Desert Island IX: Master List, Part Three

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

LemonMelon

More 5G Than Man
Joined
Aug 31, 2004
Messages
68,797
Location
Hollywoo
A month in and we're at part three. We'll get through all of these someday, I promise. Final part should be up in 10-ish days, so if you haven't sent me your playlist yet, that gives you an idea of how long you have before the deadline.

As always, listen, comment and enjoy. The links have been sent.

namkcuR

c2fo.jpg


My entry this time is an all-1970s list. The only criteria for a song to get in were for it to be from the 70s and for me to like it. This list was designed to highlight the diversity of the decade, as many consider the 70s to be the most diverse/eclectic decade for popular music(at least in the mainstream). I tried to represent a wide array of genres and subgenres, although they couldn't all be represented equally(i.e. some get one song, some get a bunch, that kind of thing, that's just how it unfolded). A lot of these are sort of obvious choices, and you probably won't discover much 'new' music here(although some of my selections are far less obvious and might be new to you). That's pretty much it. It's a love-letter to the 70s.

You can listen to each of the four 'sides' individually, but they're designed to segue nicely into each other, so you can listen straight through too.

This was a really tough list to make because there's so much to choose from; I had to make some tough cuts, and use various official edits of some songs to save time, and I still actually used up all of the available time(it's exactly 160:00 long), but I think I ended up with a pretty good list. I hope you enjoy it.

Side A - Disco, Funk, R&B, & Soul

1. Michael Jackson - "Don't Stop Til You Get Enough(7" Edit)" - Number Ones(International Version) (3:56)
2. Abba - "Summer Night City" - Greatest Hits Vol. 2 (3:34)
3. Bee Gees - "Night Fever" - Saturday Night Fever Soundtrack (3:33)
4. K.C. and The Sunshine Band - "That's The Way I Like It(Single Version)" - The Best of K.C. and The Sunshine Band (3:06)
5. The Village People - "Go West(Edit)" - We Want You - Greatest Hits(Europe Import) (3:33)
6. Parliament/Funkadelic - "Night Of The Thumpasorus People" - Mothership Connection (5:10)
7. Commodores - "I'm Ready" - Caught In The Act (3:24)
8. Earth, Wind, and Fire - "Shining Star" - That's The Way Of The World (2:51)
9. Bill Withers - "Ain't No Sunshine" - Just As I Am (2:04)
10. Marvin Gaye - "What's Going On?" - What's Going On? (3:53)
11. Stevie Wonder - "Knocks Me Off My Feet" - Songs In The Key Of Life (3:37)
12. The Delfonics - "Didn't I(Blow Your Mind This Time)" - The Delfonics (3:23)
---
41:58

Side B - Singer-songwriters(Pop & Country) & Classic Rock

1. Elton John - "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (3:13)
2. The Carpenters - "For All We Know" - Carpenters (2:33)
3. Billy Joel- "She's Always A Woman To Me" - The Stranger (3:21)
4. Cat Stevens - "Morning Has Broken" - Teaser and the Firecat (3:20)
5. Harry Chapin - "Cats In The Cradle" - Verities & Balderdash (3:44)
6. Bruce Springsteen - "Factory" - Darkness On The Edge Of Town (2:17)
7. Dolly Parton - "Jolene" - Jolene (2:43)
8. America - "Horse With No Name" - America (4:08)
9. Neil Young - "Heart Of Gold" - Greatest Hits (3:09)
10. Bob Dylan - "Knockin' On Heaven's Door" - Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid (2:32)
11. Led Zeppelin - "Tangerine" - III (3:10)
12. Grateful Dead - "Fire On The Mountain" - Shakedown Street (3:46)
13. George Harrison - "What Is Life" - All Things Must Pass (4:22)
14. Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers - "Refugee" - Greatest Hits (3:22)
15. The Who - "Love Reign O'er Me" - Quadophenia (5:48)
---
51:24

