nathan1977
Rock n' Roll Doggie
Thoughts, anyone?
MaxFisher said:Narnia made 67 million domestic, 109 million worldwide over the weekend. Second largest December opening ever. Return of the King is number one.
Definitely not as spectacular as Lord of the Rings but then the two series don't really compare. Lord of the Rings is a completely unique mythology, epic in scope, and written for a more mature/literate audience. Lewis borrows heavily from already established principles of Christianity and Medieval/Renaissance literature. His series is written specifically for children and therefore the writing and scope of the stories are more personal and less complicated thematically. Tolkien detested allegory. Lewis obviously embraces it.
The Good:
1. Lucy- excellent, excellent casting. She's absolutely perfect in the role. She exudes a sense of wonder and childlike awe whenever she's on screen. It's her first cinematic performance and she nails it. Lucy steals the whole movie.
2. Christian principles- The allegory is there. It's done well and never comes off heavy handed or weak for that matter.
3. Creature effects- top notch. Mr. and Mrs. Beaver and Aslan all look like real animals.
4. The end battle- Great effects work.
5. The bombing of London and train station scenes- touching, emotianal, good directing
The Not So Good:
1. Film length- it's too short. It's my biggest gripe with the movie.
Although clocking in at 2 hours and 15 mins, the film seems rushed and could have used an extra 30 minutes to flesh out certain characters and linger on specific scenes (ex- Father Christmas, dinner at the Beaver Damn, Professor's mansion, Aslan assembling an army after his resurrection, etc.)
2. The Witch- too one dimensional. Not very menacing or scary. She looks wonderful but she incorporates a lot of lame "bad-guy" clichés. Her motivation for keeping Narnia in a state of perpetual winter is never really explained.
3. Edmund's turn to the dark side- Not really explained thoroughly. In the book, Edmund becomes enchanted by the Turkish Delight the witch gives him and therefore will do anything to get more. The witch also appeals to his pride and convinces Edmund of his superiority compared to his siblings (especially Peter). In the movie the witch just sort of says, "bring me your brother and sisters" and Edmund obliges for no real apparent reason.
4. The thawing of Narnia- too quick. In the book this is a more gradual process. The Narnians celebrate each new indication of spring while the witch becomes more and more enraged by the lessening of her power. The movie skip over this. Winter turns to spring too matter of factly.
5. The Professor- two of my favorite parts of the book are two conversations Peter and Susan have with the professor at the beginning and end of the book. Although seeming to know nothing about Narnia, the professor makes a logical argument for its existence based on what Peter and Susan tell him. Although these conversations are alluded too in the film, they aren't done nearly as well as in the book. Also, in the movie, the professor comes off as a wizened goofball whereas in the book he's portrayed as calculating, grandfatherly, and approachable.
B+ overall.
BluRmGrl said:Never read the books, but saw the movie Friday evening & enjoyed it. I did come away with the feeling that some things were left unfinished, i.e.: was the professor aware of Narnia or not?, Edmund's relationship/interaction with the Witch, and why, after so many obvious years in Narnia, would they suddenly decide to return home?
I chalked it up to not knowing the background of the screenplay, but from Maxfisher's review, maybe that's not the case.
Entertaining movie, regardless -- glad I saw it.
intedomine said:It's an interesting story, and I'm as non-Christian as you can get.
I'm like a fundamentalist Agnostic, if such a thing exists. It's almost oxymoronic.
Thing is, I don't see the point in this movie. About 15 years ago there was a decent 6 part TV adaptation of the book, and it was an adequate representation of the original book.
Just seems like another pathetic way of making money to me....
Still no decent original ideas amongst script writers....