Quadrophenia - is it one of the greatest rock records of all time?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

cobl04

45:33
Joined
Jun 3, 2005
Messages
59,327
Location
East Point to Shaolin
I vote an emphatic yes.

Continuing my 'musical discovery' I brought Who's Next some time ago and immediately fell in love from the moment Baba O'Riley graced my ears. And the brilliance doesn't end there. Songs like Song is Over. Getting in Tune. Won't Get Fooled Again. My Wife - the horns!! - . Behind Blue Eyes (forever desecrated by the disgusting Limp Bizkit cover). And then there's all the additions which are on my version. Pure and Easy. Water. I Don't Know Myself. The list is endless.

Then I wanted another album. I chose Sell Out, simply because it was cheaper than Quadrophenia. I still don't like it much. It's got its classics, your I Can See For Miles, and other gems like Armenia City in the Sky, Our Love Was, Tattoo, Odorono, and great additions like Hall of the Mountain King. But it is overshadowed by the above and belted into submission by the following.

Quadrophenia - and I know at least Zoots will agree with me - is fucking incredible. Most concept or double albums miss a beat, there's filler, etc etc etc, but not here. 80 odd minutes of unbelievable music. The story is relatively easy to follow too, and, unlike Roger Waters, Pete makes sure the story doesn't get excessively in the way of the music. It's a story that is relatable, a key element with concept albums. Everyone can find something in it to salvage.

You've got The Real Me, which gets proceedings off to the most rocking, best possible start, complete with some damn fine Entwistle. There's Quadrophenia, my third favourite instrumental of all time, behind A New Career in a New Town and Any Colour You Like. A magical six minutes. The choruses!

Zoot suit!
White jacket with sides
That were five inches long
I'm out on the street again
And I'm leaping along!
Dressed right
For a beach fight
But I just can't explain
Why this uncertain feeling is still here in my brain...


My jacket's gonna be cut slim and checked
Maybe a touch of seersucker and an open neck
I ride a GS scooter with my hair cut neat
I wear my war time coat in the wind and sleet


Helpless Dancing, the battling vocals, and that awesome outro that leads up to "You stop dancing!" One of The Who's finest, The Punk and the Godfather, which combines the best of Daltrey and Townshend's vocals. Roge's verses (sometimes self-referencing) rock - "I'm the punk with the stutter!" -, while Pete's "I have to be careful not to preach..." verse is perfect. How good's The Dirty Jobs? "I am a man who looks after the pigs... I'm not gonna sit and weep again." The end of side one doesn't disappoint either, I've Had Enough's verses are powerfully sung.

Side two remembers Cut My Hair before launching into a bit of manic Bowie with 5:15, which is just one of the best Who songs, period, and shows why Daltrey was one of, if not the, best singers going around. The entire second half, save for The Rock, is just about unbeatable. Sea and Sand is flawless, has touching lyrics, and again recalls I've Had Enough. Drowned is simple, and has a wonderful, accessible chorus that really shows the story from Jimmy's eyes. Bell Boy is almost my favourite off the album. (My opinion is Drowned is when Jimmy is out on his own, just reflecting, but still high on leapers. The Rock/Love Reign O'er Me is when his life flashes before him - hence the unfortunate necessity of The Rock - but this time he has come down, and reality hits). Probably is; it's so hard to pick and choose. The verses are incredible, and you won't find many better throughout music history. Roger really excels here, and is helped out by the rest of the band. And then the accent comes in and surprisingly mixes in effortlessly with the music, and just adds another level.

Doctor Jimmy is nothing short of exhilirating. Eight minutes without a second wasted, and you can't help but adore those lyrics.

What is it? I'll take it.
Who is she? I'll rape it.
Got a bet there? I'll meet it.
Getting high? You can't beat it.

