BonosSaint
Rock n' Roll Doggie
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2004
- Messages
- 3,566
This isn't meant to be a thread to argue for or against the existence of God or to see whose God trumps the others' gods or whether there is a God-hole (which I recall has been argued in this forum before).
This is meant as a recognition of the influence the concept of God has throughout our culture, throughout our arts even among people who do not believe. So, why is this so? (I will admit to an absolute fascination with the why of this.) Why does it seem important to so many that we come to terms with our position on God even when it is to deny him? Why are there so many works with God as a subtext even when not the text?
Dostoyevsky, Monty Python, Ingmar Bergman, Norman Mailer, Joseph Heller, Dante, Michelangelo, Jesus Christ Superstar. John Lennon---ad infinitum--(Sorry, my religious experience is limited to Judeo-Christian, so I'm sure others will add the influence of other religions' concepts on the arts and I hope they do. I've eliminated people I think are religious spokespeople of a sort, so I do not include CS Lewis, although I enjoy his writings). God is treated with challenge, respect, humor, question and with what I'm sure some would consider blasphemy. Even when the story is not particularly God-based, we find Biblical and other works' references strongly throughout--East of Eden for one.
Have we grown up with archetypal myths with psychological truths? Why does it add to our understanding to know that East of Eden takes its inspiration from the story of Cain and Abel? Do we use God as a symbol for something else ("God is a concept by which we measure our pain.") Is God merely a symbol for doubt and pain and faith --religious or not--and joy (in short, the symbol for the human experience)?
Why would a concept of God fascinate a nonbeliever? (I'm not saying it would fascinate all or even most or maybe even many nonbelievers). So maybe, I'm simply asking why does it fascinate me who has come to terms with my own unbelief for a variety of reasons?
This is meant as a recognition of the influence the concept of God has throughout our culture, throughout our arts even among people who do not believe. So, why is this so? (I will admit to an absolute fascination with the why of this.) Why does it seem important to so many that we come to terms with our position on God even when it is to deny him? Why are there so many works with God as a subtext even when not the text?
Dostoyevsky, Monty Python, Ingmar Bergman, Norman Mailer, Joseph Heller, Dante, Michelangelo, Jesus Christ Superstar. John Lennon---ad infinitum--(Sorry, my religious experience is limited to Judeo-Christian, so I'm sure others will add the influence of other religions' concepts on the arts and I hope they do. I've eliminated people I think are religious spokespeople of a sort, so I do not include CS Lewis, although I enjoy his writings). God is treated with challenge, respect, humor, question and with what I'm sure some would consider blasphemy. Even when the story is not particularly God-based, we find Biblical and other works' references strongly throughout--East of Eden for one.
Have we grown up with archetypal myths with psychological truths? Why does it add to our understanding to know that East of Eden takes its inspiration from the story of Cain and Abel? Do we use God as a symbol for something else ("God is a concept by which we measure our pain.") Is God merely a symbol for doubt and pain and faith --religious or not--and joy (in short, the symbol for the human experience)?
Why would a concept of God fascinate a nonbeliever? (I'm not saying it would fascinate all or even most or maybe even many nonbelievers). So maybe, I'm simply asking why does it fascinate me who has come to terms with my own unbelief for a variety of reasons?