Noel vs. Liam....

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

UnforgettableLemon

Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
Joined
Oct 2, 2000
Messages
7,283
Location
Lansdale, PA
OK, Oasis fans. Who do you like more? Noel or Liam. For me, I'm gonna break it down to diff. categories

1. Vocal range
Liam-6
Noel-9.5

2. Vocal style
Liam- 8
Noel- 6

3. Songwriting
Liam- 2(Little James?)
Noel- 9

4. Badass attitude
Liam- 10
Noel- 7

5. Charisma
Liam- 9
Noel- 7

Totals-
Liam- 35
Noel- 38.5

Noel is it for me.

------------------
If I had a head like yours I'd bleedin' bury it.

This is.. uh... we don't play this tune... gonna be f*cked up!


[This message has been edited by UnforgettableLemon (edited 08-23-2001).]
 
Got to go with Noel...
without him, there is no Oasis.

Plus, I've seen Oasis live and Liam Gallagher is not exactly Bono out there. Don't Look Back in Anger and the Masterplan are both great songs sung by Noel. I would say that Liam is superior for vocals over all, but Noel is Oasis "music" what Bono is to U2 "music"

------------------
You Just Can't Get Enough Of That Lovey Dovey Stuff...
 
Liam is the rockstar...he has the fuckyou attitude, and the boy can sing...in his own style of course.

Noel is the genius...he can write the songs.

I can't split the two. OASIS would be nothing without each of them. They wouldn't have the attitude, the frontman w/o Liam, they wouldn't have the songs w/o Noel.....but Noel needs Liam to sing his songs, and Liam needs Noel to write his songs....it's a two way street, and I love 'em for it.

------------------
All is quiet on New Year's Day
Think I'll try and impress my mates
So I jumped into the lake
I won't do that again
Here we go again - A


IM me at popkidu2
 
Personally I like Noel better just because he's wrote so many classic songs. I still think Liam's really cool and he has the same birthday as me (September 21.)
 
I like both the same!
biggrin.gif


------------------
~*Dream Out loud*~

(??.?(?*?.? ?.?*?)?.??)
?.???. *Monica* .???.?
(?.??(?.??* *??.?)??.)
 
Reporter: Can you describe Oasis in one word?
Noel: ME!

Yes, it's true, Noel Gallagher runs Oasis. If he left tomorrow, there would be no more Oasis. There would just be Liam, Gem, Andy, and Alan--none of whom have contributed anywhere near as much as Noel. Now, they all excel at what they do, but this isn't the state fair, it's Oasis.

Of course, think of what would happen if Liam left. "Heresy!", they would cry. Oh well, guess we need 'em both.

------------------
Change is the only constant
 
liam has the attitude, noel is the genius, i prefer noel, cause he's the man!

[This message has been edited by Acrobat_Al (edited 08-25-2001).]
 
Of course when a reporter asked Bono, "Who's closer to God, Blur or Oasis, he replied..."Well, first of all I am God and Liam is my only son...."

Make of that what you will...
 
Back
Top Bottom