Top 2015 Shows By Metacritic Score
New Comedies:
1. Master of None (Netflix) - 93
2. Catastrophe (Amazon) - 83
3. Togetherness (HBO) - 79
4. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (CW) - 78
5. Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt (Netflix) - 78
6. Casual (Hulu) - 77
7. Documentary Now! (IFC) - 77
8. Difficult People (Hulu) - 76
9. Fresh Off The Boat (ABC) - 75
10. Younger (TV Land) - 75
11. Ash vs. Evil Dead (Starz) - 75
Returning Comedies With Enough Reviews:
1. Louie - Season 5 (FX) - 91
2. Bojack Horseman - Season 2 (Netflix) - 90
3. Veep - Season 4 (HBO) - 90
4. Broad City - Season 2 (Comedy Central) - 89
5. Silicon Valley - Season 2 (HBO) - 86
6. You're The Worst - Season 2 (FXX) - 82
7. Community - Season 6 (Yahoo Screen) - 78
8. Girls - Season 5 (HBO) - 75
New Dramas:
1. Wolf Hall (PBS) - 86 * Miniseries *
2. Show Me A Hero (HBO) - 85 * Miniseries *
3. American Crime (ABC) - 84 * Resets With A New Story Each Season *
4. Mr. Robot (USA) - 79
5. Deutschland 83 (Sundance) - 79
6. Better Call Saul (AMC) - 78
7. UnReal (Lifetime) - 78
8. The Last Kingdom (BBC America) - 78
9. The Book of Negroes (BET) - 77 *Miniseries *
10. Narcos (Netflix) - 77
11. Indian Summers (PBS) - 76
12. Fortitude (pivot) - 75
13. Marvel's Daredevil (Netflix) - 75
14. Supergirl (CBS) - 75
15. Bloodline (Netflix) - 75
Returning Dramas:
1. Fargo - Season 2 (FX) - 96 * Resets With A New Story Each Season *
2. The Americans - Season 3 (FX) - 93
3. Game of Thrones - Season 5 (HBO) - 91
4. Rectify - Season 3 (Sundance) - 89
5. Justified - Season 6 (FX) - 89 * Ended *
6. Hannibal - Season 3 (NBC) - 84 * Ended *
7. Orange Is The New Black - Season 3 (Netflix) - 83
8. Mad Men - Season 7.5 (AMC) - 83 * Ended *
9. The Returned - Season 2 (Sundance) - 82
10. Vikings - Season 3 (The History Channel) - 81
11. The Leftovers - Season 2 (HBO) - 80
12. Manhattan - Season 2 (WGN) - 80
13. The Walking Dead - Season 6 (AMC) - 79
14. The Affair - Season 2 (Showtime) - 78
15. Penny Dreadful - Season 2 (Showtime) - 77
16. Empire - Season 2 (FOX) - 77
17. Homeland - Season 5 (Showtime) - 76
18. House of Cards - Season 3 (Netflix) - 76
Other Notables:
Kurt Cobain: Montage of Heck (HBO) - 88 (Documentary)
Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief - 86 (Documentary)
Project Greenlight: Season 4 (HBO) - 80 (Reality)
Cancer: The Emperor of All Maladies (PBS) - 78 (Documentary Miniseries)
Amy Schumer: Live at the Apollo (HBO) - 77 (Standup Special)
The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst (HBO) - 76 (Documentary Miniseries)
Bessie (HBO) - 75 (TV Movie)
http://www.metacritic.com/browse/tv/score/metascore/year/filtered?sort=desc&year_selected=2015