American Idol 6 - Part 2

[Zoots]

Poor Phil. Simon was like "it was the whole hat and the eyes..." and Randy goes "Eyes??? You want him to change his eyes..?" or something like that. I was cracking up!

 

[Irvine511]

is it me, or did Chris Sligh just subtly call the really, really heterosexual Ryan Seacrest out on his gay baiting with Simon with the whole, "come on man, give me a hug."

i think i like him. he's smug, but on the good side of smug.

that said, they all kind of sucked tonight.

 

[kellyahern]

is it me, or did Chris Sligh just subtly call the really, really heterosexual Ryan Seacrest out on his gay baiting with Simon with the whole, "come on man, give me a hug."

Nope, not just you.

That was kind of awesome, wasn't it?

 

[MissVelvetDress_75]

to tonight's performers

Only performance I liked was Chris Sligh and he is the only one that should be there. I can't stand that guy who did the 311 song, the bald guy who did LeeAnn's song was awful, Sanjay and Sundance's Jermey was terrible. I felt it was a cover that I would have heard in a college bar. I agreed with Simon.

If any one of the male performers win American Idol this season, I will be suprised.

 

[Westport]

I like Phil. But is it me or does he kind of have a Gollum thing going on?

All in all, I'm bored this year. There is a lack of star potential with this group. Central casting gone bad or is this the muck of what's left of undiscovered American talent after six seasons?

A few of the girls are good but realistically could any of them sell records or attract a live audience? Melinda and Lakisha are sweethearts and have decent voices but I'm not excited about either.

Outside of Blake and Chris, the men are completely forgettable. Though I did love Sundance Head and his brilliant emotional sobbing fit last Thursday night.

Blake has the best overall commercial potential.

 

[cruzila]

Tonights episode is a snoozer. None of the guys impressed me. Out of the whole night, I think Blake has my vote.

 

[Lila64]

Nice to see you again Westport

 

[one4u2]

Tonight was

I think this show is becoming a little tired

 

[corianderstem]

I thought Sundance's "Jeremy" was awful, and I have now completely written him off. Last week was good karaoke, this week was mediocre, dime-a-dozen karaoke.

I didn't think much of Brandon one way or the other until he said he was a classically trained pianist. Now I'm all, "pianists unite!"

 

[RavenBlue]

Blake singing 311 was frikkin awesome. My fav of the night. I enjoyed Chris Sligh too.. I must be tone deaf because I thought he sounded alright

 

[corianderstem]

I thought Chris Sligh was just fine. I didn't like the song, but he sounded good.

Blake was my favorite. It's been ages since I heard that song.

 

[Lila64]

Liked Blake & Chris

I thought Sundance was so pitchy tonight. They can send the other 6 guys home

 

[Bonochick]

I still like Blake! Chris is a great singer, but his personality is starting to grate me.

 

[Irvine511]

Nope, not just you.

That was kind of awesome, wasn't it?

he's so irritating.

we all known Anderson Cooper is gay, and he doesn't explicitly deny it, and anyone who lives in New York knows he has a beautiful boyfriend named Julio. it's just not an issue with him, he doesn't address it.

Seacrest, on the other hand, who's every bit the "well known homosexual" that Cooper is, goes out of his way to appear straight -- remember his whole, "ah, the things we've all done to that song," after someone sang "sexual healing," and i got the heebie-jeebies -- and his pounding man-hug to Chris and his supertransparent grandchild-like kiss with Teri Hatcher .... ugh, he's so irritating like that.

still, he's good at what he does.

he's just the biggest freaking poser in the world.

but, hey, it's American Idol.

 

[BonoIsMyMuse]

I liked Blake, and then I liked that House came on after AI.

It wasn't that the others were bad (with the exception of Sanjaya--pretty boy needs to go home. He seems like a sweet kid, but he's so not ready for a professional singing career), they just weren't memorable. I kept wanting to go do other things instead of watching.

 

[Golightly Grrl]

AI Recaps-March 6th
The Top 8 Guys

Tonight the guys reveal little known secrets about themselves to the AI watching public. Fortunately, they are not too TMI about it. After hearing Jared dedicate “Let’s Get it On” to his parents, I don’t know how much I can take. Oh, there is some singing...allegedly.

