U2 Feedback

U2 Feedback (http://www.u2interference.com/forums/)
-   Everything You Know Is Wrong Archive (http://www.u2interference.com/forums/f288/)
-   -   Crumbs from Your Table depreciation thread (http://www.u2interference.com/forums/f288/crumbs-from-your-table-depreciation-thread-161828.html)

Canadiens1131 07-09-2006 09:34 PM

Crumbs from Your Table depreciation thread
 
Listening to this song today, I was struck by the fact that it does, indeed, suck.

It's like they were trying to summon up the crappy filler vibe from the latter half of ATYCLB, except those filler songs were actually good when listened to alone.

Crumbs is also the only song in my iTunes liberry containing the word 'crumbs'.

Piece of crap.

EDIT: And that random interference/synth crap that starts panning around the song near the ending build-up - whoever decided to leave that in the mix....great job, fuckface.

vaz02 07-09-2006 09:46 PM

Its everything a love about u2 but done in the wrong way. There is some shades of great lyrical brilliance but its over produced in everyway. This song would of worked better accoustic i think.

Overall its the type of pompus music u2 produce when they wanna fill a album.

Axver 07-09-2006 09:56 PM

This thread gets a big :down:

Not only is Crumbs a great political song, but also the second-best song on HTDAAB. I don't get the criticism.

ozeeko 07-09-2006 10:08 PM

Crumbs is the only song on BOMB that I can stand! I think it's because it doesn't sound forced. They knew they had a good-to-mediocre song on their hands and instead of subjecting it to 570 rewrites until it's "single-material", they just left it as it was written.

But you do have a point about the over-production. And the lyrics range from dumb to shockingly dumb to impressively shockingly dumb.

But these are small prices to pay for (kinda) pleasant melodies.

xaviMF22 07-09-2006 10:15 PM

this song does indeed "suck"

awful lyrics, over produced=:down:

J_NP 07-09-2006 10:17 PM

Arrume uma vidha

gherman 07-09-2006 10:19 PM

:lock:

KhanadaRhodes 07-09-2006 10:28 PM

crappy song.

Quote:

Originally posted by gherman
:lock:
please stay out of this thread unless you have something to actually contribute to the discussion.

J_NP 07-09-2006 10:39 PM

ate a galerinha certinha pode chegah aq e falar besteirol , imbessil to pasmo

Axver 07-09-2006 10:46 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by J_NP
ate a galerinha certinha pode chegah aq e falar besteirol , imbessil to pasmo
Looking for somewhere? http://forum.interference.com/f215.html

cobl04 07-09-2006 10:48 PM

:grumpy::down:

Please, we get the point. Stop bashing the songs. It's getting extremely old. We've heard it all before. I can't wait for the next album to come out. After about a week, there will be a thousand 'oh, this song sucks' and 'the lyrics are so shallow' threads.

AtomicBono 07-09-2006 11:56 PM

Re: Crumbs from Your Table depreciation thread
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Canadiens1160


Crumbs is also the only song in my iTunes liberry containing the word 'crumbs'.


:lmao: good to know :wink: (same for me man...)

Crumbs... generic sounding U2 song. Unlike many people, I don't think most of HTDAAB is generic U2. But this song certainly is. Do I hate it? No, but I'm not crazy about it. The production hurts my ears to listen to. Two words: TOO. BRIGHT. It's so sharp it feels like someone is stabbing my ear with a pocket knife. Also, I think there's too many overdubs. The bare song has potential, as evidenced by the HTDAAB DVD, but all the extra parts seem unnecessary, especially since the whole point of U2's last two albums has been a "stripped down" approach.

Anyway, the solo in the song is too similar to Walk On's, and then the outro, which is the coolest sounding part, is too similar to Electrical Storm's. The lyrics are mixed. I actually like a lot of them, especially the line "then your face caught up with your psychology." Really, I don't have a beef with the lyrics, though the chorus is a little meh.

