Bono is a crappy guitar player...

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
So funny watching Bono play guitar......

I leaned over to my husband during one of the concerts and said,"I'm pretty sure nobody told Bono that his guitar isn't actually plugged in..." Keep in ind-I LOVE him, but a natural at guitar, he 'aint.
 
I aint know nothing about no guitar playing, so, it's hard for me to saunter in here and comment.....but I do know that I love the song "I Fall Down" and on many live versions, Bono's guitar is prominent. Not saying it's good....just.....present.
 
A wah-wah pedal (or just wah pedal) is a type of guitar effects pedal that alters the tone of the signal to create a distinctive effect, intended to mimic the human voice. The pedal sweeps the peak response of a filter up and down in frequency to create the sound (spectral glide), also known as "the wah effect."
The first wah-wah pedal was created by Brad Plunkett at Warwick Electronics Inc./Thomas Organ Company in November 1966. This pedal is the original prototype made from a transistorized MRB (mid-range boost) potentiometer bread-boarded circuit and the housing of a Vox Continental Organ volume pedal.

The creation of the wah-wah pedal was actually an accident which stemmed from the re-design of the Vox Super Beatle guitar amplifier in 1966. Warwick Electronics Inc./Thomas Organ Company had bought the Vox name due to the brand name's popularity and association with the Beatles. Warwick Electronics Inc. also owned Thomas Organ Company and had assigned Thomas Organ Company to create a new product line called the all-electric Vox Amplifonic Orchestra, the project was headed by musician and bandleader Bill Page. While creating the Vox Amplifonic Orchestra, the Thomas Organ Company needed to re-design the Vox amplifier into a transistorized solid state amplifier, rather than tube, which would be less expensive to manufacture. During the re-design of the USA Vox amplifier, Stan Cuttler, head engineer of Thomas Organ Company, assigned Brad J. Plunkett, a junior electronics engineer, to replace the expensive Jennings 3-position MRB circuit switch with a transistorized solid state MRB circuit.

Plunkett had lifted and bread-boarded a transistorized tone-circuit from the Thomas Organ (an electric solid state transistorized organ) to duplicate the Jenning 3-position circuit. After adjusting and testing the amplifier with an electronic oscillator and oscilloscope, Plunkett connected the output to the speaker and tested the circuit audibly. At that point, several engineers and technical consultants, including Bill Page and Del Casher, noticed the sound effect caused by the circuit. Bill Page insisted on testing this bread-boarded circuit while he played his saxophone through an amplifier. John Glennon, an assistant junior electronics engineer with the Thomas Organ Company, was summoned to bring a volume control pedal which was used in the Vox Continental Organ so that the transistorized MRB potentiometer bread-boarded circuit' could be installed in the pedal's housing. After the installation, Bill Page began playing his saxophone through the pedal and had asked Joe Banaron, CEO of Warwick Electronics Inc./Thomas Organ Company to listen to the effect. At this point the first electric guitar was plugged into the prototype wah-wah pedal by guitarist Del Casher who suggested to Joe Banaron that this was a guitar effects pedal rather than a wind instrument effects pedal. Joe Banaron, being a fan of the big band style of music, was interested in marketing the wah-wah pedal for wind-instruments as suggested by Bill Page rather than the electric guitar suggested by Del Casher. After a remark by Del Casher to Joe Banaron regarding the Harmon mute style of trumpet playing in the famous recording of "Sugar Blues" from the 1930s, Joe Banaron decided to market the wah-wah pedal using Clyde McCoy's name for endorsement.

After the initial invention of the wah-wah pedal, the prototype pedal was then modified by Del Casher and Brad Plunkett to better accommodate the harmonic qualities of the electric guitar. However, since Vox had no intention of marketing the wah-wah pedal for electric guitar players, the prototype wah-wah pedal was given to Del Casher for performances at Vox press conferences and film scores for Universal Pictures. The un-modified version of the Vox wah-wah pedal was released to the public in February 1967 with an image of Clyde McCoy on the bottom of the pedal.

Warwick Electronics Inc. assigned Lester L. Kushner, an engineer with the Thomas Organ Company, and Bradley J. Plunkett to create and submit the documentation for the Wah-Wah pedal patent. The patent was submitted on February 24, 1967 which included technical diagrams of the pedal being connected to a four-stringed "guitar" (as noted from the "Description of the Preferred Embodiment"). Warwick Electronics Inc. was granted US patent 3530224 (foot-controlled continuously variable preference circuit for musical instruments) on September 22, 1970.