Side C - Early Metal & Hard Rock, Glam, Punk, and Post-Punk

1. Aerosmith - "Walk This Way" - Greatest Hits (3:50)
2. Black Sabbath - "Paranoid" - Paranoid (2:53)
3. T-Rex - "Children Of The Revolution" - Stand-Alone Single (2:29)
4. Argent - "God Gave Rock And Roll To You(45' Edit)" - In Deep (3:20)
5. David Bowie/Mott The Hoople - "All The Young Dudes(David Bowie and Ian Hunter vocal)" - All The Young Dudes(Remastered) (4:24)
6. Queen - "Killer Queen" - Greatest Hits I&II (3:02)
7. The Clash - "Garageland" - The Essential Clash (3:15)
8. The Ramones - "I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend" - Hey! Ho! Let's Go: The Anthology (2:27)
9. Wire - "Mannequin" - Pink Flag (2:37)
10. The Police - "Can't Stand Losing You" - Outlandos d'Amour (2:58)
11. Television - "Elevation" - Marquee Moon (5:07)
12. Patti Smith - "Dancing Barefoot" - Wave (4:16)
---
40:19

Side D - Electronic & Prog

1. Kraftwerk - "Transistor" - Radio-Activity (2:15)
2. Pink Floyd - "Any Colour You Like" - Dark Side Of The Moon (3:26)
3. Genesis - "Seven Stones" - Nursery Cryme (5:08)
4. Yes - "Awaken" - Going For The One (15:31)
---
26:19

Total runtime: 160:00


Mr. V

nameless.jpg


Jibber-jabber:

I've been dying to do another DI and I reckon this might just be my favourite list. I have never used most of these artists before and in fact, most of this music has come out very recently - a fair chunk of it I've only had for a few weeks. But it all fits together. I place a great deal of importance on transitions and I'm really happy with all of these. Thematically, this list kind of follows where I've been at in my life over the last little bit. It just sounds like where I'm at. It's the music I listen to. Hope you like it. PS: My track 31 actually isn't 24 minutes long. Well, it is, but the first four minutes are the song and then it transitions into like 20 minutes of beach noise which obviously isn't compulsory listening.


---


nameless


1. Cocaine 80s - "Nameless" - The Pursuit EP (2:49)
2. Rhye - "The Fall" - Woman (3:45)
3. LCD Soundsystem - "All I Want" - London Sessions (6:29)
4. The National - "All The Wine" - Alligator (3:15)
5. The Black Keys - "Little Black Submarines" - El Camino (4:11)
6. Arctic Monkeys - "R U Mine?" - R U Mine? (single) (3:20)
7. Tame Impala - "Mind Mischief" - Lonerism (4:32)
8. Vampire Weekend - "Hanna Hunt" - Modern Vampires of the City (3:56)
9. Amy Winehouse - "Love is a Losing Game" - Back to Black (2:35)
10. John Legend - "Prelude" - Get Lifted (0:43)
11. John Legend - "Let's Get Lifted" - Let's Get Lifted (3:37)
12. Frank Ocean - "Thinkin Bout You" - Channel Orange (3:21)
13. Flume - "Warm Thoughts" - Flume (3:49)
14. Miami Horror - "Moon Theory" - Illumination (4:23)
15. Autre Ne Veut - "Play by Play" - Anxiety (5:15)
16. The Weeknd - "Wicked Games" - House of Balloons (5:25)
17. Cut Copy - "Need You Now" - Zonoscope (6:09)
18. CLASSIXX - "Holding On (Original Mix)" - Hanging Gardens
19. Chromeo - "Don't Turn The Lights On (Aeroplane Remix)" - Don't Turn The Lights On (single) 5:33)
20. Mark Ronson & The Business Connection - "Bang Bang Bang" - Bang Bang Bang (single) (4:05)
21. Daft Punk - "Lose Yourself to Dance" - Random Access Memories (5:50)
22. Groove Armada - "Serve Chilled" - Vertigo (5:09)
23. U2 - "If You Wear That Velvet Dress" - Pop (5:15)
24. The xx - "Angels" - Coexist (2:53)
25. Dan Sultan - "Goddess Love" - Get Out While You Can (4:13)
26. Frightened Rabbit - "The Twist" - The Midnight Organ Fight (3:31)
27. Best Coast - "Last Year" - The Only Place (3:33)
28. Beach House - "Used To Be" - Teen Dream (4:02)
29. Los Campesinos! - "You'll Need Those Fingers for Crossing" - We Are Beautiful, We Are Doomed (5:09)
30. Japandroids - "The House That Heaven Built" - Celebration Rock (4:49)
31. Eddy Current Suppression Ring - "Rush to Relax" - Rush to Relax (24:39)

