LemonMacPhisto said:
It'll air right after Spielberg on Spielberg, just offering rebuttals to everything Stevie said.
Anytime.
"Lazarus on Spielberg". Ratings bonanza.
Also, Return of the Jedi can suck it. I will defend to the death the superiority of The Phantom Menace to this awful Muppet-Fest.
Example #1: Mark Hamill's haircut. Just...no.
Example #2: Harrison Ford. 20 pounds overweight, sleepwalks through role. What happened to the cool, rascally badass? He ain't in this film. His performance in the Jabba's palace scenes are unforgivably bad, and his Endor material is only a step above embarassing. The high school level love spat with Leia near the end of the film? Worse than any Anakin/Padme scene in the prequel trilogy.
Example #3: Carrie Fisher. Hopped up on prescription medication and almost delirious. See above. Jabba's Palace line: "Someone who LOVES you." Oh my god terrible.
Example #4: Max Rebo's band. Okay. If you can show me something in The Phantom Menace worse than the musical number in Jedi, you win a prize. Nope, there isn't one. As bad as Jar Jar Binks was, at least he wasn't a BLUE FUCKING ELEPHANT. Who the hell designed that unique, outlandish alien? A third grader?
Example #5: Salacious Crumb. Do I even need to explain this? Again, the little muppet laughter was more grating than any single moment from Jar Jar. Sure, he wasn't in the entire film, but bad enough to tarnish the entire thing.
Example #6: Boba Fett's death. First you have the supremely awkward physical comedy of Han Solo stumbling around the skiff barge, until he "accidentally" sets off Boba's jetpack, sending the bounty hunter to his doom in the Sarlacc pit, which burps after swallowing him. Right. And people were complaining about poop jokes in Episode 1?
Example #7: The Death Star. Yeah, we saw that in A New Hope. It was a pretty cool idea in that film. Second time around? A bit redundant. Did all the creative ideas get used up in Empire? Fucking lame. Compare the moment this one gets blown up to the same scene in A New Hope. Pretty fucking anticlimactic.
Example #8: Yoda and Obi-Wan. Yoda pretty much gives Luke the opposite advice he gave in Empire. Then it was "don't face Vader, stay here and complete your training". Now it's "you must defeat Vader to truly become a Jedi". Huh? Obi-Wan, as mentioned above, SITS ON A FUCKING LOG to blurt out a bunch of exposition to Luke. Needless to say, it's not a high point. Spielberg loved this so much he used it in A.I. when the robot voiced by Ben Kingley explains the fucking movie to Haley Joel Osment. It didn't work there either.
Example #9: Ewoks. What can I say here? Again, as mentioned above, not a bad idea in theory. But considering this was originally supposed to be an Wookie planet, it could have been so much better.
Example #10: Inept Stormtroopers. Okay, they weren't exactly great shots in the last two films either, but you got the sense they were hot on the trail, always right behind our heroes. In this film, they're like silent movie boobs, tripping, getting knocked out by sticks and stones. This is how the Empire maintained their stranglehold on the galaxy? Who WERE they able to defeat?
Do I need to go on? Yeah there's a lot of cool moments with the Emperor and Vader. That takes up about 1/10 of this film. With The Phantom Menace, even if you took out all the Jar Jar material and a few bad scenes with li'l Anakin, you've still got a shitload of cool scenes spread throughout the ENTIRE film. ROTJ, on the other hand, really only comes alive in the final Death Star scenes and the space battle. That just ain't enough.