The album version isn't half bad at all. Not too interesting, but it's not horrible like Red Light or Babyface. Just... to me nothing special I guess. I loved the EU video for it though, Bono being kicked out of a van.
I'm glad they're not playing it live anymore. It was really annoying hearing it every show.. if they would play it full electric like on the Elevation tour, that'd be actually quite cool. But acoustic? God I cannot stand that abomination. I don't even knwo what it is about it that turns me off so badly.. I love Edge's falsetto, but the acoustic treatment doesn't work for most of U2's songs. Same with Stay, I absolutely ADORE the album version and love the electric Zooropa tour version, but acoustic live? It was decent at most. Meh, maybe I'm hanging out in the setlist forum too much..
Though I still don't give a crap for the static setlists.