Total runtime: 142:27


LJT

TLM.jpg


Tractatus Logico- Musicum I

It's been a while since I took part in a Desert Island, my taste in music I would not say has changed but I like to think my taste has considerably broadened. Looking back on previous DI most of the music I listened to followed a very similar structure, I was always the indie rock/pop guy at school. Now I'm out in the working world and I find myself looking more towards dub-step and other electronica much more and hip hop which I actively avoided while younger but I will always enjoy a good melody no matter how complex or simple a song is. There is no particular theme to these playlists other than to introduce folks to some of the great music I have been listening to over the past couple of years. There is a loose idea that part I is a bit more accessible than part II, to guide the listener into some of the more eclectic material in the second half. The title I have nicked from Ludwig Wittgenstein's Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, and these playlists are (in a small corny way), a logical musical treatise on how music remains such a big part of my life, and long may it "reign o'er me".


01. A Lull- "Weapons of War"- Confetti (4:13)
02. James Pants- "Beta"- James Pants (2:55)
03. Ulrich Schnauss- "Passing By"- Faraway Trains Passing By (6.35)
04. Loops of Your Heart- "Broken Bow"- And Never Ending Nights (10.17)
05. Trembling Blue Stars- "This Once Was An Island"- The Last Holy Writer (4.11)
06. Joe Goddard Feat. Valentina- "Gabriel"- Gabriel EP (5.36)
07. JJ- "Ecstasy"- JJ N°2 (3.33)
08. Wolf Gang- "Dancing With the Devil"- Dancing With the Devil (3.42)
09. Delicate Steve- "Wally Wilder"- Positive Force (4.03)
10. Chic- "What About Me"- Risque (4.14)
11. Gil Scott Heron- "Home Is Where the Hatred Is"- Pieces of a Man (3.22)
12. Dog is Dead- "Do the Right Thing"- All Our Favourite Stories (4.26)
13. Fruit Bats- "The Banishment Song"- Tripper (5.57)
14. How to Dress Well- "Suicide Dream (Orchestral)- Just Once EP (4.50)
15. Anna Calvi- "Suzanne & I"- (4.11)

Total:72:16

Tractatus Logico- Musicum II

01. Stara Rzeka- "Przebudzenie Boga Wschodu"- Cien Chmury Nad Ukrytym Polem (12.10)
02. Balam Acab- "Regret Making Mistakes"- See Birds EP (4.18)
03. Tricky- "Aftermath"- Maxinquaye (7.38)
04. Open Mike Eagle- "Pissy Transmissions"- Unapologetic Art Rap (3.23)
05. Ghostpoet- "Survive It"- Peanut Butter Blues & Melancholy Jam (4.23)
06. iLiKETRAiNS- "The Hive"- The Shallows (5.01)
07. Kuedo- "Truth Flood"- Severant (3.39)
08. Divine Fits- "For Your Heart"- A Thing Called Divine Fits (5.25)
09. Stellar Om Source- "Fascination"- Joy One Mile (5.57)
10. Django Django- "Waveforms"- Django Django (4.26)
11. Moonface- "Faraway Lightning"- With SInaii: Heartbreaking Bravery (4.45)
12. Laurel Halo- "Carcass"- Quarantine (4.32)
13. Disco Inferno- "Love Stepping Out"- The 5 EPs (6.22)
14. Blood Orange- "Champagne Coast"- Coastal Grooves (4.52)
15. Jono McCleery- "Wonderful Life"- There Is (3.22)

Total: 80:20

Grand Total: 152:36


bono_212

DiCover_zps8c0f35da.png


Here we are, my first "Concept" list. What's the concept? I just wanted to make a list of songs with girl's names in the title.

