Desert Island Album Game: Semi Final 1

[VertigoGal]

I was really hoping that as this is B&C, not EYKIW, people would go on the overall quality of the mix, not whether it had U2.

I do hope you're not insulting the overall quality of my prized mix.

 

[vivalapopedge]

I was really hoping that as this is B&C, not EYKIW, people would go on the overall quality of the mix, not whether it had U2.

I didn't go by that, I feel I made a completely un-biased pick

 

[Axver]

but everyone here is a U2 fan, and would not want to go an entire lifetime without atleast 1 U2 song.

Like if no one had Dream Theater on a Portnoy forum

(i hope i'm right with portnoy's band name)

Heh, yes, you're right, but on the Portnoy forums, there wasn't a case of "but so-and-so has Dream Theater". I honestly don't remember the lists very well, but I've certainly noticed some people are motivated differently here. I guess on the Portnoy forum, the thing was more "how prog is the list?" The more prog a list was, the more popular it was, whether or not it was heavily swayed towards Dream Theater or any of Portnoy's other bands like Transatlantic or Liquid Tension Experiment.

I guess, for me personally, I want a list that is immensely enjoyable. I would rather a great, consistent list with no U2 than a somewhat decent list that happens to have a few U2 songs.

 

[LMP]

Heh, yes, you're right, but on the Portnoy forums, there wasn't a case of "but so-and-so has Dream Theater". I honestly don't remember the lists very well, but I've certainly noticed some people are motivated differently here. I guess on the Portnoy forum, the thing was more "how prog is the list?" The more prog a list was, the more popular it was, whether or not it was heavily swayed towards Dream Theater or any of Portnoy's other bands like Transatlantic or Liquid Tension Experiment.

I guess, for me personally, I want a list that is immensely enjoyable. I would rather a great, consistent list with no U2 than a somewhat decent list that happens to have a few U2 songs.

I see what you mean, I'd want a list with great songs that aren't restricted by who it's by, but I'd atleast like to hear Bono once.

 

[impy13]

I do believe 13 unanswered votes isn't going to happen.

 

[Total U2 Nut]

VertigoGal

 

[LMP]

Isn't this round over pretty soon?

I'm anxious for the next one

 

[Axver]

Well, this is embarrassing, I move the start time of the rounds and within only a few days, manage to lose my schedule again.

Next semi-final coming soon!