LCD Soundsystem: One Thread Is Never Enough

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
They get a :up: from me.

I'm so glad someone else loves Black Screen as well. I saw a lot of mixed responses to it when the album first leaked but I think people are coming around.
 
I would agree with the general scope of the rankings, Cobbler. IMO one of the album's only flaws is a relatively weak opening duo. Then it kicks into four stunners in a row. Emotional haircut doesn't make a lot of sense where it is placed, either - American dream into black screen would have been a hell of a closing punch.
 
After 2 listens:

American Dream
Oh Baby
Call the Police
How Do You Sleep?
Black Screen
Tonite
I Used To
Emotional Haircut
Other Voices
Change Yr Mind

A great album that I'm enjoying more with each listen.
 
Black Screen is so fucking moving because of the Bowie ties. How open and honest he is about his regrets and anxieties surrounding working with him:

You couldn't make our wedding day, too sick to travel
You fell between a friend, and a father

Been saving email trails, kept together
I read them back sometimes to remember
The time I wrote to you, from the island
Your quick replies made me high

I had fear in the room, so I stopped turning up
My hands kept pushing down in my pockets
I’m bad with people things
But I should have tried more

Been watching images from the station
Earth one from satellites, all streaming
Feels slow at seventeen thousand miles an hour
You could be anywhere
On the black screen
On the black screen
On the black screen
On the black screen
On the black screen
You could be anywhere
On the black screen


Heartbreaking.
 
I have heard Call The Police a shitload of times on the radio and have been pretty unimpressed with it, but given how highly folks here rate the album I think I'll give it a crack. I don't have much familiarity with LCD aside from that.
 
Right. Have had my listen through with music and lyrics and wine and good headphones and it's definitely somewhat the wine talking but this might actually be their best album. It's also really fucking easy to forget that James Murphy does 95% of the music, which makes it wildly more impressive, because he really only sings live. But he's doing the vast, vast majority of the percussion, guitars and synths. Could work out that way in the end. Now onto the track by track review with all small caps.

oh baby 8
interested to hear from lm what he likes so much about this one. i wonder if it's the same as me. first few listens, i thought yeah this is nice as hell, but it's also a bit plodding and takes forever to get going, if it does at all. like why the fuck did they pick this as an opener? but that's the thing about LCD sometimes... they suck you in. this is an absolutely beautiful song, and i would argue, one of the best pure love songs of recent times. i connected deeply with this, as i love my girlfriend a lot and she has night terrors (bad dreams) sometimes. i think what this song also does well is let you know that James Murphy is in this 1000%, it sounds so fucking genuine and immediately wipes away all fears that this comeback was misguided. just a full-hearted love song that builds and releases too. amazing.

other voices 7
the 6 is an 'LCD 6', so for other artists would be a 7. the shit cooks, but there's always been these fast-paced but somewhat pedestrian tracks on LCD albums: One Touch, half of their pre-s/t tracks, Time to Get Away. The best part for sure is the "please / if yr coming home" verse, which is backed (and followed by) Fripp guitar from Another Green World. The Eno influences are everywhere, as they have always been. ACTUALLY FUCK IT, when Nancy comes in that shit deserves another point. 7. wicked AF.

i used to 9
the percussion on this song alone is reason enough for this album to exist, particularly when that synth bloops come in 40 seconds in. i wish there were more lines in the verses, cos they sound so wicked, but a very minor complaint. just a fucking slow, sly, motherfucking monster this track. and fucking dark, too. this album is fucking dark as fuck.

change yr mind 9
as iyup said above, 70s bowie. James has done Berlin Trilogy Bowie for fucking ages (Get Innocuous) but this is the best he has done it by miles. Get Innocuous is beat-led, whereas this is full of the tortured guitar that lords over Low and "Heroes" and Lodger. i'm extraordinarily tempted to give this song a 10 because i have waited day and night for a record that features the sounds and textures of "Heroes" (the album) and this song probably comes closer than anything i (or LM, who I've also had on the case) have ever heard. it is a fucking sensational song, this one. lyrically, i wonder if this is about the comeback; he announced it in january 2016 but the album didn't get announced til july 2017.