It started as one of those simple ideas...I was driving in my car with Travis and "Oh Sherrie" came on for the 10,000th time. We started talking about songs with girl's names in them and very quickly I decided it would be fun to make a list of them. Then I decided that it might make a nice DI list. I think I started with "Oh Sherrie", "Kayleigh", "Kelsey" (by Metro Station) and "Meet Viriginia"...you're probably going to think the list improved fairly well over that.

Over the next year or so (yes, I've been working on this for a while), every time a new song would come on the radio, I'd get excited and make sure to add it to the list as soon as I got home.

Unfortunately, as these things often do, what started as a fun little hobby soon went down the rabbit hole of insanity. I suddenly had all of these arbitrary rules that mattered to no one but me for what could be on the list. It was for that reason that original staples from the list, "Bette Davis Eyes" and "Hurricane J" (replaced by "Chelsea Dagger" thanks to the Blackhawks) got the boot. The former for not being the name of the actual girl in the song, the latter because Jessie's name is not spelled out in the song title. Those are just two examples of my insanity in creating this list.

But, you know what? I think it was worth it. I really enjoy it and I've had a generally great time making it as well. Shouldn't that always be a part of the fun?

Anyways, I don't want to take up more of your time, I just thought you might like to hear a little about what went on while I made this list. I tried to preserve a bit of that radio feeling that I got while creating this, as you might hear in the opening and closing songs especially. I hope you guys enjoy!

1. Polaris - "Hey Sandy" - Music from The Adventures of Pete & Pete (2:33)
2. The Ramones - "Judy Is a Punk" - Ramones (1:31)
3. The Jesus and Mary Chain - "Taste of Cindy" - Psychocandy (1:42)
4. The Magnetic Fields - "Candy" - The Wayward Bus (2:31)
5. The House of Love - "Christine" - The House of Love (3:24)
6. The Cure - "A Letter To Elise" - Wish (4:19)
7. Wild Nothing - "Only Heather" - Nocturne (3:14)
8. Bat for Lashes - "Marilyn" - The Haunted Man (4:32)
9. Cocteau Twins - "Lorelai" - Treasure (3:41)
10. Prefab Sprout - "Goodbye Lucille #1" - Steve McQueen (4:32)
11. Marillion - "Kayleigh" - Misplaced Childhood (3:32)
12. Steve Perry - "Oh Sherry" - Street Talk (3:48)
13. The Killers - "Believe Me Natalie" - Hot Fuss (5:04)
14. M83 - "Kim & Jessie" - Saturdays = Youth (5:24)
15. Bell X1 - "Eve, The Apple of My Eye" - Music in Mouth (4:02)
16. One EskimO - "Kandi" - One EskimO (4:02)
17. Shawn Colvin - "Sunny Came Home" - A Few Small Repairs (4:24)
18. Jane's Addiction - "Jane Says" - Nothing's Shocking (4:52)
19. Train - "Meet Virginia" - Train (4:00)
20. Franz Ferdinand - "Eleanor Put Your Boots On" - You Could Have it So Much Better (2:50)
21. Okkervil River - "Savannah Smiles" - The Stage Names (3:37)
22. Rod Stewart - "Maggie Mae" - Every Picture Tells a Story (4:58)
23. Pure Prairie League - "Amie" - Bustin' Out (4:18)
24. Kenny Rogers & The First Edition - "Ruby, Don't Take Your Love to Town" - (2:54)
25. Simon & Garfunkel - "Cecilia" - Bridge Over Troubled Water (2:52)
26. The Hollies - "Carrie Anne" - The Hollies' Greatest Hits (2:58)
27. Neil Diamond - "Cracklin' Rosie" - Tap Root Manuscript (2:57)
28. The Beatles - "Dear Prudence" - The Beatles (3:48)
29. Fleetwood Mac - "Rhiannon" - Fleetwood Mac (4:10)
30. The National - "Karen" - Alligator (3:57)
31. The Velvet Underground - "Stephanie Says" - VU (2:48)
32. Rolling Stones - "Ruby Tuesday" - Between the Buttons (3:15)
33. The Left Banke - "Walk Away Renee" - Walk Away Renee/Pretty Ballerina (2:41)
34. Edison Lighthouse - "Love Grows (Where My Rosemary Goes) - Greatest Hits: Edison Lighthouse (2:47)
35. Them - "Gloria" - The Angry Young Them (2:36)
36. Bruce Springsteen - "Candy's Room" - Darkness of the Edge of Town (2:46)
37. Donnie Iris - "Ah! Leah!" - Back on the Streets (3:44)
38. Kaiser Chiefs - "Ruby" - Yours Truly, Angry Mob (3:22)
39. The New Pornographers - "Jackie, Dressed in Cobras" - Twin Cinema (3:03)
40. The Fratellis - "Chelsea Dagger" - Costello Music (3:34)
41. The Knack - "My Sharona" - Get the Knack (4:54)
42. Amanda Palmer - "Melody Dean" - Theatre is Evil (4:02)
43. Elvis Costello - "Veronica" - Spike (3:07)
44. The Nails - "88 Lines About 44 Women" - Mood Swing (4:54)

