(07-13-2004) Note to Clay: Leave the U2 Tunes Alone -- Lexington Herald-Leader

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

dsmith2904

ONE love, blood, life
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
12,290
Location
Just keep me where the light is
Note to Clay: Leave the U2 Tunes Alone

By Walter Tunis

CONTRIBUTING MUSIC CRITIC


"You all shout like I can hear what you say," said a bemused Clay Aiken last night at Rupp Arena.

Granted, the screams, cheers and overall jubilation of the largely female crowd was certainly an audience force for this American Idol celebrity to reckon with. But with a turnout of only 3,000 -- a figure that seemed smaller given that Rupp's full-house seating configuration was employed -- Aiken easily held court over the crowd with a two-set, two-hour performance devoted to mostly cheery and calculated pop fare.

On the plus side, Aiken performed as a capable if not terribly daring singer. His voice easily sailed up to the higher registers on This is the Night and cooled to ballad timbre for the comparatively hushed I Survived You. It was also refreshing to see an artist so obviously designed to meet the expectations of a teen pop audience play to all ages. At one point, an older patron was escorted onstage to dance with the singer during the radio-friendly pop of When You Say You Love Me.

In essence, what you got from Aiken was what you have been seeing on TV in the past year: a likeable, politely unrefined pop personality with a wholesome voice, who doesn't fall back on cheesy choreography, video-friendly theatrics or, worse, lip-synching during a stage performance.

But when Aiken ventured into deeper waters, there were problems. For example, who thought it was a good idea for him to open the concert with U2's Where the Streets Have No Name? The song boasts a social resonance way, way beyond the singer's grasp. A mid-show medley of James Taylor tunes, which included an overly stoic and stilted reading of Sweet Baby James, sounded equally out of place.

The more appropriate cover tunes -- and there are loads of them -- steered to the safer pop-fabric framework Aiken updated on his 2003 album, Measure of a Man. Such jukebox fare included: Mr. Mister's Kyrie, Orleans' Still the One, Toto's Rosanna and an encore of Neil Sedaka's Solitaire. All come from a middle-of-the-road base that has become a clear comfort zone for the singer.

In her second Lexington concert in as many months, opening act Cherie, a 19-year-old French singer with a booming vocal command, used her self-titled debut album as the basis for a surprisingly comprehensive pop presentation.

--Lexington Herald-Leader
 
For example, who thought it was a good idea for him to open the concert with U2's Where the Streets Have No Name? The song boasts a social resonance way, way beyond the singer's grasp.
My thoughts exactly!
 
I hate American Idol...I hate Clay Aiken..and I swear to God if he ever attempts to sing MY favorite U2 tune of all time...well, we're going to have a little problem. 'Nuff said. :mad:
 
You know, I bet alot of Clay Aiken fans don't even know he's singing a U2 song there (but why would they?)

:shrug:
 
I think Clay Aiken should seriously be arrested for doing this, I thought Cher sampling Still havent found was bad, this is awful. I need to sit down and take deep breaths for awhile because im gettin upset.
 
RademR said:
I think Clay Aiken should seriously be arrested for doing this, I thought Cher sampling Still havent found was bad, this is awful. I need to sit down and take deep breaths for awhile because im gettin upset.

I got so pissed off I had to run around the block a few times!!!
 
RademR said:
Cher sampling Still havent found was bad, this is awful.

I saw this act of horror in person - I actually went to a Cher show. That she sung it to begin with was awful - it was the fact that she was riding a chandelier that really put me off. :|
 
HelloAngel said:


I saw this act of horror in person - I actually went to a Cher show. That she sung it to begin with was awful - it was the fact that she was riding a chandelier that really put me off. :|

I saw it too, only on TV , I almost jumped out the window.:|
 
najeena said:
Cher singing ISHFWILF, while riding a chandelier. It defies even the most flexible imagination.

Oh come on...it's Cher. It's a campy opening; not meant to be serious, and I'm not even the greatest fan of Cher, but it worked for her.

Now Clay Aiken? He's not meant to be campy or a joke, and his voice is so very "Star Search"--e.g., he should be singing benefits for starving children, not cutting albums.

Melon
 
Artists that don't belong in the music industry:
Cher
Clay Aiken
Ruben Studdard
Britney Spears
Cher
Justin Timberlake
Cher
All other teen pop singers/groups
Cher
 
well, just give the man a break. who knows he could be a U2 fan and just wants to pay tribute and so much so he can not hide it == regardless if he gives justification to the song or not. Maybe we should hear from clay? why really clay, why?:eyebrow: :eyebrow:
 
desire25 said:
well, just give the man a break. who knows he could be a U2 fan and just wants to pay tribute and so much so he can not hide it == regardless if he gives justification to the song or not. Maybe we should hear from clay? why really clay, why?:eyebrow: :eyebrow:

:up:. Exactly. Really, I'm not a big fan of Clay's music, either, but I don't really mind the guy-he seems like a nice person, he can sing...him doing this song doesn't really bother me. Maybe I'm weird, but I just don't care.

Originally posted by HelloAngel
You know, I bet alot of Clay Aiken fans don't even know he's singing a U2 song there (but why would they?)

:shrug:

Actually, my sister's part of this Clay Aiken board (she was the one who told me about him doing the U2 song to begin with-she noticed mention of it from people who'd gone to his concerts thus far), and there's lots of Clay fans there who know full well that he's doing a U2 song. Why wouldn't they know who that song's originally by?

Angela
 
what about this norwegian guy who won the world idol? I was amazed at his voice!! so close to bono's.:wink:
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom