Of The Joshua Tree Demo Clips...

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Screwtape2

Blue Crack Addict
Joined
Jul 19, 2006
Messages
18,353
Location
Omaha, Nebraska “With Screwtape on Kettle Dr
Which would you most like to hear the complete version of?


Personally, I'd want to hear Diamond Store and Present Tense. Diamond Store sounds like Exit multiplied by ten. Present Tense is obviously an early version of Walk To The Water which is the band's best work. The Doors feel is so intriguing that I'd love a full version. :combust:
 
I've never even heard any of the B-sides, so I don't know if I can judge then.
 
Honestly, none of those little demos grab me. They seem a bit musically uninteresting, but given how short they are, it's kind of hard to even draw that sort of judgement when you lack a broader context.
 
I haven't heard them in a few years. I found them too short to really be able to get into them. I found a site with a history of how they came to being available:

U2 - Joshua Tree B-sides demo session snippets

lineage: studio master tape>cassette>.WAV>cassette>.WAV>CD-R(0)>.SHN

These are demo snippets from one of a set of three 60-minute cassettes.
The cassettes were supposedly copied direct from a master tape of a
"Joshua Tree b-sides session".

A person appeared on the U2 internet mailing list WIRE 5-6 years
ago and purported to have all three cassettes for sale to the highest
bidder. I believe he was seeking in the neighborhood of $1000-$2000.
My memory is unclear on the exact details, but I think this person
claimed to have been charged with the duty of transporting the
master tapes across town and either stopped by his house and made a
quick copy or perhaps snuck a quick copy of the tape in the studios
which were at either end of his journey.

Regardless of how the tapes came into existence, this was nonetheless
a very dubious story. WIRE, for once, seemed to want some proof instead
of wildly just spreading rumours. So the seller established a temporary
website and stated that he would offer proof in the form of .WAV files
which could be downloaded. Chris Jenkins was able to download eight of
these files and later traded a tape copy of them to me. I remember he
did say there were a few that he missed before the website was "mysteriously"
shut down.

Think about it: this person posted on the Internet that he had stolen
something from U2. U2's management no doubt read this and took actions
to secure the tapes - or at least get the person to "cease and desist"
under threat of lawsuit. After the website suddenly shut down,
this person (to my knowledge) was never heard from again.

Another interesting item of note is that all this ocurred in the same time
frame as the anticipated release of the Joshua Tree Ultradisc from Mobile
Fidelity Studios. This release was delayed for unspecified reasons, but
is it a coincidence that Mobile Fidelity REQUIRES access to an album's
master tapes before they agree to license it to create the Ultradisc?

A very intriguing story.

I remember thinking that there would probably be a very interesting new
bootleg to listen to a few months after the tapes were sold, but nothing
ever came forward. Perhaps U2 took back what had been stolen. All we
have to listen to then are these few snippets:

(I've quoted a best-guess of Bono's lyrics in each case)

1. "in the doorstep, golden light"
2. "tell them the story"
3. "dance with me baby"
- in retrospect, I think this one sounds a lot like
something you can hear on the SALOME bootleg.
4. "and you didn't make any enemies"
5. "move, up, up"
- spooky African motif includes some chanting
- kinda reminds me of "Race Against Time"
6. "Walk To the Water" - demo with vocal
lyrics: "through the past, through the future,
we're all wading in the present tense
7. "diamond store"

[each segment is approximately 30-sec. long]

After listening to these, there is no doubt in my mind that they are
legitimate. They sound like U2, but they don't exist anywhere else
that someone could have copied them and pretended they were new.

U2 - Joshua Tree B-sides demo session snippets
 
To me, "Dance With Me Baby" is the most interesting of the demos -- it seems to point the way to Achtung Baby.
 
I dont think any of them sound all that great. To me, they sound like soundcheck jams and not album recordings and they have done much better soundcheck jams than what is on these demos over the years. They really dont have a studio sound to them. I still wonder exactly what and where they really came from.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom