SYCMIOYO Video - BBC Top Of The Pops 18-02-2005

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

enajh2

Refugee
Joined
Jul 26, 2002
Messages
1,815
Location
Loughborough, UK
SYCMIOYO Video - BBC Top Of The Pops 18-02-2005

I believe this to be the other of the two performances/takes they performed indoors :)

Comparing this with "U2_SYCMIOYO_TOTPs_14-01-2005.wmv", I'm led to believe they performed it twice; once with both verses and once without. The camera tracking etc appears to be the same but I think they are different and hence the first broadcast (when Busted split up) was not a bad edit but what they performed on the day :up:

WMV video is here http://homepage.ntlworld.com/alan.hazell/U2/

DVD video, vob file http://www.must-suck.net/ (the source I used for my wmv clip)

:wave:

Alan
 
I was at the show and they didn't record it twice. It's the same take, just a different edit.

Thanks for putting it up here!
 
Dutch Partygirl said:
I was at the show and they didn't record it twice. It's the same take, just a different edit.

Thanks for putting it up here!

Ha! Thanks!

I was annoyed by the haters when the first clip came out that said nope, they sang it that way cause Bono probably couldn't hit the siiiiiiiing
:blahblah: :blahblah:

I knew it had to be an edit... I saw what they did with Brooklyn and knew it was a case of the same thing...

And once again, thanks Alan! :wink:
 
Maybe you can't spot the edit points because they were filming it with A LOT of cameras?? (I'm not very familiar with the technical aspect of all of this)
 
enajh2 said:
SYCMIOYO Video - BBC Top Of The Pops 18-02-2005

I believe this to be the other of the two performances/takes they performed indoors :)

Comparing this with "U2_SYCMIOYO_TOTPs_14-01-2005.wmv", I'm led to believe they performed it twice; once with both verses and once without. The camera tracking etc appears to be the same but I think they are different and hence the first broadcast (when Busted split up) was not a bad edit but what they performed on the day :up:

WMV video is here http://homepage.ntlworld.com/alan.hazell/U2/

DVD video, vob file http://www.must-suck.net/ (the source I used for my wmv clip)

:wave:

Alan

Alan,

How do I open stuff from you homepage?
I mean I can see the green "online" words but there is nothing to click on (not for me anyhow) I DO know that I've had access before but lately I haven't been able to open anything:confused:

I haven't asked this before because I thought it was a temporary thing, but i guess that's not it.
 
Back
Top Bottom