Early versions of the Clyde McCoy featured an image of McCoy on the bottom panel, which soon gave way to only his signature. Thomas Organ then wanted the effect branded as their own for the American market, changing it to Cry Baby which was sold in parallel to the Italian Vox V846. Thomas Organ's failure to trademark the Cry Baby name soon led to the market being flooded with Cry Baby imitations from various parts of the world, including Italy, where all of the original Vox and Cry Babys were made.[1] Jen, who had been responsible for the manufacture of Thomas Organ and Vox wah pedals also made rebranded pedals for companies such as Fender, Gretsch and under their own Jen brand. When Thomas Organ moved production completely to Sepulveda, California and Chicago, Illinois these Italian models continued to be made and are among the more collectible wah pedals today.
The variation in the peak response frequency of the filter resembles the change in formant frequency in the human vocal tract when saying the word "wah", making the wah-wah pedal a crude form of speech synthesizer. The traditional "wah wah" effect does not affect the guitar's volume, although many modern models offer a volume boost and distortion options.

The most common function of the wah-wah pedal is as a lead guitar booster. Frequently, lead lines do not cut through the mix of the band sufficiently, so some sort of effect is utilized to push the lead part to the front. A wah-wah inflected lead guitar part varies its timbre with the motion of the pedal, thus creating a distinct space within the sound of a band. Moreover, it mimics some of the sounds of human speech, which are typically picked up more readily by the human ear. Many people also find that use of the wah-wah pedal adds emotional expressiveness to single-note guitar lines, such as the solos on Cream's "White Room", Jimi Hendrix's "Voodoo Child (Slight Return)", Quicksilver Messenger Service's "The Fool", Supertramp's "Goodbye Stranger", the Guns N' Roses hit "Sweet Child o' Mine", Pearl Jam's "Alive", Jethro Tull's "We Used to Know", Metallica's "Enter Sandman", the main riff of The Doors's Peace Frog and U2's "The Fly".

An envelope filter or envelope follower is often referred to as an auto-wah or T ("triggered", by the input signal's amplitude)-wah.
Many bassists have also used the wah-wah effect, for example Michael Henderson on Miles Davis's album On the Corner (1972). Bassist Cliff Burton of Metallica used a Morley Wah pedal (along with a Big Muff Distortion) extensively, including on "(Anesthesia) Pulling Teeth", which is primarily a bass solo recorded for Kill 'Em All (1983), and "The Call of Ktulu" and "For Whom the Bell Tolls", both recorded for Ride the Lightning. Geezer Butler, bassist of Black Sabbath, used it when playing his solo "Bassically", along with the bass line in "N.I.B.". Chris Squire of Yes used a wah-wah pedal on his solo piece "The Fish" on the album Fragile.

Keyboardists have also made use of the wah-wah effect both in the studio and during live performances. Garth Hudson famously used a wah-wah pedal on a clavinet in The Band song "Up on Cripple Creek" to emulate a Jaw Harp. Rick Wright of Pink Floyd played a Wurlitzer electric piano through a wah-wah pedal in their song "Money" to give the impression of many consecutive chords being played. Jordan Rudess of Dream Theater made an extensive use of the wah wah pedal on Dream Theater's album Train of Thought.

Many jazz fusion records feature wind and brass instruments with the effect - Miles Davis's trumpet being a well-known example. Davis first used this technique in 1970 (at concerts documented on Live-Evil and The Cellar Door Sessions) at a time when he also made his keyboard players (Keith Jarrett, Chick Corea) play electric pianos with a wah-wah pedal. Napoleon Murphy Brock played a saxophone amplified through a wah-wah pedal in the Frank Zappa movie The Dub Room Special, as well as on some of Zappa's albums. David Sanborn can be heard playing an alto saxophone modified by a wah-wah pedal on the David Bowie album Young Americans. Noted saxophonist King Curtis was also known to use a wah-wah pedal. Dick Sims, the keyboard player with Eric Clapton in the late seventies, used a Hammond organ in conjunction with a wah-wah pedal, sat on top of the organ operated by his palm.

The effect is also extensively used with the electric violin. Notable examples are Jerry Goodman with the Mahavishnu Orchestra, and Jean-Luc Ponty, Don "Sugarcane" Harris and Shankar, with Frank Zappa, all usually engaged in long wah-wah violin/guitar duels. Boyd Tinsley of Dave Matthews Band is known to use a wah-wah pedal live.
 
Tyrawahwaaaah.gif
 
I aint know nothing about no guitar playing, so, it's hard for me to saunter in here and comment.....but I do know that I love the song "I Fall Down" and on many live versions, Bono's guitar is prominent. Not saying it's good....just.....present.

This. On the way to Montreal I had a 16 GB memory stick with a crapload of old shows loaded onto it. I must've heard about 11 versions of I Fall Down and for some reason it hit me again..hey, if Edge is playing the piano there...and there's guitar happening...OH! :lol:
 
There seem to be two different arguments happening concurrently: whether or not Bono's guitar is loud enough to contribute, and whether or not he's a good player.

He's not a good player, but he's not shitty. And the volume of his guitar tends to depend on the night.
 
Yup. Because the volume of his guitar is always MUCH higher in his IEMs, he usually adjusts the volume too much for people to hear over the PA. That's a shame, cause it usually sounds really good.
 
