Why do you think this takes giant balls??? It's a cool lyric and a great way to end the album, but balls?
Because on first appraisal, it sounds pretty depressing! Like he's ending the album on a major downer or bum note. Which runs contrary to U2's characteristic mood of uplift. I'm glad you think it's a great way to end the album, cuz that's an enlightened view. It most certainly wasn't my
initial reaction.
My very initial reaction was "Ugh, depressing"! I then realized he was really saying something meaningful, and being real and honest. But to close out the whole album, an important album, with those lines, and vere that far from U2’s characteristic mood, did indeed take guts. It was a brave way to finish.
And my point from the last post to you was that you seem to place him on a giant pedestal.
My remark that Bono is one of the greatest lyricists ever was not made as a statement of worship (lol), but simply as a statement of fact. And it is a fact. Plain and simple, it just is. The suggestion was that Bono be assaulted in the crotch region for reading his own lyrics. I merely made the distinction between a crap lyricist reading his own lyrics, and one of the greatest ever lyricists (fact not worship
) reading his own lyrics and that, well, there's a certain amount of leeway or license there.
I also made the far more important point, which you may not have noticed, about context. I’m sure you don’t agree with taking things out of context. The reason Bono was reading those lyrics was cuz U2 wrote that song, and Bono wrote those lyrics, for BB, and with him in mind. And Bono was reading the lyrics, not to himself aloud in staggered admiration, but
to BB, as like a gift to him.