Total runtime: 157:37


phanan

DI9Cover2.jpg


1. David & David - "Welcome To The Boomtown" - Boomtown (5:33)
2. Simple Minds - "See The Lights" - Real Life (4:24)
3. Beach House - "Lazuli" - Bloom (5:02)
4. Washed Out - "Before" - Within and Without (4:46)
5. Boards Of Canada - "New Seeds" - Tomorrow's Harvest (5:39)
6. Doves - "Winter Hill" - Kingdom Of Rust (5:19)
7. The Church - "Ripple" - Priest = Aura (6:04)
8. Big Country - "Chance" - The Crossing (4:29)
9. Winter Hours - "Island Of Jewels" - Wait Till The Morning (5:12)
10. R.E.M. - "Half A World Away" - Out Of Time (3:28)
11. Hugo Largo - "Fancy" - Drum (4:18)
12. Low - "Especially Me" - C'mon (5:27)
13. The National - "About Today" Cherry Tree (4:11)
14. Beck - "Lost Cause" - Sea Change (3:47)
15. George Harrison - "Behind That Locked Door" - All Things Must Pass (3:10)
16. The Jayhawks - "Settled Down Like Rain" - Hollywood Town Hall (3:01)
17. The Decemberists - "Calamity Song" - The King Is Dead (3:50)
18. John Mellencamp - "Minutes To Memories" - Scarecrow (4:13)
19. The New Pornographers - "Crash Years" - Together (4:07)
20. The Radio Dept. - "This Time Around" - Clinging To A Scheme (3:46)
21. Grimes - "Genesis" - Visions (4:15)
22. Fiction Factory - "(Feels Like) Heaven" - Throw The Warped Wheel Out (3:33)
23. Men At Work - "It's A Mistake" - Cargo (4:47)
24. The Smiths - "Heaven Knows I'm Miserable Now" - Louder Than Bombs (3:37)
25. Modest Mouse - "Dark Center Of The Universe" - The Moon & Antarctica (5:03)
26. Real Estate - "Out Of Tune" - Days (4:52)
27. Dumptruck - "Carefree" - For The Country (3:05)
28. Tom Petty - "Wildflowers" - Wildflowers (3:17)
29. Gordon Lightfoot - "Hi'Way Songs" - Songbook (3:37)
30. The Rolling Stones - "Dead Flowers" - Sticky Fingers (4:05)
31. Head Candy - "Part Of The Earth" - Starcaster (4:44)
32. Buffalo Tom - "Mineral" - Let Me Come Over (4:34)
33. Peter Murphy - "Cuts You Up" - Deep (5:26)
34. Memoryhouse - "Walk With Me" - The Slideshow Effect (4:43)
35. Arcade Fire - "Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains)" - The Suburbs (5:20)
36. Shearwater - "Star Of The Age" - Animal Joy (5:01)

Total time: 159:47
 
1. Cut a hole in the box.
2. Bump.
3. I tracked down one of Axver's running diaries of a prior list of mine because I hate myself. The results were enlightening.
 
