Best and Worst SOE vs. Best and Worst SOI

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

BANZAI

War Child
Joined
Dec 8, 2004
Messages
575
BATTLE OF THE BEST

The little things that give you away vs. Every breaking wave
Landlady vs. Iris
Love is bigger than anything in its way vs. The troubles

... SOE wins...


BATTLE OF THE WORST (which song is the best?)

Get out of your own way vs. Volcano
You're the best thing about me vs. California
American soul vs. The miracle

... SOI wins...


Conclusion: SOE has stronger highs and lows than SOI (in my opinion of course).
 
BATTLE OF THE BEST

The little things that give you away vs. Every breaking wave
Landlady vs. Iris
Love is bigger than anything in its way vs. The troubles

... SOE wins...


BATTLE OF THE WORST (which song is the best?)

Get out of your own way vs. Volcano
You're the best thing about me vs. California
American soul vs. The miracle

... SOI wins...


Conclusion: SOE has stronger highs and lows than SOI (in my opinion of course).

<shrug>

To each his/her own.

My "best" and 'worst" would be different than yours.

But even looking at what you've posted, I'd reverse them. I just think the songs on SOI were better down the line and overall.

Well, maybe I'd put AS above Miracle. Hard to say, that clunky "you are rock-n-roll" being belted over and over again bogs the song down. Too bad.

(Loved Volcano though)
 
American Soul vs. Volcano is a more logical matchup since they share the same riff, and I'll take AS in a landslide. Volcano just sounds like a thin early mix by comparison.
 
Back
Top Bottom