HBK-79
War Child
We all saw U2 and Green Day unite as one for the reopening of the Superdome a few years ago. So I was wondering if loyal U2 fans here are also Green Day fans.
I ask this because it's a well-known fact that the whole pop-punk genre is regarded as shite to all discerning music listeners in their adult years. In this particular genre, you have the likes of Blink-182, Sum 41, Good Charlotte, and Simple Plan. Green Day are also part of this group.
Now while all these pop-punk outfits have faded into obscurity, Green Day made a comeback in 2004 with American Idiot. In 2005, American Idiot sold more than How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb and X&Y. With that, Green Day became popular like never before. All of this is kind of odd to me, since (like I said) everyone with good taste in music thinks the pop-punk genre sucks.
So what do you guys think of American Idiot? Do you think Green Day are deserving of such success and popularity? Why is Green Day more respected than all the other pop-punk acts out there? How is it that Green Day is still going strong while Sum 41, Good Charlotte, etc. have lost momentum?
Can anyone better elucidate Green Day’s overall appeal to the masses?
I like Green Day and all- but AI was a tad overrated.
I ask this because it's a well-known fact that the whole pop-punk genre is regarded as shite to all discerning music listeners in their adult years. In this particular genre, you have the likes of Blink-182, Sum 41, Good Charlotte, and Simple Plan. Green Day are also part of this group.
Now while all these pop-punk outfits have faded into obscurity, Green Day made a comeback in 2004 with American Idiot. In 2005, American Idiot sold more than How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb and X&Y. With that, Green Day became popular like never before. All of this is kind of odd to me, since (like I said) everyone with good taste in music thinks the pop-punk genre sucks.
So what do you guys think of American Idiot? Do you think Green Day are deserving of such success and popularity? Why is Green Day more respected than all the other pop-punk acts out there? How is it that Green Day is still going strong while Sum 41, Good Charlotte, etc. have lost momentum?
Can anyone better elucidate Green Day’s overall appeal to the masses?
I like Green Day and all- but AI was a tad overrated.