Finished the first part of LJT's list. Was really looking forward to this list as I've been listening to a lot of electronic music lately. The first half has lots of variety (going from ambient/electronic to indie rock) but it works surprisingly well. I didn't notice any weird transitions so the flow was good and there were quite a few unknown songs I enjoyed: Passing By, Broken Bow, Gabriel and Do the Right Thing spring to mind. There were a few songs I wasn't so keen on but that didn't bother me too much. Looking forward to part 2.
 
So I finished it. The opening track was definitely interesting. Easily the most out there track I've heard so far during this DI. Overal I liked the second half more than the first. There were less stand-outs but it was more consistent. Favorite song by far was Aftermath. I'm surely going to listen to that Tricky album soon. The flow was again pretty good, not spectacular.
 
Cheers for your thoughts niels, I don't think i've ever entered a list that has been universally loved, but i'm always happy to share new stuff with people, plus because there aren't as many UK posters as there used to be it seems I think I hear a few different things over here than what you get in the states. If your interested in electronic music I advise checking out The Quietus review site. They pride themselves on being more out there than Pitchfork but they write good reviews and most of there main people have a heavy electronic/dance music interest, they can be a bit weird but again the writing is usually good and consistent. They do great articles as well.
 
can't get mr v's second half to download. i'm trying the new links, but it gets stuck on the "preparing to download."

anyone count how many people used tame impala songs? i swear every single playlist i've listened to has included one, even though it was only peef, padj, gump and tourist so far (and i haven't even listened to gump's yet). it's kind of the reason i've been dragging ass on listening to a lot of these. the over-abundance of hipster dream poppy shoegazey music (half being from the last 4 or 5 years) is not something i really need to ever hear again...and yet, here it is. perhaps this was a bad installment to start whining about that, since mr v is the only one here who included them. ljt has all sorts of stuff i probably won't love, but will never have heard before, so that's cool. and namrucker made an all 70s playlist, which means no tame fucking impala, so i already like it. and 212erz' list should be fun.

mr v gets points (despite the tame impala song for me to skip) for being not entirely that, even though when it does veer away from p4k's beloved it doesn't go anywhere i ever wish to go again. at least it's something different. and all the wine (only song i knew going into this) is always a good thing. unexpected highlight: arctic monkeys (who i've actually never listened to, aside from one song when they first got huge). autre ne vuet was pretty awesome, too, though.



phanan up next, which should be good. phanan always put together a good list.
 
Last edited:
Mr. V - really appreciated this as over half the songs I wasn't familiar with. Some of those artists I've never heard of, others are bands that I just never took the time to check out.

Some really standout tracks I'll be holding onto permanently and exploring those artists further.

Nice progression from indie to modern soul to dance/electronic and back to indie again. Plus, any Los Camp! fan is cool in my book.

I was listening to this while working on a sailboat and I let that final track go on for quite some time. Perfect atmosphere to inhabit and a great opportunity to let the music sink in before moving onto more intense stimuli again.
 
can't get mr v's second half to download. i'm trying the new links, but it gets stuck on the "preparing to download."

anyone count how many people used tame impala songs? i swear every single playlist i've listened to has included one, even though it was only peef, padj, gump and tourist so far (and i haven't even listened to gump's yet). it's kind of the reason i've been dragging ass on listening to a lot of these. the over-abundance of hipster dream poppy shoegazey music (half being from the last 4 or 5 years) is not something i really need to ever hear again...and yet, here it is. perhaps this was a bad installment to start whining about that, since mr v is the only one here who included them. ljt has all sorts of stuff i probably won't love, but will never have heard before, so that's cool. and namrucker made an all 70s playlist, which means no tame fucking impala, so i already like it. and 212erz' list should be fun.

mr v gets points (despite the tame impala song for me to skip) for being not entirely that, even though when it does veer away from p4k's beloved it doesn't go anywhere i ever wish to go again. at least it's something different. and all the wine (only song i knew going into this) is always a good thing. unexpected highlight: arctic monkeys (who i've actually never listened to, aside from one song when they first got huge). autre ne vuet was pretty awesome, too, though.



phanan up next, which should be good. phanan always put together a good list.

I'm not sure what you really expected from this competition. Thanks for the nice words though.
 
Mr. V - really appreciated this as over half the songs I wasn't familiar with. Some of those artists I've never heard of, others are bands that I just never took the time to check out.

Some really standout tracks I'll be holding onto permanently and exploring those artists further.

Nice progression from indie to modern soul to dance/electronic and back to indie again. Plus, any Los Camp! fan is cool in my book.

I was listening to this while working on a sailboat and I let that final track go on for quite some time. Perfect atmosphere to inhabit and a great opportunity to let the music sink in before moving onto more intense stimuli again.

Thanks man. Aw, that would have been perfect for Rush to Relax.
 
I'm not sure what you really expected from this competition. Thanks for the nice words though.

:shrug: what I described is exactly what I did expect the first time I played this game, and while I've only participated in one longer di and a mini, it's hardly what people have done. Despite the way threads dedicated to pitchfork bnm bands do dominate this place, there is still a decent variety of music being discussed. Then on top of that, people were pulling out lists filled with other things they listen to. Oneblood's total hip hop list, LM has deftly crossed genres with each list he's made, phanan had an uncanny ability to provide context in which I find myself enjoying songs that I know I would hate on their own, iyup made a mini blues rock list last time, what i daid before about your list, laz's is different too, etc. it's probably the way they were grouped together, or just the order in which I started listening (which is why I haven't cracked gump or Joey's yet) where it's felt like a best of this place's favorite current bands has dominated. There was even that person who made metal list that one time (and I was the only person who liked it).


You'll probably get to my list and wonder why I even post on this site, but the best thing about it is that under most circumstances, there is a nice variety of music talked about at this place--more so than any other one place I've found on the Internet. And I did used to be a huge U2 fan at one point.
 
That was a frustratingly glib comment on my part. To that end though, I don't see the point in dressing down folks for their tastes. Not sure what type of discourse that is suppose to inspire, though it's great that you're being honest. I'm definitely throwing stones in this case, just rubbed me the wrong way is all.

Superchunk - Me & You & Jackie Mittoo - YouTube
 
Dammit, the Internet cut out and just ate my original post. Let me try this again.


Dressing anyone down for their taste in music wasn't my intent. Despite my normal cynical, borderline sociopathic tendencies in most other aspects of life, I meant it more as an apology as to why I'm sorry, I'm trying to enjoy the playlists people spent some time and effort constructing (ones that represent some of their favorite music out there), and while there certainly are elements of every one I've listened to thus far that I do enjoy, the common denominator preventing me from really getting into this game is the over abundance of this particular music. Was it a bit abrasive and poorly framed for an apology? Probably. Do I (or anyone who doesn't like a particular list) really need to apologize for not really liking someone else's contribution to a game on a message board? Not really. I could keep that to myself. To be honest, if I'm going to single out a band like tame impala as overused, I should probably mention the ubiquitousness of the national as well, but as I am fully on board with the near-universal love that band receives at this place, they're something of a blind spot for me. Hell, if you want overlap in taste, Joey and I use the same fucking nine inch nails song. It's not even like well, cobbler used all the wine two DIs ago and mr v used it this time. I get that sort of thing is going to happen. My real disappointment is the fact that I'm not gleaning all kinds of awesome new musical discoveries off people's lists, cos I'm selfish like that.
 
This isn't directed at IWB at all, but I get very annoyed by comments aimed at us B&Cers by other forum members as if we're all simply Pitchfork fanboys. These lists would be a cavalcade of shitty no-name hip-hop if that were the case.
 
There are plenty of sites out there to discover music through besides Pitchfork. I find any insinuation that I'm a P4k fanboy to be more of an insult towards my ability to use google than in my taste in music.

But honestly, I'm just glad people are using this thread.
 
