Pink Floyd Best Song Survivor: Announcement Thread!!!

[LemonMelon]

With the impending release of IN RAINBOWS, wouldn't this be the most apparopriate time for Radiohead Survivor?

I already called dibs on a Radiohead survivor in the PF thread. It will be next.

 

[DaveC]

This is not a bad idea.

Yes, it is.

Well...not a bad idea, but it really takes a lot of the chance away for those songs that don't immediately jump out at you but seem to surprise everyone by staying around until the end of an album round.

I say do it as normal, and start ASAP. No need to wait till next week.

 

[cobl04]

Half the albums only have like seven songs, there's really only like The Wall and the b-sides that'll go for a while. Plus we stumbled through The White Album remember.

I'm going away this weekend.... so I could start it today but we wouldn't have round two until Monday.

 

[intedomine]

Finish off The Beatles first...

and then once we ge 10 huge bands out the way, we can put all the winners in a round to decide the ultimate song

 

[cobl04]

I'll start it when I get back next week.

And I like that idea ^

 

[SeattleVertigo]

Finish off The Beatles first...

and then once we ge 10 huge bands out the way, we can put all the winners in a round to decide the ultimate song

Well, the Beatles have taken over a year to do, so I guess we'll get that ultimate song competition going in around 2017 or so. <grin>

 

[Screwtape2]

Finish off The Beatles first...

and then once we ge 10 huge bands out the way, we can put all the winners in a round to decide the ultimate song

Couldn't there just be a survivor where people submit a top five song list and you eliminate and get a winner from that?