how do you sleep? 10
everyone loves "dance yrself clean", and with good reason, but this track is like dance yrself clean in a fucking way darker space. the percussion absolutely cooks for ages, building and building, with strings added as well and this absolutely incredible far-off vocal from James that actually does sound like he's on a shore and then 3 minutes and 38 seconds in the synth comes fucking slamming down and then about 90 seconds of more buildup later it's all guns blazing. lyrically this is another one that i wonder speaks to Bowie - "you warned me about the cocaine / then dove straight in" - but it could be anyone. but i really think Bowie's spectre is all over this record. it doesn't haunt it, but it certainly informs it. anyway, i cannot wait to hear this song live. and i think one of the measures of whether this comeback should exist should be "are there songs off the new record that i would happily have replace old tracks in the setlist?" and this song answers that question affirmatively.

tonite 9
i have no idea how LCD managed to make this song sound so fucking retro. this could very, very easily be a forgotten offcut from a proto-electro 70s album, but it's here as a bonafide single. a banger, as i've said. the last two verses of this song are also tremendous lyrically, from one line to the next, combined with the way that the music and has vocals pick up pace before diffusing over a huge beat. just sensational. the last lines in particular:
still making mistakes that you thought you had learned from
...
you've been badgered and taunted and told that yr missing a party that you'll never get over
you hate the idea that yr wasting yr youth
that you stood in the background until you get older
but
that's
all lies


call the police 8
probably the only track that for me sounds at times a little ham-fisted. i can't stand the elongated intro, and it takes a solid one and a half minutes (when the guitar comes in at the end of the 'moving to Berlin' line) to really start hitting its straps. as i've said before, this is a U2 song, and if U2 came out with it, i'd be over the goddamn fucking moon, but not quite LCD. but then it starts getting going and you get swept up in the majesty of it. the guitar is fantastic, the lyrics are really quite cutting and insightful and actually relevant - the 'call the police' refrains at the end are actually aimed at conservative culture war fuckwits. and the searing guitar at the end of the choruses is sensational. FUCK IT, i'm bumping this to an 8 for the lyrics, the last four minutes and the ending is dope as hell ("they're gonna eat the rich!!")

american dream 10
this song is actually a fucking marvel. holy shit do i fucking adore this song so deeply. it was my favourite of the double a-side from the start and it has proved to be an even better song the more you listen. again, it has those huge synths that are found on Bowie's 70s work (this one in particular is a 'Low' song) and it has this incredible dichotomy between the synth-waltz underpinning it and the interstellar pull of the vocals and the chorus synths, which manages to tug the heartstrings with great fervour too. again, i wonder if this is another Bowie nod - "he was leather and he was screaming (even the way he sings these lines actually sounds like Bowie at times) / you couldn't know he was leaving / but now more will go with age you know" - but the other striking thing about this song is that it can also be taken as a very small, grounded song, just the point of view of a downtrodden man who is looking for some solace, whether it be acid in the morning or just the heartbeat of cacophonous music. (also added points for the "oh the revolution was here / that would set you free from the bourgeoisie") just a fucking tremendous, tremendous song.

emotional haircut 7
this album's "drunk girls" and "watch the tapes" - the guitar-led, fast-paced in-and-out banger. and yet unlike those tracks, it still hits you with emotional resonance in the form of the lines iYup mentioned above. "you got life-affirming moments in yr past that you can't repeat" is a fucking heart-tearer, in a song that both is (getting a haircut to tie yourself to a certain time) and isn't (fastpaced rocker) an emotional song. it's an extremely significant line; if you took "All My Friends" and tried to distill it into one line, that's what you'd get. also, this song fucking cooks, so there's that. gonna be sick fun live.