Doctor Jimmy and Mister Jim
When I'm pilled you don't notice him
He only comes out when I drink my gin

You say she's a virgin
Well I'm gonna be the first in
Her fella's gonna kill me?
Oh fucking will he


Really gives an insight into the warped teenage mind. The instrumentation's astonishing. Finally there's Love Reign O'er Me, which, after over an hour of staggering music, provides even more highlights with the soft, beautiful piano intro, and then provides the best example of the might of Roger Daltrey's voice. No wonder he says The Who are at their best when he sings Pete's songs. Somehow, the band manage to top all that has come before it on this song, the solos are incredible.

Now let's appreciate.
 
It's been years since I've listened to it in its entirety, but 5:15, The Real Me, and Love Reign O'er Me are three absolute classic songs.

I still prefer early, goofier, more playful and less bombastic Who, though.
 
I still prefer early, goofier, more playful and less bombastic Who, though.

You and me both.

Regardless, Quadrophenia has a place in my heart, and I can appreciate its ambition, scope, and clutch of classic songs. I just don't think it's their finest work.
 
Quadrophenia is everything Tommy wishes it was.

Who's Next is also fantastic.
 
There is a significant amount of bombast, yes, but it's immaterial to me. Listen to I think it's the end of The Real Me, or 5:15 maybe. There's bass, guitar, drums, bass, piano and horns all at once :faint:

I don't own Tommy, and don't really plan to either, unless someone gifts it to me.
 
Tommy sucks. The Who Sell Out was so much better executed, and it isn't laughably pretentious.
 
If it drops in price, I'll definitely get it. But we're not here to talk about that. Lemel, feel free to bump your 'Tommy sucks' thread, it was a ripper.

And let's talk about how utterly awesome Bell Boy is.
 
Wow! How did I miss this thread?

Yes indeed. This album is really really brilliant! I do have a thing for rock operas and concept albums where the themes get repeated but that said, everything on Quadrophenia is perfect.. the music, the lyrics, the vocals.. damn! Despite not being all that fond of Drowned or Bell Boy (they're okay), this album is in my Top 10 albums of all-time. Was listening to it again today on good speakers and I was pretty much :combust: ing all over again.

The transition from Doctor Jimmy to The Rock = :faint:
 
Quadrophenia has ranked among my all-time favorite albums for quite some time, and shows no signs of relinquishing its spot in the top five. The band is firing on all cylinders, most notably Townshend on lyrics: perhaps only Morrissey has ever given such expressive voice to alienation and existential angst.

And, as Zoots commented, Doctor Jimmy / The Rock / Love Reign O'er Me is among the best trilogies in rock history.
 
:up: to you both. it's firmly in my top five.

Bell Boy is an awesome song, just about my favourite, is it those cockney accent verses that put you off Zoots?

The only song I really don't care for is The Rock. It adds absolutely nothing and to me is a real bore.



desperately hoping Pearl Jam play The Real Me or Love Reign O'er Me when I see them on the 20th
 
Bell Boy is an awesome song, just about my favourite, is it those cockney accent verses that put you off Zoots?

Well, nah.. the cockney doesn't bug me all that much, it's actually kind of amusing. But the song itself just isn't as catchy as most of the rest I guess.
 
"Bell Boy" is pants-shittingly awesome. Probably my favorite track off of an unbelievable record, maybe Top 5 for the Who as well. Since you're wondering:

1. A Quick One, While He's Away
2. The Seeker
3. Won't Get Fooled Again
4. Bell Boy
5. Substitute
 
Well, nah.. the cockney doesn't bug me all that much, it's actually kind of amusing. But the song itself just isn't as catchy as most of the rest I guess.

i think it's the catchiest song on there, for mine anyway.

The Real Me
Quadrophenia
The Punk and the Godfather
5:15
Sea and Sand
Bell Boy
Doctor Jimmy
Love Reign O'Me...

:drool:
 
Get a job and fight to keep it
Strike out to reach a mountain
Be so nice on the outside
But inside keep ambition

:drool:

reminds me of these lines 4 years later:

And after a while, you can work on points for style
Like the club tie, and the firm handshake
A certain look in the eye and an easy smile
You have to be trusted by the people that you lie to
So that when they turn their backs on you
You'll get the chance to put the knife in

:drool:
 
Back
Top Bottom