nathan1977
Rock n' Roll Doggie
The notion of cause and effect in our world tilts me towards determinism and even introducing some truly random non-deterministic event that alters my actions still leaves my thought processes beyond my control. My feeling is that we all have an illusion of choice and are psychologically primed with concepts about moral responsibility that don't easily reconcile with determinism.
I actually agree with this as well, but I feel like the force of determinism is a consequence of our own choices and actions -- karma. Do to others as you've been done. I don't even think it's a choice a lot of the time -- I don't think we can help it. I'm reading a fascinating book about relationships that explores the time-honored and tested notions that so much of our dysfunction is inherited -- the sins of the father, so to speak, being passed down. The entropic nature of the universe prevails.
This is why I've never had a problem with humanity needing a Savior, because without some external change, we will never escape our darker side. The concepts of moral responsibility, as you so aptly put it, are from our conscience -- and the conscience, at least in my worldview, is the reminder from the Spirit of who we were/are supposed to be. And without an external force to introduce change, we would be left alone to contend with forces over which we have no control.
St. Paul puts it this way: we're either beholden to sin (our broken nature) or beholden to righteousness (our whole nature). And the whole story of humanity is that we can't ever really escape our brokenness on our own. It's why from the Greeks to the Romans to the present day, human drama rarely changes. If anything, God restores choice to us by presenting us with another option. He tells His people in Deuteronomy, I've set before you death and life. Choose life.