RATINGS POLL PART 2: OCTOBER

[U2fan42]

B-sides:

J. Swallow..............................5
A Celebration...........................8.5
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...7

October:

Gloria.............................8.5
I Fall Down........................7
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...8.5
Rejoice............................8
Fire...............................7
Tomorrow...........................9
October............................7.5
With A Shout.......................8
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7.5
Scarlet............................7
Is That All?.......................7

 

[Dustybot]

Ok, I'll bite.

B-sides:
J. Swallow..............................?
A Celebration...........................7
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...8

October:

Gloria.............................9
I Fall Down........................6
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...6.5
Rejoice............................5
Fire...............................8
Tomorrow...........................9
October............................9
With A Shout.......................5
Stranger In A Strange Land.........4.5
Scarlet............................4
Is That All?.......................4

 

[WHYWHY]

Righto: (Studio versions only)

Gloria - 8.3
I fall down - 7.6
I threw a brick - 6.9
Rejoice - 6.8
Fire - 7.3
Tomorrow - 8
October - 7.5
With a shout - 6.4
Stranger in a strange land - 5.4
Scarlet - 6
Is that all? - 5.8

B-SIDES:

J. Swallow - ???
A Celebration - 7
Party Girl - 5.2

Bless you all
WHYWHY

 

[80sU2isBest]

Yippee! My fave U2 album!

B-sides:

J. Swallow..............................6
A Celebration...........................10
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...5

October:

Gloria.............................10
I Fall Down........................9.5
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...9.5
Rejoice............................9
Fire...............................9
Tomorrow...........................9
October............................8.5
With A Shout.......................9.5
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7.5
Scarlet............................8
Is That All?.......................7.5

 

[Saracene]

Gloria.............................9
I Fall Down........................7.5
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...7.5
Rejoice............................5
Fire...............................7.5
Tomorrow...........................9.5
October............................8
With A Shout.......................6
Stranger In A Strange Land.........5
Scarlet............................4
Is That All?.......................4

 

[Dorian Gray]

B-sides:
J. Swallow..............................4
A Celebration...........................7
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...7.5

October:

Gloria.............................8.5
I Fall Down........................7
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...7
Rejoice............................7.5
Fire...............................7
Tomorrow...........................8.5
October............................8.5
With A Shout.......................7.5
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7
Scarlet............................8
Is That All?.......................7


------------------
And I felt like a star...

 

[agentorange]

Very solid album...

Gloria...............9
I Fall Down..........9
Threw a Brick........7.5
Rejoice..............9
Fire.................6
Tomorrow.............9
October..............7
With a Shout.........8.5
Stranger...Land......5
Scarlet..............7
Is That All..........8.5

 

[Michael Griffiths]

B sides that I've heard:

* Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl - 8
* A Celebration - 9.5 (So good, it should be remixed as a new single! Possibly on the next best of...)

October:

* Gloria - 8.5
* I Fall Down - 9
* I Through A Brick Through A Window - 7.5
* Rejoice - 6.5
* Fire - 7.5
* Tomorrow - 9
* October - 10
* With A Shout - 6
* Stranger In A Strange Land - 6
* Scarlet - 8.5
* Is That All - 5

------------------
The Tempest

 

[ericb]

Gloria- 10
I Fall Down- 9
I Threw A Brick- 3
Rejoice- 8
Fire- 10
Tomorrow- 9
October- 7
With A Shout- 7
Stranger In A Strange Land- 8
Scarlet- I can't remember this song
Is That All?- can't remember this one either

 

[UnforgettableLemon]

B-sides:

J. Swallow..............................4.5
A Celebration...........................8
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...7.5

October:

Gloria.............................8
I Fall Down........................8.5
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...9
Rejoice............................8
Fire...............................10
Tomorrow...........................10
October............................9
With A Shout.......................5
Stranger In A Strange Land.........6
Scarlet............................2
Is That All?.......................6

 

[mikal]

Gloria...................7
I Fall Down..............6
I Threw A Brick..........6
Rejoice..................7
Fire.....................6
Tomorrow.................8
October..................5
With A Shout.............6
Stranger.................5
Scarlet..................7
Is That All..............4

------------------
Look what you did, you little JERK!

Kevin! You're such a disease!

 

[KhanadaRhodes]

B-sides:

J. Swallow..............................5
A Celebration...........................8.5
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...6

October:

Gloria.............................9
I Fall Down........................8
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...9
Rejoice............................8
Fire...............................9
Tomorrow...........................9
October............................7
With A Shout.......................8
Stranger In A Strange Land.........8
Scarlet............................7
Is That All?.......................6

------------------
the lights are down, but you don't sleep so tight. the word's around that we play for keeps tonight...
ME!

 

[Roland of Gilead]

B-Sides

J.Swallow......4.5
A Celebration......7.5
T,T,and the Party Girl......7.5

The Album

Gloria......8
I Fall Down......7.5
I Threw a Brick......7.5
Rejoice......7.5
Fire......7
Tomorrow......8
October......8.5
With A Shout......7.5
Stranger In A Strange Land......7
Scarlet......6.5
Is That All?......7

 

[MixingBliss]

Gloria - 7.5
I fall down - 7.25
I threw a brick - 8
Rejoice - 6.5
Fire - 7
Tomorrow - 9
October - 8.5
With a shout - 5
Stranger in a strange land - 7.5
Scarlet - 5.5
Is that all? - 5

B-SIDES:

J. Swallow - 5.75
A Celebration - 6.75
Party Girl - 6.5

 

[Olofski]

B:sides:

A Celebration...........................8
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...9

October:

Gloria.............................8.5
I Fall Down........................7,5
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...7
Rejoice............................8
Fire...............................7
Tomorrow...........................9,5
October............................7,5
With A Shout.......................7
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7.5
Scarlet............................6
Is That All?.......................6


------------------
***********
Olofski
SWEDEN
We move through miracle days Spirit moves in mysterious ways

 

[mike63]

J. Swallow..............................5
A Celebration (not a B side, but an indep single after October but before War)...........................8.5
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...5 (live version, 6)

October:

Gloria.............................9.5
I Fall Down........................6
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...6.5
Rejoice............................7
Fire...............................7
Tomorrow...........................9.99
October............................6.5
With A Shout.......................7
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7.5
Scarlet............................7
Is That All?.......................7

Mike

 

[senrab]

J. Swallow..........................?
A Celebration....................8
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...5

October:

Gloria.............................9
I Fall Down........................8
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...8
Rejoice............................8
Fire...............................8
Tomorrow...........................8
October............................10
With A Shout.......................7
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7.5
Scarlet............................8
Is That All?.......................8

 

[U2Fan101]

J. Swallow..............................5
A Celebration...........................8.5
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...7

October:

Gloria.............................8.5
I Fall Down........................7
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...8.5
Rejoice............................4.5
Fire...............................3.0
Tomorrow...........................10
October............................10
With A Shout.......................8
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7.5
Scarlet............................7
Is That All?.......................7

 

[Sperber]

B-sides:
J. Swallow..............................7
A Celebration..........................9
Trash, Trampoline, and the Party Girl...6

October:

Gloria.............................10
I Fall Down........................7
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...7
Rejoice............................7
Fire...............................8
Tomorrow...........................7
October............................8
With A Shout.......................9
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7
Scarlet............................10
Is That All?.......................6

 

[Jack4U]

October:

Gloria.............................8
I Fall Down........................7
I Threw A Brick Through A Window...6
Rejoice............................8
Fire...............................6
Tomorrow...........................9
October............................8
With A Shout.......................7
Stranger In A Strange Land.........7
Scarlet............................5
Is That All?.......................6