djerdap
Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2004
- Messages
- 7,605
That whole band is a plagiarized regret anyway.
David Bowie survivor - extraneous
- Thread starter cobl04
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
OP
OP
cobl04
45:33
Too far.
OP
OP
cobl04
45:33
ATTENTION EVERYONE!
We have 69 songs in the playoffs
How would people feel about the following... completely arbitrary, just came up with it right now.
David Bowie>Young Americans - 26 songs. Nine thru to final.
Station to Station>Lodger - 16 songs. Eight thru to final.
Scary Monsters>Extraneous - 27 songs. Four thru to final.
happy to change it!
We have 69 songs in the playoffs
How would people feel about the following... completely arbitrary, just came up with it right now.
David Bowie>Young Americans - 26 songs. Nine thru to final.
Station to Station>Lodger - 16 songs. Eight thru to final.
Scary Monsters>Extraneous - 27 songs. Four thru to final.
happy to change it!
OP
OP
cobl04
45:33
the songs going through:
Love You Til Tuesday
Space Oddity, Memory of a Free Festival
Width of a Circle, Black Country Rock, The Man Who Sold the World
Life on Mars?, Oh! You Pretty Things, Changes
Moonage Daydream, Ziggy Stardust, Suffragette City, Starman, Five Years, Lady Stardust
Panic in Detroit, Lady Grinning Soul, Aladdin Sane, Watch That Man, Time
Sorrow
Diamond Dogs, Sweet Thing, Rebel Rebel
Young Americans, Fame
Station to Station, Golden Years, Stay, Wild is the Wind
Sound and Vision, Always Crashing in the Same Car, A New Career in a New Town, Speed of Life, Subterraneans
Beauty and the Beast, "Heroes", Joe the Lion, Secret Life of Arabia
Look Back in Anger, Boys Keep Swinging, Fantastic Voyage
Scary Monsters, Ashes to Ashes, Fashion, Teenage Wildlife
Let's Dance, Modern Love
Blue Jean
Time Will Crawl
Heaven's in Here
As the World Falls Down
Nite Flights, Miracle Goodnight
Sex Church
Outside, Strangers When We Meet
Little Wonder
Thursday's Child
Sunday, Slow Burn
Fall Dog Bombs the Moon, Bring Me the Disco King
The Next Day, The Stars (Are Out Tonight), Love is Lost, Where Are We Now?
John I'm Only Dancing, Velvet Goldmine
Space Oddity, Memory of a Free Festival
Width of a Circle, Black Country Rock, The Man Who Sold the World
Life on Mars?, Oh! You Pretty Things, Changes
Moonage Daydream, Ziggy Stardust, Suffragette City, Starman, Five Years, Lady Stardust
Panic in Detroit, Lady Grinning Soul, Aladdin Sane, Watch That Man, Time
Sorrow
Diamond Dogs, Sweet Thing, Rebel Rebel
Young Americans, Fame
Station to Station, Golden Years, Stay, Wild is the Wind
Sound and Vision, Always Crashing in the Same Car, A New Career in a New Town, Speed of Life, Subterraneans
Beauty and the Beast, "Heroes", Joe the Lion, Secret Life of Arabia
Look Back in Anger, Boys Keep Swinging, Fantastic Voyage
Scary Monsters, Ashes to Ashes, Fashion, Teenage Wildlife
Let's Dance, Modern Love
Blue Jean
Time Will Crawl
Heaven's in Here
As the World Falls Down
Nite Flights, Miracle Goodnight
Sex Church
Outside, Strangers When We Meet
Little Wonder
Thursday's Child
Sunday, Slow Burn
Fall Dog Bombs the Moon, Bring Me the Disco King
The Next Day, The Stars (Are Out Tonight), Love is Lost, Where Are We Now?
John I'm Only Dancing, Velvet Goldmine
bono_212
Blue Crack Distributor
As always, here's what I did for The Cure:
Tier 1 albums (the 4 albums that received the most votes in the favorite album poll) had a total of 15 representative tracks. There was a survivor for those 15 tracks and 10 of them moved on to the final.
Tier 2 albums (the 5 albums that received the middle # of votes) had 13 representative tracks. The survivor also removed five tracks, sending 8 songs through to the final.
Finally Tier 3 albums (the bottom four plus B-Sides) had 21 total tracks. The survivor removed all but 6 songs, which moved on to the final.
In total, there were 24 songs in the Cure finals. You have room for 30 poll options, so you could do something similar, if you wanted to, so that the rounds weren't quite so arbitrary.
Tier 1 albums (the 4 albums that received the most votes in the favorite album poll) had a total of 15 representative tracks. There was a survivor for those 15 tracks and 10 of them moved on to the final.
Tier 2 albums (the 5 albums that received the middle # of votes) had 13 representative tracks. The survivor also removed five tracks, sending 8 songs through to the final.
Finally Tier 3 albums (the bottom four plus B-Sides) had 21 total tracks. The survivor removed all but 6 songs, which moved on to the final.
In total, there were 24 songs in the Cure finals. You have room for 30 poll options, so you could do something similar, if you wanted to, so that the rounds weren't quite so arbitrary.
OP
OP
cobl04
45:33
Ahh yes I forgot about that system.
So how about -
Low, Ziggy Stardust, Aladdin Sane, "Heroes", Station to Station. 23 songs. 11 songs go thru to final.
Hunky Dory, Scary Monsters, TMWSTW, Diamond Dogs, Lodger, Let's Dance, Next Day. 22 songs. 7 songs go thru to final.
The rest. 24 songs. 4 songs go thru to final.
22-song final.
So how about -
Low, Ziggy Stardust, Aladdin Sane, "Heroes", Station to Station. 23 songs. 11 songs go thru to final.
Hunky Dory, Scary Monsters, TMWSTW, Diamond Dogs, Lodger, Let's Dance, Next Day. 22 songs. 7 songs go thru to final.
The rest. 24 songs. 4 songs go thru to final.
22-song final.
Hewson
Blue Crack Supplier
We could just call it a 69 way tie.
iron yuppie
ONE love, blood, life
Cobbler, anything that narrows the field significantly is fine by me.
Similar threads
