I wouldn't be so sure as far as GT goes. Night Ripper kicks the shit out of Feed the Animals.
BSB? Way too low. It'll be interesting to see where the other albums land.
I've said it before, I'll say it again: that filthy Ying Yang Twins song about showing your penis to the ladies over "Bittersweet Symphony" is the shit.
I think GAF will be very mad that the Arctic Monkeys debut is that low, and frankly, I was a little shocked myself.
I'm most-curious to see how they treat ...Trail of Dead's Source Tags & Codes, which received a perfect 10.0, upon its 2002 release.
Get cracking.
And by cracking I mean discussing. Not the adjective Cracking™.
Either way, I am glad to see that not everybody has forgotten about Cannibal Ox. The 150 range sounds good enough to me. Good-ass record, The Cold Vein. Anybody who wants to convince him- or herself that Pitchfork's taste in hip-hop isn't all bad would do well to check out that jittery, paranoid, cold-as-ice record. Wonderful stuff.
As far as I know, Pitchfork has only granted a perfect 10 to two initial-release albums: Yankee Hotel Foxtrot and Kid A. If Wilco - or Animal Collective for that matter - takes the top spot over Radiohead, I doubt that I will ever read Pitchfork again.
Pitchfork wasn't around in 1997?