Best Album Survivor: Round Eight

[LemonMelon]

Studio Bad is about 100x worse than live Bad, but that's a lil strong.

The studio version of Bad is massively disappointing to listen to

 

[Nick66]

Studio Bad is about 100x worse than live Bad, but that's a lil strong.

The studio version of Bad is massively disappointing to listen to

Is that your scientific analysis? 100x? Why not 1000x?

Almost all U2 songs are improved live; that doesn't make the originals bad. And the original Bad can only be disappointing to someone who'd heard the live version.

 

[The Sad Punk]

I think Achtung Baby is going to win, you guys.

 

[LemonMelon]

Is that your scientific analysis? 100x? Why not 1000x?

Almost all U2 songs are improved live; that doesn't make the originals bad. And the original Bad can only be disappointing to someone who'd heard the live version.

I said "about." Future attempts to replicate the studies will reveal the imprecise nature of my approximation.

 

[Vlaco]

Studio Bad is about 100x worse than live Bad, but that's a lil strong.

The studio version of Bad is massively disappointing to listen to

Can't disagree more. Many live versions are definitely superior to the album version. But the album version just stand on its own. This may sound a bit awkward, but it's like a cathedral, in all its purity and grandness...

 

[Nick66]

I think Achtung Baby is going to win, you guys.

Corrected.

That's a foregone conclusion.

 

[BlueSilkenSky]

I think Achtung Baby is going to win, you guys.

Whatever gave you that idea?

 

[Galeongirl]

I think Achtung Baby is going to win, you guys.

As it should.

 

[Nick66]

I think Achtung Baby is going to win, you guys.

Whatever gave you that idea?

It has Acrobat on it. Therefore, by default on Interference, it MUST win.

 

[lazarus]

Studio Bad is about 100x worse than live Bad, but that's a lil strong.

The studio version of Bad is massively disappointing to listen to

"Massively disappointing" doesn't sound too different to me than "almost painful".