Battle of the ridiculous hard rock comedy albums

[LemonMelon]

vs.

Here are two bands who released one classic album only to come back years later with a crappier one long after the joke had gotten stale.

The question is, which one of the above albums is a better artistic creation?

Tenacious D's debut is overlong, messy, but occasionally truly brilliant. Black actually has a good voice, and some of the instrumentation is fantastic. Plus, it has a clutch of really great songs. However, it's weighed down by pointless skits and a ton of filler. Spinal Tap's album is far more consistent and to the point, but it lacks the killer tracks of TD's album.

I may hold off on voting for a bit. I really like both of these.

 

[elevated_u2_fan]

I'm going with Spinal Tap cus they turn it up to 11

 

[impy13]

It's like, how much more easy could this decision be? And the answer is none. None more easy.

 

[corianderstem]

Exploding drummers ftw.

 

[discothequeLP]

lukewarm water ftw. how the fuck can you mess with BIG BOTTOM