IWasBored
Blue Crack Supplier
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2002
- Messages
- 36,783
At least WOAD was all-new material.
Maybe this will surprise us. Maybe with Morello it will have a uniqueness to it and that's why Bruce is getting this out there. Maybe the revisions will work out. Maybe it will actually rock.
But I'm quite concerned. This smells like a total rush job. High Hopes is a cover that he already did. Harry's Place is from The Rising sessions and you wonder how it relates to Mary's Place. American Skin is over a decade old and already available in studio form courtesy of a promo single (and of course it's available live as well). We all know about The Ghost Of Tom Joad (has there ever been a title track to an album re-released on a different album?). The Wall has been around for years (albeit unreleased), and Dream Baby Dream is available already as a live cover from the Devils & Dust tour.
Yes, it means more touring, and that's a definite plus. I get it. But at the expense of what? A new album that is a partial rehash job that will downgrade the latter part of his discography? There are other ways to continue a tour in 2014. You don't need a new album to do it. How about an EP with just the new songs? I'd be all over that.
Wrecking Ball is a great album. Take some time, release some other projects (The River and BITUSA box sets are due anyway) or the aforementioned EP, and come back with a strong follow-up later.
but it was all bad, all new material. no silver lining there at all.
i definetly agree that you don't need a new album to tour, and it's especially transparent when your new album is a throw-away collection of stuff that is really only going to appeal to the same die-hards that already have whatever versions are already lurking around. at the same time, i can't say i like the idea of getting price-gouged on a super deluxe box set version of entire albums i already own, either.
as for a studio version of 41 shots, i wonder if that was what i was confusing the lack of studio version of land of hopes and dreams with when we got that last time around. cos i was under the impression there was one prior to it re-surfacing, but then you guys told me there wasn't...