black screen X
this one was so unexpected for me. the first few times i listened to this album, i did so without lyrics, but this was the one song that also struck me as carrying significant emotional heft. and i think the mark of a great, heartpulling song is one that hits you without you having sat with the lyrics. it's completely unique in LCD Soundsystem's catalogue; the droning is different to the droning songs they've done before, as it's so gentle, and lasts so much longer than any of their slower songs (the only long-lasting LCD songs prior to this all have a pulse - Yeah, dance yrself clean, beat connection, etc etc etc). again, we get Berlin-era Bowie synths throughout, but this time they're punctuated by the heaviest vocals that James Murphy has EVER committed to tape; usually in the past, in LCD's most emotionally resonant tracks, there was always something at stake and you could hear that in the vocals (All My Friends, Home). Someone Great is this track's closest cousin, but it too still has far too much momentum to compete. again i wonder if this one is talking about Bowie, but even if it's someone else, it still cuts through so hard for seven straight minutes, it's a heartbreaking lyric, and yet, you can get through it, because James Murphy takes you with him. it's a togetherness song. he sounds ~somewhat~ resigned, but it's that ~relative~ resignation that allows the listener to come along for the ride. the moment when Al Doyle's piano comes in at about the 7:30 mark is so beautiful, and then the last four or so minutes are, dare i say it, the most fucking beautiful in LCD's entire catalogue, Someone Great excepted.

so all in all i think this a fucking tremendous album and if i ever ANYONE ever say again that they're shitty about the LCD comeback after the elongated goodbye i will fucking flip my shit, because this album immediately dissolves all that. this album proves that this is just a band who still has a fucking awful lot to say. i think this is definitely James Murphy's most lyrically hard-hitting album, pound-for-pound, and i think the music around it gives it a further elevating quality.

i fucking adore this band and i hope i have expressed my feelings about this record and comeback well enough. xo
Please keep posting stuff like this, it's great.

I'm pretty impressed after 1.5 listens. How Do You Sleep really is a banger. I have to disagree about Other Voices though, it's another highlight.
 
The first half of How Do You Sleep? reminds me of Nick Cave. I think it's the combination of Murphy's delivery and the percussion.

I like Emotional Haircut except for the parts when they say emotional haircut.

Good morning to everyone except Impy and the two cops who have given me speeding tickets over the last five weeks.
 
I can't remember the last time I've heard an album that sounds so immense and yet deeply personal and melancholic at the same time. In so many places, it feels like Murphy mixed Bowie's Low into the grandiosity of past LCD albums. I also love that even though it's a return for the band, American Dream still moves forward and sounds like nothing else in their catalog. The vocals on "How Do You Sleep?" are jaw-dropping in places.

And that's not even getting into the flawless second half. The run from "Tonite" to "Black Screen" feels unbelievable. I kept expecting one of the songs to be a bit weaker or cool off the streak but it just keeps going and getting better. "Black Screen" is one of their most emotional moments and a beautiful tribute to Bowie. I have no problem putting it right alongside "Someone Great" in terms of its cathartic impact.

After a couple of listens, I think I'd put "American Dream" above everything they've done outside of "Sound of Silver." Definitely one of the best "reunion" albums ever produced.
 
I can't remember the last time I've heard an album that sounds so immense and yet deeply personal and melancholic at the same time. In so many places, it feels like Murphy mixed Bowie's Low into the grandiosity of past LCD albums. I also love that even though it's a return for the band, American Dream still moves forward and sounds like nothing else in their catalog. The vocals on "How Do You Sleep?" are jaw-dropping in places.

And that's not even getting into the flawless second half. The run from "Tonite" to "Black Screen" feels unbelievable. I kept expecting one of the songs to be a bit weaker or cool off the streak but it just keeps going and getting better. "Black Screen" is one of their most emotional moments and a beautiful tribute to Bowie. I have no problem putting it right alongside "Someone Great" in terms of its cathartic impact.

After a couple of listens, I think I'd put "American Dream" above everything they've done outside of "Sound of Silver." Definitely one of the best "reunion" albums ever produced.

How sick is the part in How Do You Sleep? when Murphy is like "just be aaaaasking... HOW DO YOU SLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEP" :drool:

And yes, good call about Black Screen - I think I made that point earlier, it's very much in that vein, Someone Great.
 
