Pink Floyd Best Song Survivor: Round Two - Piper at the Gates of Dawn

[cobl04]

Pow R. Toc H. has the high honour of being the first song eliminated.

Votes:
Pow R. Toc H. - 5
Chapter 24 - 3
Take up Thy Stethoscope and Walk, Bike, Matilda Mother - 1
Total Votes - 11

Eliminated so far:
1. Pow R. Toc H.


Round Two now, vote for your least favourite song. Polls are open for one day.

 

[cobl04]

Gotsa to be Bike. Average ride.

What songs are we all pulling for?

 

[notAxver]

Nah, Bike for the huge bloody win. Absolutely hilarious. I hope it wins, but I know Astronomy Domine will be the one to go through.

Right now ... not sure. Matilda Mother, maybe? I'll vote later.

(Not wasting my 30,000th post on this. )

 

[cobl04]

I saw you were on 29999 last night.

Shame you can't save it for a massive NZ victory post

 

[notAxver]

I was hoping to use it on that, too!

I now have no idea what to do. I normally don't make a big deal about post milestones, I think I've let everything pass without note since 17,000, but 30,000 is a serious shitload. I'm sure some people think it's 30,000 loads of shit too.

 

[cobl04]

I'll summarise:

"one is teh suk, wire has not been played since 17 july 1986, fucking bogans"

its been fun

 

[DaveC]

RIP Pow R Toc H...

I voted again for Stethoscope.

 

[notAxver]

I'll summarise:

"one is teh suk, wire has not been played since 17 july 1986, fucking bogans"

its been fun

7 July 1985, Werchter!

...

Oh, you win anyway.

... fucking bogan ...

 

[cobl04]

i got the month right at least!!

oh shit. i forgot "oh heartland. oh one tree hill and 11:00ticktock and oh wild irish rose (no interview)"

course, there's the distinct lack of bad grammar and punctuation as well.

im going to bed. celebrate it well
start a thread!!

 

[notAxver]

i got the month right at least!!

oh shit. i forgot "oh heartland. oh one tree hill and 11:00ticktock and oh wild irish rose (no interview)"

course, there's the distinct lack of bad grammar and punctuation as well.

Yeah, you got me.

And I was a bit thrown by your 17 July 1986 bit. Since it looks a bit similar to the correct date, the only thing that tipped me off that it was wrong was that U2 weren't playing live gigs much in 1986! If you'd said 1985, I'm not sure I would've even registered that it actually happened on the 7th, not the 17th.

im going to bed. celebrate it well
start a thread!!

Start a thread with what? 30,000 setlists?

 

[cobl04]

Haha I'm happy I came close. Shows a minute knowledge at least.

Start Heartland appreciation thread part two. Post tally: Axver 300, Aardvark 300, notAxver 200, notAarvark 200

night all
go lucifer

 

[Screwtape2]

The Scarecrow. Not a bad song but definitely one of the most annoying Floyd songs after a couple listens.

 

[phanan]

Gotsa to be Bike. Average ride.

Bike is one of the best songs on here.

Still deciding what should go next.

 

[LemonMelon]

Chapter 24...it's pretty repetitive.

 

[cdisantis83]

Bike it is.

 

[Screwtape2]

Gotsa to be Bike. Average ride.

Bike it is.

Life's rough for Gerald these days.

 

[DaveC]

He's a good mouse.

Really.

I'm surprised, I thought Bike would stick around till the later rounds of this album...

 

[Zoots]

Bike is friggin awesome!

Stethoscope can go.

 

[Zoots]

Jennifer Gentle you're a witch!

The entirety of Matilda Mother including the instrumental break in the middle =

 

[Zoots]

...and then one dayyy hooray!

 

[cobl04]

Well not long to go and unless someone else votes its a five-way elimination...

Need more voters and repliers!!!

 

[notAxver]

Edit: Ignore this. I was going to ask for my vote to be manually counted towards Chapter 24 but I see the next round's live already.