a choice, an act of selfishness and cowardice that leaves those behind feeling guilty and feeling helpless and to to blame.

Am I equally at blame for the suicide rate among the chronically depressed and unhappy because I'm one happy SOB?

Humans have freewill. They have an intellect in which to overcome their genes, environment or emotions. But I know, it's mean to think people are ultimately responsible for their actions.

Off topic. All I have to say about that.
 
Back
Top Bottom