ATYCLB v. HTDAAB

[MrBrau1]

I would've done it in the track order the band selected:

1. BD vs. vertigo
2. stuck vs. MD
3. elevation vs. sometimes
4. walk on vs. lapoe
5. kite vs. cobl
6. ialw vs. aboy
7. wild honey vs. amaaw
8. poe vs. crumbs
9. wilatw vs. one step
10. ny vs. original
11. grace vs. yahweh

mine:
1. beutiful day
2. miracle drug
3. sometimes
4. walk on
5. city of blinding lights
6. all because of you
7. a man and a woman
8. crumbs from your table
9. one step closer
10. original of the species
11. yahweh

That way makes more sense. The original in this thread seem set up strange. Why not do it in track order? I'm doing it your way:

1. BD
2. MD
3. sometimes
4. lapoe
5. kite
6. ialw
7. wild honey
8. crumbs
9. wilatw
10. original
11. yahweh

 

[GibsonGirl]

That way makes more sense. The original in this thread seem set up strange. Why not do it in track order? I'm doing it your way:

1. BD
2. MD
3. sometimes
4. lapoe
5. kite
6. ialw
7. wild honey
8. crumbs
9. wilatw
10. original
11. yahweh

I think I'll do it that way too, because the other way just doesn't make sense. I mean, how could you compare something as brilliant to LAPOE to Peace on Earth?

01. Beautiful Day
02. Miracle Drug
03. Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own
04. Love And Peace Or Else
05. City Of Blinding Lights
06. All Because Of You
07. Wild Honey
08. Crumbs From Your Table
09. When I Look At The World
10. Original Of The Species
11. Yahweh

HTDAAB still kicks ATYCLB's arse that way, but wouldn't that just make a perfect album?

 

[U2girl]

I would've done it in the track order the band selected:

1. BD vs. vertigo
2. stuck vs. MD
3. elevation vs. sometimes
4. walk on vs. lapoe
5. kite vs. cobl
6. ialw vs. aboy
7. wild honey vs. amaaw
8. poe vs. crumbs
9. wilatw vs. one step
10. ny vs. original
11. grace vs. yahweh

mine:
1. beutiful day
2. miracle drug
3. sometimes
4. walk on
5. city of blinding lights
6. all because of you
7. a man and a woman
8. crumbs from your table
9. one step closer
10. original of the species
11. yahweh

Well in that case it's

Beautiful day
Stuck
Sometimes
Love and peace
a tie
In a little while
a tie
Crumbs
Step
Original
Yahweh

 

[lazarus]

I think I'll do it that way too, because the other way just doesn't make sense. I mean, how could you compare something as brilliant to LAPOE to Peace on Earth?

To answer your question (that someone else above asked as well), I put POE against LPOE because one is about the Irish conflict, the other inspired by the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. I tried to put the songs against each other thematically when possible.


laz

 

[The Sneak]

Beautiful Day
Sometimes
Vertigo
4) Walk On v. City of Blinding Lights- no fair 2 very different songs!
5) Kite
All Because of You
7) Wild Honey
8) A Man and Woman
9 Origin of the Species
10) New York
One Step Closer

 

[neutral]

1) Miracle Drug
2) Tie, don't make me pick between those two
3) Vertigo
4) Walk On
5) Kite
6) All Because of You
7) Yahweh
8) A Man and Woman
9) When I Look at the World
10) New York
11) One Step Closer

 

[gherman]

1) Beautiful Day v. Miracle Drug (both the same
2) Sometimes
3) Vertigo
4) Walk On v. City of Blinding Lights (both the same)
5) Kite
6) All Because of You
7) Yahweh
8) A Man and Woman
9) When I Look at the World
10) Love, Peace, Or Else
11) One Step Closer