VintagePunk said:
And since we're having this frank discussion this morning, I'd like to say that regarding the song Hallelujah, the versions of it I like best are, in order:
1) Rufus Wainwright
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
2) Leonard Cohen's original
3) Jeff Buckley
*SHUDDER*
I'm sorry, I still have that reaction to Hallelujah, esp when Jeff Buckley is mentioned... This stems from a Jeff Buckley tribute weekend that I went to (which is still an annual event but this was the first) because there were a bunch of artists performing that I wanted to see, unfortunately spread out over the three days (it went Thurs-Sat). It was by far the worst ever weekend of music I've ever had in TO.
Now to set this up, I have to say that Tory Cassis used to do a Tom Waits tribute night (note the difference at the beginning - Waits with a much longer career has a night, Buckley got three days) that was one of the best organized tributes I've ever seen. Each artist gets one song at a time (though some got a second in the second set) and
THERE ARE NO REPEATS.
For that Jeff Buckley tribute weekend, over the three days (not exaggerating, I kept track when things started repeating) I heard Hallelujah SEVEN TIMES (three times by one artist who started off all three nights *shudder*, and her own music was worse - avoid Mary Simon), and various other songs repeated as well. Not to mention each artist not only got to do a Jeff Buckley song, but one or more of their own as well, which kind of defeats the purpose of a tribute night in my mind.
This also is the origin of the absolute loathing I have for Three Days Grace *SHUDDER* Not only did they do a repeat of a song done at least twice before, but the lead singer did two songs solo (bad songs to boot) before saying "And now I'm going to bring up my band" and proceeding to suck even more.
Ever since that weekend, my friend Leanne and I have referred to Hallelujah as "The Song Which Shall Not Be Named" - no reflection on Cohen, just the unfortunate result of three nights of musical torture