Blake (All Mixed Up)-Blake let’s us know that he’s really into improv comedy. His alter ego Jimmy Walker Blue shows up...and mercifully leaves. Blake sings a 311 song showing that he’s current on today’s artists. Of course the judges aren’t aware of this song. I think their musical collections ended somewhere in 1987. Blake conveys another flavor to his singing by showing a reggae side. The beat boxing returns. I’m afraid the beat boxing might be too much of a crutch. It’s okay for now, but he might want to put the beat boxing away during the theme nights.

Sanjaya (Waiting on the World to Change)-Sanjaya’s little secret? He can hula dance. Okay, but can he perform better than he has in past weeks? Sadly, the answer is no. Sanjaya remains outclassed by other singers in the competition. He has no energy. Give this kid a Red Bull...or ten. However, I’m sure the power of his hair, whether curly, flat ironed, or looking like Paula’s, will bring in the tween vote. Parents of America, please ground your kids for a week and take away their phone privileges. I’m begging you, please!

Sundance (Jeremy)-Sundance reveals to us that he’s actually thin, but wears a fat suit on camera. Sundance sings an iconic Pearl Jam song. Wow, this song brings back memories, days and nights of wearing my Doc Martens and dying my hair black. Rock music is not Sundance’s strong point. I’m all for the power, but he shouted throughout the song. Sundance isn’t good enough to touch the hem of Eddie Vedder’s tattered flannel shirt. Sundance needs to jump back into his box and tape it shut. However, he’ll probably make it to the top 12 and torture me during theme weeks.

Chris R (Tonight I Wanna Cry)-Chris R was a football player and has lost 40 pounds since his gridiron days. I guess Sundance found them. Chris sings a Keith Urban country song and boy bands it for all it’s worth. Despite being nasally and boring, he gets a tongue bath from the judges. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s the Chosen One. I guess he seems safe, malleable and completely personality-free, the perfect candidate for AI to impose their narrowly-focused vision.

Jared (If You Really Love Me)-Jared played Division 2 basketball. He also sings a song by an artist that is way overplayed on AI, Stevie Wonder. I like Stevie Wonder, but enough is enough. Can we have a Stevie-free season? Jared does have a lot of energy and his voice did sound pretty good, but compared to most of this lot, that’s not saying much. It was good in a karaoke way, but not in a star-making way.

Brandon (I Just Want to Celebrate)-Brandon reveals he’s a classical pianist, but won’t be singing any classical music. Instead he charges things up a bit more since last week, and sings a high-energy song by Rare Earth. Despite a few runs that don’t work, Brandon brings a vibrancy and rock edge to his performance. I didn’t think he was unmemorable like Simon did, but I wonder if he’ll survive over lesser candidates (Sanjaya, I’m looking in your direction).

Phil (I Need You)-Our resident baldy used to have long hair, Then he joined a cult, I mean a college group, and cut his hair short. Phil sings a song that his voice can’t quite handle. To me, his voice is too unpleasant, very guttural. Between the stupid hat, and his odd voice, Phil is like a Muppet that sings. And the judges didn’t seem too thrilled with his song choice.

Chris S (We All Want to Be Loved)-Chris has a secret to tell us. Before he was Sideshow Bob, he used to have very short/shaved hair. Chris’ performance is probably the best of the night, but look at the guys I’m comparing him to. He doesn’t have much to compete with. Compared to past years, Chris would be totally wiped off the show by stronger and more talented singers. He should thank his lucky stars he’s competing against such a lackluster bunch. However, I will give him credit for picking a song by a group outside of the AI box, DC Talk. I’m sure it was a shout out to all of his Christian homies at Bob Jones University.

Once again, the guys are completely underwhelming, and I wouldn’t mind if most of them didn’t show up next week. I first thought I wasn’t getting into the show because I’ve been suffering from a bad head cold for the past few days (that’s my “reveal” for the week). But no, the guys are really, really bad. Mommy, make them stop.

 

[She Is Raging]

I'm just about to give up on this season, period. There are a few girls that are pretty good - but that's about it. Not that they don't usually show some sort of bias, but the judges arent even trying to be fair this season and stay somewhat neutral. It's completely obvious that Chris R. is being pimped for this season's winner, and I just don't get it.