I can only assume that the people posting these videos dont play guitar themselves. Nothing anyone has posted has shown Bono to be anything other than good enough to get by. I suppose that's a step above crap, but it certainly isn't good
 
Ya, I agree. I just get the feeling that some people are giving him more credit than they should. Might just be the good old internet miscommunication though.
 
Apparently in the early days, Bono tried to impress crowds at Mount Temple in the Cafeteria by trying to play guitar. At which point the Edge noticed he couldn't play. And that's how they met...

30 years later, Bono doesn't have an extremely important role in U2 as a guitar player. He plays rythym guitar on some songs live to add depth, such as 'The Fly'. If you look at what the edge plays on guitar (the main riff) it doesn't sound right without a rythym guitar to back it up because he is playing a few notes with added distortion and wah. In order to keep the correct tone but also to add more bass and depth to the guitar section, Bono has to play as well.

If you listen to 'One' from the Album, you can distinctly hear two guitars, one plays the main riff that opens the song and through the chrous, bridge etc.. And one that plays any other licks and chords with whatever effects. When played live, bono just plays the basic chords of the song again to give Edge's guitar riff a foundation.

I wouldn't say Bono is a crappy guitar player, he plays when he needs to.
 
Salient points. Im just gonna say this, having played these songs oh maybe a few times with a few bands: The songs can in fact technically be played without playing Bonos parts. But they sound a hell of alot better - if I can get by on em - with his parts included. They actually really do sound fuller, more complete.

It also makes me feel like a million bucks to crank out that long E on The Fly :rockstar:

:wink:
 
I can only assume that the people posting these videos dont play guitar themselves. Nothing anyone has posted has shown Bono to be anything other than good enough to get by. I suppose that's a step above crap, but it certainly isn't good

Yes 20 years playing guitar: acoustic and electric guitar. The Edge is the guitar player and Bono only plays rythm parts in some songs. I think there shouldn't be discussion about if Bono plays better or worse the guitar, is not his work, but I like his accompaniments or little parts he plays. He did some interesting chords in "Exit" as Lanois said some time ago. But no matter, his contributions are a few but are correct. I would like to hear him more contributions.

Cheers
Gery
 
‪U2 Melbourne 2010-12-01 Bad - U2gigs.com‬‏ - YouTube

A nice bit of guitar at the end from Bono, nothing complicated but Bad doesn't need it....

I think he's a good guitar player and a good singer, he just has difficulty doing both at the same time.

I have to admit that this is why I've been a little cranky with the boys this tour...two main reasons actually, one, they didn't play Bad enough and two, after seeing the early 360 "Bad" (like this one) I was really hoping they'd keep going and greatly expand this little guitar piece that Bono came up with...it could have grown into an epic ending of an epic song!!! Oh well, maybe next time.
 
I am in NO WAY comparing myself to any of the U2 guys, but, here goes.

I can play anything I have ever wanted to play on guitar, never had a problem with any cover, or original. I can also sing more than my fair share of songs. BUT, I am that guy who just can't sing and play at the same time. I know plenty of other musicians that are the same way, and have seen alot of professional musicians that can't do it, either. So for me to see Bono even playing the simplest of chords, and singing the lyrics he does, my hats off to ANYONE that can do that.

I wouldn't say he's a crappy guitar player by any means, to pick up a guitar, sing, and play, to the masses that he does, he will always have my respect.
 
I am in NO WAY comparing myself to any of the U2 guys, but, here goes.

I can play anything I have ever wanted to play on guitar, never had a problem with any cover, or original. I can also sing more than my fair share of songs. BUT, I am that guy who just can't sing and play at the same time. I know plenty of other musicians that are the same way, and have seen alot of professional musicians that can't do it, either. So for me to see Bono even playing the simplest of chords, and singing the lyrics he does, my hats off to ANYONE that can do that.

I wouldn't say he's a crappy guitar player by any means, to pick up a guitar, sing, and play, to the masses that he does, he will always have my respect.


That's weird to me. I'm not a great guitar player - I've been playing since I was 14, but I'm not nearly as good as I should be for playing that long - and I think it's easy to play and sing at the same time. As long as it's chords, it really shouldn't be a problem. The problem usually lies when you have to think too much about playing when you're also trying to sing. If you know a song well enough, it should be more of a muscle memory, freeing your mind to concentrate of the singing
 
the ending of Last Night On Earth: :drool:
playing along to Adam Clayton's part after the choruses on The Fly during 360 sounded fucking badass too.
 
the ending of Last Night On Earth: :drool:
playing along to Adam Clayton's part after the choruses on The Fly during 360 sounded fucking badass too.

I love watching him play on The Fly too. He gets to really play guitar hero rock star on that song, especially since he got his new guitar recently and he looks great and seems to be having a blast doing it. :D
 
I was waiting for someone to post Staring at the Sun. lol Good example of a stilted yet important guitar part. He can play, a little, but he's the singer so who cares how good he is!
 
Back
Top Bottom