October vs Bomb vs Rattle and Hum in a deserted island

[the tourist]

Easily R&H. The studio songs by themselves blow the other two out of the water.

 

[Harley.GirlU2]

harley girl, i agree with you it is all personal opinion. i didnt say anyone should or should not like a particular album, i said it is likely that older fans would prefer R&H, but of course some of them may not.

Yeah, but it sound like we(youg people) don't know R&H at all, what is not true.
but whatever, opinions are opinions.