I only mentioned pitchfork as a descriptor for the genre classification I don't exactly know the name of. Hipster shoegazy pitchfork bnm dream pop psychedelic throwback--that's the kind of mouthful I try to avoid, much like my general dislike (which we've discussed about as frequently as Christgau comes up) of slapping post- -core -wave prefixes and suffixes to things just to give them a name. But I really don't know what else to call those bands. If I had just slapped that vague blanket term of "indie" on it, we probably could have avoided this conversation altogether (then we could have had that equally tired conversation about using indie to categorize music instead! wouldnt that have been fun to rehash).

I know that while a lot of you guys do check pitchfork from time to time, I was also under the impression that most, if not all, of you consider the bulk of their writing obnoxious and pretentious, and take it as just another source. Like I apparently tried to convey and failed to before, I've learned from past DI games that pretty much everyone here has a much wider variety of musical taste than most people I've run into both on and offline--something no one here would have if any of us were straight up pitchfork fanboys (this would be a pretty shitty place to discuss music, and I'd have left years ago). The whole pitchfork fanboy thing as an insult is for the close-minded only-post-in-eykiw/only-listen-to-U2-or-bands-thy-think-sound-like-U2 schlooopy types. I know there's more to the people who frequent b&c than that. It's that whole selfish thing about wanting to be handed a taste of music outside of what I already am familiar with. Hell, I get irritated with pandora when I type in bouncing souls, and it gives me the same social distortion, street dogs, pennywise songs I've already had on my iPod for years. Maybe it's just an indication that I've spent too much time here, weighted this place as too important a source of music, and that's where the overlap really comes from.

Or, I just really don't like tame impala.
 
I think I could legitimately be called a Pitchfork fanboy in the sense that I have enjoyed a very high percentage of what they recommend (aside from hip-hop, which is my blindspot). On that basis I trust their judgment, as I think many of us do considering how many bands/artists are discussed on account of a BNM tag.

That said, I think every one of us that frequents B&C also has a lot of knowledge about music outside Pitchfork as well. Cobbler knows hip-hop, Laz knows basically everything about the 90s, djerdap seems to know metal quite well, I'd say I know a thing or two about jazz, etc. Though our tastes may intersect at Pitchfork darlings like The National or Los Campesinos, the spectrum of this forum as a whole is impressively far-reaching. Just my take.
 
This isn't directed at IWB at all, but I get very annoyed by comments aimed at us B&Cers by other forum members as if we're all simply Pitchfork fanboys. These lists would be a cavalcade of shitty no-name hip-hop if that were the case.

I remember a post Nick made in which he said something to the effect that any poster who doesn't fawn over U2 must be too busy listening to Vampire Weekend. I know obnoxiousness was his intent, but it was still a comment of glaring ignorance.
 
I think I could legitimately be called a Pitchfork fanboy in the sense that I have enjoyed a very high percentage of what they recommend (aside from hip-hop, which is my blindspot). On that basis I trust their judgment, as I think many of us do considering how many bands/artists are discussed on account of a BNM tag.

But there's a difference between using them as a trustworthy source of music recommendations vs simply agreeing with everything they say. You can enjoy the majority of the albums they tag as bnm all you want, but unless you're parroting their opinions word for word, I don't think fanboy is really the correct term.

That said, I think every one of us that frequents B&C also has a lot of knowledge about music outside Pitchfork as well. Cobbler knows hip-hop, Laz knows basically everything about the 90s, djerdap seems to know metal quite well, I'd say I know a thing or two about jazz, etc. Though our tastes may intersect at Pitchfork darlings like The National or Los Campesinos, the spectrum of this forum as a whole is impressively far-reaching. Just my take.

Exactly.
 
Laz knows basically everything about the 90s

I know more than that!

I'm smahhhht!


IWB is right, a true Pitchfork fanboy would just take all their ratings as gospel, and like everything that gets a high score.

While I get almost all my music info from Pitchfork (either directly or through people here), my tastes don't fall in line like that. It's just a place to discover what's new and read descriptions where you can get a sense of whether it's something you might enjoy.
 
Back
Top Bottom