With or Without You Yes or no?

[ShellBeThere]

I just got done listening to it in the boot of Chi 4, and I thought it sounded great! I like it there in the setlist, think it can work perfectly well as a close to main set...

 

[MTEdge]

Yes. I got butterflies listening to the Chi4 version. The Edge almost went off on a solo. Larry played the drums as he played them on the album version for most of the song. Adam was, well, Adam.

Based on a listen of that version, I feel the band is working out some kinks for a revised longer version that will be played once every two or three shows.

 

[broken toy]

No.

If they play it, I'll enjoy it... but then be disappointed if they don't do the Joy Division thingy.

 

[daygloeyes2]

Yes, but if they don't play it it's not going to ruin my show.

 

[Ellay]

Nay

 

[vanessajones82]

They need that song. But, if I ever heard them play it, I'd have to change my underwear. Hell, if I ever see them, I'll just not wear underwear.

 

[Ghostwriter]

Finally got a chance to listen to it from Chi4. Much, much better. However, given the number of different ways this song's been played over the years I can tell U2 aren't completely happy with the way it sounds live. It seems it's different every tour, and the sound often changes during the middle of a tour as well. If they'd just go back to playing like in JT/LT it'd be fine.

 

[ayearwome]

They need that song. But, if I ever heard them play it, I'd have to change my underwear. Hell, if I ever see them, I'll just not wear underwear.

Nice!

 

[DPrinceNY]

Duh! play it!
ask me a harder question

 

[redkat]

YES please! I was just listening to the chicago version and it does sound much different than it used to but the emotion is still there and it gave me goosebumps. Love the strangers snippet at the end.

 

[barrett]

Yes. They did a really good version in Chicago 4. The casual fans really expect this song to be played.

 

[Yahweh_OMG]

nooooooo

 

[susanp6]

Yes!

 

[popacrobat]

play it sparingly

 

[bigwali]

After listening to Chicago IV.....

Absolutely...No Question!...WOWY.....WOW