UltravioletU2
The Fly
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2002
- Messages
- 222
So, as a Christian, what do you think of Harry Potter?
I am a Christian, not one that is totally on the right track right now, but struggling. I love Harry Potter. Here are some of my thoughts:
1. Most Christians have not read Harry Potter yet criticize him ruthlessly.
2. The HP attackers let their kids watch the Wizard of Oz and read them fairy tales of witches and wizards and spells and enchantment.
3. These same Christians who claim "this fiction can turn real" are the same people who watch movies with shootings and killings, but when questioned, they say, "it's only a movie!"
4. These people will take their kids to see innocent magicians who wave a wand and do a magic trick, yet when HP waves his wand and makes something float, he is satanic.
I dunno. I think Harry Potter is great. Sure, the last ones are dark, but no darker than fantasy stories like LOTR. Perhaps the last one was a little bit too dark for children, but it's simply good versus evil. I guess I find that Christians who have the book chopping parties and HP protests seeth religiousness and turn people off from Christianity.
What are some of your views? I find it's hard to find a Christian who has actually read Harry Potter. I see it as a fantasy land, good versus evil plot. Just like the old fairy tales with godmothers who waved their wand, Harry waves his wand. Plus, it has encouraged so many children to read.
If I had children who begged me to introduce them to Harry Potter "because all their friends are", I would read it with them and discuss it. I know they would love the books, because I sure do!
I am a Christian, not one that is totally on the right track right now, but struggling. I love Harry Potter. Here are some of my thoughts:
1. Most Christians have not read Harry Potter yet criticize him ruthlessly.
2. The HP attackers let their kids watch the Wizard of Oz and read them fairy tales of witches and wizards and spells and enchantment.
3. These same Christians who claim "this fiction can turn real" are the same people who watch movies with shootings and killings, but when questioned, they say, "it's only a movie!"
4. These people will take their kids to see innocent magicians who wave a wand and do a magic trick, yet when HP waves his wand and makes something float, he is satanic.
I dunno. I think Harry Potter is great. Sure, the last ones are dark, but no darker than fantasy stories like LOTR. Perhaps the last one was a little bit too dark for children, but it's simply good versus evil. I guess I find that Christians who have the book chopping parties and HP protests seeth religiousness and turn people off from Christianity.
What are some of your views? I find it's hard to find a Christian who has actually read Harry Potter. I see it as a fantasy land, good versus evil plot. Just like the old fairy tales with godmothers who waved their wand, Harry waves his wand. Plus, it has encouraged so many children to read.
If I had children who begged me to introduce them to Harry Potter "because all their friends are", I would read it with them and discuss it. I know they would love the books, because I sure do!