I gave it a try.
To me it sounds like a mix between Underworld and My Life in the Bush of Ghosts, but then somehow still ending up as uninteresting.
 
Seems like they're following their previous thing of not playing that much of the new album yet, haha. Fuck. Tonite, Call the Police and American Dream are all regulars and Emotional Haircut and Change Yr Mind have been played at the Brooklyn Steel gigs and the last two shows in Copenhagen. Interested to see if you get more, Martijn! The Copenhagen sets look sick, just like what we got (which was fucking incredible) plus a few more songs. I'd be stoked with that.

But disappointing they're not yet playing I Used To or in particular How Do You Sleep?
 
Nope, I got the same 4 songs from the album as they played in Copenhagen. But that didn't matter, as it was a fucking great show! Really enjoyed it, dancing, jumping, surviving the pit. It was amazing to see this band in such a small venue.
 
Last night wasn't enough for me. I managed to snag a ticket for today's show too! It came up on Ticketmaster and I couldn't let it pass.
So...

Tonite! :happy:
 
But disappointing they're not yet playing I Used To or in particular How Do You Sleep?

Don't be so disappointed anymore. They debuted I Used To tonight.
The set started with Us v Them, which I think is a better opener than Yr City's A Sucker (even though that's a great song too). For a large part of the show I was in/near the pit so the energy was great over there. What a party!
 
At first I thought How Do You Sleep was the clear highlight, but now I think Tonite is a legit challenger. Some very clever lyrics in that one.
 
American Dream is my album of the year so far. Hard to pick favorite tracks, but top three are 1. i used to; 2. american dream; and 3 call the police. The title track is just mesmerizing.
 
American Dream, Black Screen and Oh Baby. Ask me again in 5 minutes and my answer would probably be different.
 
I think this is LCD Soundsystem's best album.

Its only competition is Sound of Silver, which is the record I will always reach for, as it's got everything that makes them great - emotional dance/rock songs (All My Friends, Someone Great), four-to-the-floor stompers (Get Innocuous!), their self-styled 'dance-punk' - (North American Scum), long, hard-edged, irresistibly rocking dance numbers (Us v Them, Sound of Silver) and more traditional rock song homages (New York I Love You).

But it also has a couple of very enjoyable but neither-here-nor-there tunes (Time to Get Away, Watch the Tapes), and outside of Someone Great, All My Friends, New York I Love You and North American Scum there's not much to write home about lyrically. Which doesn't matter at all, it doesn't remotely effect the record's enjoyment, because they're also a great fucking dance band, which is all about repetition, small morsels of changes that take long songs in extremely effective and interesting ways.

The debut is fucking great fun, but not a whole deal more (not that it needs to be), and This is Happening is split between some of their very best ever songs (Dance Yrself Clean, All I Want, You Wanted a Hit, Home) and a few numbers that fall in that very enjoyable but neither-here-nor-there category (Drunk Girls, One Touch, Pow Pow). And then there's one absolute stinker.

American Dream, I think, is their best, and most fully-formed, effort. It's extremely consistent and it's fully thematic from start to finish. Every single track has, at some point, both fucking awesome music and fucking great lyricism. You can't say that about any other LCD Soundsystem record. The themes James Murphy explores - mortality, business, insecurity, socialism, ageing, the music industry, self-reflection - are done so with a heart of gold and a mind that's constantly ticking and the results are the most compelling set of lyrics he's committed to tape. And then there's the music - full of classic LCD synth bleeps that we've come to know and love, pummelling percussion, warped guitar and a million and one references to Bowie (and others), that, as always, manage to strike this perfect balance between being quite blatant but also extremely genuine, organic and fitting.

Man, I am so glad they're back. Who knows what happens from here, but I'm going to enjoy this album for a fucking long long time.
 
The man's an absolute fucking idiot. Not even going to click on that. I saw his tweets on it, "do they even give a shit anymore" or something to that effect. That's, like, objectively wrong. In the popular Australian vernacular, he's a flog.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom