Opinions Only Please

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Dreadsox

ONE love, blood, life
Joined
Aug 24, 2002
Messages
10,885
I am finding it interesting how many of us actually have very opposite stands on issues. We argue one way on one issue and another complete different in another. What I am looking for here is just a simple answer (YES or NO) to the following questions. I am not looking to debate. I am really curious to see if there is a pattern here on the issues. I would really like to see no debating in this thread.

Are you a pacifist?
Are you for capital punishment?
Are you for abortion?
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)?
Are you for gun control?


Thanks in advance for responding!

Peace
 
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? YES
Are you for abortion? NO
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES
Are you for gun control? NO
 
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? UNCERTAIN
Are you for abortion? NO
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? UNCERTAIN
Are you for gun control? YES
 
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? NO
Are you for abortion? YES
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES
Are you for gun control? YES
 
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? NO
Are you for abortion? YES
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES
Are you for gun control? YES
 
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? YES
Are you for abortion? NO
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? Depends on the case.
Are you for gun control? Generally, NO - depends on the "control"
 
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? NO
Are you for abortion? YES
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES
Are you for gun control? YES
 
Are you a pacifist? Yes
Are you for capital punishment? NO:no:
Are you for abortion? YES, although this has to be clarified. I'm Pro-Choice.
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES
Are you for gun control? YES:lol:
 
Last edited:
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? NO
Are you for abortion? YES
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES
Are you for gun control? YES
 
Are you a pacifist?: No (just-war theorist)
Are you for capital punishment?: No (all the time)
Are you for abortion?: No, but who is?
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)?: I'm never *for* abortion, I'm *for* a woman's right to choose
Are you for gun control?: Yes
 
Pacifist: uncertain (the jury is still out on the "just war" theory in my mind)
Capital Punishment: No
Abortion: No
Abortion in cases of rape or incest: Yes
For Gun Control: More than what we have in the USA at the moment, so that might be a yes.
 
Are you a pacifist? YES
Are you for capital punishment? NO
Are you for abortion? NO
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? I think it should be legal, but I don't think it should be common or encouraged. If that makes sense....
Are you for gun control? YES
 
Are you a pacifist? - YES, but I will take the law into my own hands should someone harm my children, then I become an animal...LOL.

Are you for capital punishment? NO, but I am saddened by the current pathetic state of the justice system.

Are you for abortion? NO

Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? NO

Are you for gun control? YES, and even more so control of gun makers.
 
Are you a pacifist? Yes. I guess so.
Are you for capital punishment? No. Never.
Are you for abortion? As a choice, yes.
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? As a choice, yes.
Are you for gun control? Yes, and for the persecution of small arms sales.
 
Are you a pacifist? I lean towards one, but undecided.
Are you for capital punishment? Undecided
Are you for abortion? As a choice, yes.
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? As a choice, yes.
Are you for gun control? Yes.
 
Re: Re: Opinions Only Please

meegannie said:

Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? I think it should be legal, but I don't think it should be common or encouraged. If that makes sense....

I meant to put that as the answer to both the abortion questions. :banghead:

I think it's wrong and I would NEVER do it, but I don't think I have the right to judge someone else. I definitely think there needs to be more education/conselling before (and conselling after) abortions.
 
You are asking us to respond to a Litany of Litmus Tests.

Are you a pacifist? No.
Are you for capital punishment? I refuse to answer this question for fear of reprisal in the form of character assassination.
Are you for abortion? I refuse to answer this question for fear of reprisal in the form of character assassination.
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? I refuse to answer this question for fear of reprisal in the form of character assassination.
Are you for gun control? I refuse to answer this question for fear of reprisal in the form of character assassination.

~U2Alabama
 
Are you a pacifist? ya right, NO
Are you for capital punishment? No.
Are you for abortion? No
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? Yes, but decided with the help of family
Are you for gun control? Yes.
 
are you a pacifist? No
are you for capital punishment? tending towards yes
are you for abortion? no
are you for abortion in some cases? not really
are you for gun control? there's enuf of that!
 
Are you a pacifist? Absolutely.
Are you for capital punishment? Absolutely not.
Are you for abortion? As Martha said, I'm for choice.
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? see above.
Are you for gun control? yes.
 
Are you a pacifist? YES*
Are you for capital punishment? NO
Are you for abortion? NO**
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES***
Are you for gun control? YES





*I'm only a pacifist to the extent pacifism is actually possible for a human being. Hypothetical situation: Let's suppose that on September 11, 2001 I was one of the passengers on Flight 93, the airplane that crashed in Pennsylvania when the heroic passengers fought back. Let's also suppose that I would have known then what I know now about the terrorists' intent and the full scope of their actions that day, and let's further suppose that, while on that flight, I had a gun in my possession. I'm sure that, in the interest of self-preservation, I would have shot the terrorists on board that plane if need be. It's all about situational ethics. For me, I don't think it's possible to be a pacifist at all times, but I'd like to think that I strive to be pacifistic, particularly when it comes to war actions.

Oh, another area where I wouldn't have been a pacifist: Rwanda 1994. I think we (the U.S.) should have gone in and used force to stop the Hutus from carving the Tutsis into pieces.

**I wouldn't answer that I'm "for" abortion without qualifying my response. I like martha's ever so succinct answer to the question and I'd agree. I'm *for* having the choice of abortion. So in truth, my answer to Dread's question is YES. That said, abortion is not an issue that has had any bearing on my life and I really don't feel qualified to debate it.

***Again, I'm not "for" abortion, but, for me the answer to this question is obviously YES.

I find the abortion question to be perplexing, and I consider it an unsolvable, unanswerable issue or "problem." Furthermore, I think my opinion with respect to this issue is meaningless. But you asked. :tongue:
 
Are you a pacifist? NO
Are you for capital punishment? I AM NOT AGAINST IT
Are you for abortion? NO
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? YES
Are you for gun control? YES

I guess cos of the last one, I cant join the republican club. :wink:

Edit: country Australia
 
Last edited:
Are you a pacifist? i don't think so. i don't think that wars really fix things, but i can't really say i'm a pacifist.

Are you for capital punishment? no

Are you for abortion? i almost answered yes but realised i'm answering yes to the next question and need to think about this a little more.

Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? yes

Are you for gun control? yes

country: u.s.
 
Are you a pacifist? Not at all; I pick my fights wisely.
Are you for capital punishment? No. I believe that Death is too good for people who commit such crimes.
Are you for abortion? No, I am not 'for' abortion, per se.
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? Yes.
Are you for gun control? Yes.
country: United Kingdom.

Ant.
 
Are you a pacifist? Yes
Are you for capital punishment? No
Are you for abortion? As a choice, yes (but not encouraged)
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? Yes
Are you for gun control? Yes.

Country: the Netherlands

Marty
 
Are you a pacifist? no*
Are you for capital punishment? no (can you believe it, formerly from Texas!)**
Are you for abortion? yes***
Are you for abortion in some cases(rape, incest)? Yes
Are you for gun control? Yes, no question

country: Canada

*its interesting how this forum is requesting opinions, but is asking if you are in fact a pacifist. This is contradictory, because if you respond you are already in fact declaring your partiality towards one side of the issue or another. In my non-pacifist opinion, there is no true pacifism.

**this comment was made jestingly. I do not want to generalize about an entire state... especially one of the biggest (see gun control question for reason why). I have a lot of friends from Texas.

***choice of the parents or those in custody of the unborn infant.

It was interesting to add country as a stipulation for this post. I would like to further request that the responding contigent say what district or state they are from. There is a lot more diversity to account for, if you are comparing the Northern American states to the traditional Southern states... just a suggestion.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom