I'm actually less enamored with the album on second listen. It's bizarre as hell, sporadically beautiful, often repetitive, and always misguided. A few tracks are awesome and will stick with me, but I'm a bit nonplussed about the rest.
Incredible:
Futile Devices
I Walked
Impossible Soul
Cool:
Get Real Get Right
Bad Communication
Whatever:
Too Much
Now That I'm Older
Vesuvius
All For Myself
Hopeless:
Age of Adz
I Want To Be Well (most pretentious lyrics in the history of time; Sufjan even speaks to himself in the third person)
I want to compare this to Justin Vernon's horrendous Volcano Choir side project, but much of this album is actually salvageable. I just couldn't imagine sitting through this live when he's ignoring Romulus, Detroit, the entirety of Seven Swans and Casimir Pulaski Day. Like Dalton said, I'm sure the crowd reaction would be the highlight.