 

[She Is Raging]

My post went through before I was done!

But seriously- is there anyone this season that even stands out as an individual? Blake is pretty good - but the beatbox is getting a little irritating. Last season there were at least a few people with unique, stand out voices that kept things interesting, and this year it's all total glorified karaokee. (sp?)

 

[kellyahern]

he's so irritating.

we all known Anderson Cooper is gay, and he doesn't explicitly deny it, and anyone who lives in New York knows he has a beautiful boyfriend named Julio. it's just not an issue with him, he doesn't address it.

Seacrest, on the other hand, who's every bit the "well known homosexual" that Cooper is, goes out of his way to appear straight -- remember his whole, "ah, the things we've all done to that song," after someone sang "sexual healing," and i got the heebie-jeebies -- and his pounding man-hug to Chris and his supertransparent grandchild-like kiss with Teri Hatcher .... ugh, he's so irritating like that.

still, he's good at what he does.

he's just the biggest freaking poser in the world.

but, hey, it's American Idol.

I saw Teri Hatcher on Oprah, and she said after that kiss, she never heard from him again .

Irvine, why must you destroy my fantasies that Anderson Cooper is really straight? Why?

 

[BonoIsMyMuse]

Between the stupid hat, and his odd voice, Phil is like a Muppet that sings.

I really hope he and Sanjaya go home this week.

 

[Headache in a Suitcase]

Simon is an idiot! That is how Pearl Jam's Jeremy is supposed to be sung.

that was awful... i threw up in my mouth a little bit.

 

[Regina Filangie]

I wonder if the ratings will decline next year. So many long time fans, myself included, seem to be really bored with this season.
I'm only still watching because I've been sucked in and have to see it through to the end now, but I'm not sure I'll tune in next year.
Also, Sanjaya is a very sweet kid but his hair is distracting to the point that it's all I can focus on when he performs.

 

[RavenBlue]

Phil kinds of creeps me out a bit. He's like a thin Mr.Clean.

 

[MrsSpringsteen]

I missed it last night, sounds like I didn't miss anything

tmz.com

Nigel Lythgoe, executive producer of "American Idol," has just released a statement in response to criticism made against the show by "View" host Rosie O'Donnell. It reads:

"Without wishing to add to the obvious self-promotion of Ms. O'Donnell, I feel as though I must refute her absurd and ridiculous claims that 'American Idol' is racist and/or weightist.

"Ms. O'Donnell has, once again, spoken without thought or knowledge. Viewers need only look at the show tonight to realize that 'American Idol' constantly confirms to America that talent has nothing to do with weight or color."

It was Rosie's comments on Tuesday's episode of "The View" that drew "Idol's" ire. Rosie called the show "weightist and racist" over the way it has handled the Antonella Barba photo scandal this season, as opposed to when it booted contestant Frenchie Davis for the same thing. Although an "Idol" spy tells us that the difference is that Frenchie was paid for her pre-Idol porn, while Antonella's photos were private, and published without her knowledge or permission.

 

[corianderstem]

Although an "Idol" spy tells us that the difference is that Frenchie was paid for her pre-Idol porn, while Antonella's photos were private, and published without her knowledge or permission.

Hey, that was my guess! I'm so s-m-r-t.

 

[U2isthebest]

How dare they let Antonella ruin a Corrine Bailey Rae song! That was awful. Honey, it's not a power shouting song.

 

[cruzila]

 

[kellyahern]

Like I said last week, just give it to Melinda. Seriously, save us all a few months and give it to her now. She's so good, she's almost a ringer.

I want Simon to call me a tiger.

 

[Zoots]

that was awful... i threw up in my mouth a little bit.

Well... I agree it wasn't great. But Simon said something like you shouted the whole way thru. But Simon, you idiot.. how do you sing a song like Jeremy without at least screaming a bit?

 

[Zoots]

I was so bored by the show last night that I text voted for Sanjaya just to see if this idiotic show (and I guess the audience that votes for him) actually ends up making him Idol.

Tonight was quite boring too except for Melinda, Lakisha and maybe Gina. Voted for Melinda. She's the best.