Best Song Survivor: October Round Three

[bonocomet]

I fear this battle shall return next round too. Hopefully that will be its last reprise.

Let's go.

 

[Galeongirl]

Or we could just kick With a Shout and Scarlet out right now. Just two more votes for scarlet!

 

[BlueSilkenSky]

You click "view poll results"

Okay, I'll try that for the next poll. Thanks!

 

[Tyagu_Anaykus]

with a shout going down

 

[Axver]

Come on Scarlet! If it can survive this round, it'll be its personal best in Survivor.

(Who said the Tour Effect wasn't good for anything?)

 

[The Sad Punk]

With A Shout could just as well be a Faith + 1 song, but I rather like it and hope it stays for another round.

 

[The_acrobat]

I didn't know With a Shout was so maligned. I love that song.

Edge has even said that this was his least favorite U2 song, and he knew so little about it he referred to it as "Jerusalem" when he said so.

 

[bonocomet]

Edge has even said that this was his least favorite U2 song, and he knew so little about it he referred to it as "Jerusalem" when he said so.

Wait! Is this from the article where he said it was the song he'd be happy to never have to ever hear again? (Or something like that.) Because I have been searching for that article for years! I read it then forgot which song he had said it about, so I always ask around but nobody knew. Do you think that's it?

 

[TheWanderer]

I don't understand all the Scarlet hate. I have loved that track for decades.
I would put Scarlet in the top 3 tracks off October.
Madness.