Alright, here goes:
I still stand by what I said earlier about the construction of your list: it's really well put together, distinct to your tastes, and fits the concept well. You do it better than most.
The songs, for the most part, were terrible for me to listen to. Most either bordered on painful, ridiculous, or non-objectionable, while I did enjoy some. We have different tastes, and in other cases, I would respect that and move along, but the way you trashed my list last night, regardless the time and effort I put into it, was condescending, rude, and uncalled for. There's a difference between "brutal honesty" and being pretentious, and I think you crossed it. It sucks the fun out of everything.
Giving it a low grade would be as insulting as giving mine a D+, since it obviously meant a lot to you to put together, so I'll just pull a BIMM and give it an N/A, surely for using all facets of death metal and providing me with all of the atmosphere I'll ever need.