I think maybe the problem with Crumbs is if you look at its core, lyrically anyway, it's a pretty angry song. But on the album, it doesn't come across as angry at all. Instead, it makes me angry cuz it kind of sucks.

amerrydeath 07-10-2006 12:59 AM

:lol:

GibsonGirl 07-10-2006 01:08 AM

Re: Re: Crumbs from Your Table depreciation thread
 
Quote:

Originally posted by AtomicBono

I think maybe the problem with Crumbs is if you look at its core, lyrically anyway, it's a pretty angry song. But on the album, it doesn't come across as angry at all. Instead, it makes me angry cuz it kind of sucks.

Precisely! If you're going to make an angry song, make it sound angry. Music should be used to shape emotions, not just provide a backdrop. You can have the angriest lyrics in the world, but put them to something that sounds like a more-upbeat Walk On, and it'll always come across as being upbeat. It's wrong that I should feel happy when I'm listening to a song about the problems in Africa. It's not the fault of the lyrics, it's the fault of the music. U2's best songs, I feel, are the ones that incorporate both the lyrics and the music to create emotion. Exit, for instance. The lyrics are dark, the music is dark. Outcome: a dark song. Imagine the lyrics of Exit sung to the music of Trip Through Your Wires - that's what Crumbs From Your Table is like!

XHendrix24 07-10-2006 01:22 AM

Besides the production being kind of shit in places, I like the song. Sure it's kind of derivative of some of their other work, but I certainly wouldn't go out of my way to call it a bad song. It's got some pretty cool lyrics and Bono executes some of the lines really well ("you ate all your friends").

But, to stick with the spirit of the thread, the production does kind of suck, making the song hard to listen to in places. :wink:

DreamOutLoud13 07-10-2006 01:41 AM

Crumbs is the only U2 song that I really cannot stand to listen to. The lyrics aren't spectacular, but for me, they're not the main problem. I can't stand the melody. It's far too swingy, and it bothers me. Bono's voice just keeps going up and down every few seconds. I've also got to agree about the over-production.

One thing I did notice the last time I listened to it all the way through (I usually go out of my way to skip the track, but at the time, I was busy and had my hands full, so I just let it play):

You were pretty as a picture
It was all there to see
Then your face caught up with your psychology
With a mouth full of teeth
You ate all your friends
And you broke every heart thinking every heart mends


That verse reminds me of Tom Cruise :lmao: Though it was written before he flipped his lid.


In conclusion: U2 writing songs while drunk is never a good idea.

BVS 07-10-2006 01:48 AM

I don't see this as a "angry" political song. I see this as a heartbroken political song...I think there's a huge difference.

Is it a little too polished? Yes, but come on most of the post Pop songs are.

Some liked polish, some like raw...what are you going to do?

BVS 07-10-2006 01:50 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by DreamOutLoud13

In conclusion: U2 writing songs while drunk is never a good idea.

Write more songs drunk!!! Please!!!

Canadiens1131 07-10-2006 01:51 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by DreamOutLoud13

You were pretty as a picture
It was all there to see
Then your face caught up with your psychology
With a mouth full of teeth
You ate all your friends
And you broke every heart thinking every heart mends


That verse reminds me of Tom Cruise :lmao: Though it was written before he flipped his lid.

Holy crap that's hilarious :laugh:

Axver 07-10-2006 01:52 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by BonoVoxSupastar
I don't see this as a "angry" political song. I see this as a heartbroken political song...I think there's a huge difference.
Exactly! It isn't meant to be Bullet The Blue Sky.

Personally, I think the song sounds great, but I like Edge's traditional, chime-y sound. My only problem with the song is a few lyrics ("cool down mama"? "With a mouth full of teeth" - wow, what else might it have, Bono?), but some of the other lines are some of the best on the album.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:13 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Design, images and all things inclusive copyright © Interference.com