Ranking the songs after >10 days

[BVS]

NLOTH
M
IGCIIDGCT
GOYB
SUC
B

I prefer:

 

[purpleoscar]

I prefer:

Jeez the new U2 album is really LONG.

 

[nielsgov]

It's difficult.
1. Unknown Caller: one their best ever, the intro is just amazing and the solo too of course!
2. Fez-Being Born: it's just a soaring song!

3. Breathe: great rocksong with very good solo!
4. Moment of Surrender: just an epic song, love the vocals!
5. Magnificent: classical U2!
6. No Line on the Horizon: also great vocals, great opener!
7. Cedars of Lebanon: one of their best closers ever!

8. Get on Your Boots: fun song and better than Vertigo.
9. White As Snow: beautiful song with great lyrics.

10. Crazy: just a fun pop song, the 'baby baby baby' part is the best.
11. Stand up Comedy: just good, not very special but I certainly don't hate it.

 

[God Part III]

Magnificent is slowly fading for me.
WAS on the day of release:

1. Magnificent
2. Breathe
3. No Line On The Horizon
4. FEZ/Being Born
5. Unknown Caller
6. White As Snow
7. Get On Your Boots
8. Cedars of Lebanon
9. Moment of Surrender
10. I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
11. Stand Up Comedy

IS now:

1. No Line On The Horizon
2. Unknown Caller
3. Moment of Surrender
4. Magnificent
5. FEZ/Being Born
6. Breathe
7. Get On Your Boots
8. Cedars of Lebanon
9. I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
10. White As Snow
11. Stand Up Comedy

I'm starting to think that Unknown Caller features the greatest Edge solo ever.

 

[gweeps]

After six months:

Breathe
Fez – Being Born
I’ll Go Crazy If I Don’t Go Crazy Tonight
No Line on the Horizon
Moment of Surrender
White as Snow
Cedars of Lebanon
Unknown Caller
Magnificent
Stand Up Comedy
Get On Your Boots

 

[roy]

I'm starting to think that Unknown Caller features the greatest Edge solo ever.

I've thought this ever since I heard the original beach clip.

 

[trinx]

MOS #1, but Breathe is so close after hearing it live - what an awesome song. Magnificent as well. Unknown Caller. These are the ones I listen to the most. I simply can't decide, I really like the album.

 

[2861U2]

1) Breathe
2) Magnificent
3) Cedars Of Lebanon
4) IGCIIDGCT
5) Stand Up Comedy
6) Get On Your Boots
7) No Line On The Horizon
8) White As Snow
9) Fez-Being Born
10) Unknown Caller
11) Moment Of Surrender

And less than 2 months later...

1) Breathe
2) No Line On The Horizon
3) Magnificent
4) I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
5) Moment Of Surrender
6) Cedars Of Lebanon
7) Get On Your Boots
8) Unknown Caller
9) Fez-Being Born
10) Stand Up Comedy
11) White As Snow

No doubt this is an amazing album.

 

[cjboog]

I am very surprised that so few people have Breathe at the top of their lists! I cannot stop listening to this song -- have had it stuck in my head for 2 weeks. It absolutely ROCKS live and is quickly becomming an all time favorite

WAS...

1) Magnificent
2) Breathe
3) Moment Of Surrender
4) Get On Your Boots
5) Unknown Caller
6) I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
7) No Line On The Horizon
8) Stand Up Comedy
9) Fez - Being Born
10) White As Snow
11) Cedars Of Lebanon

NOW IS...

1) Magnificent + Breathe (tie)
3) Moment Of Surrender
4) I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
5) Get On Your Boots
6) No Line On The Horizon
7) Unknown Caller
8) Fez - Being Born
9) Stand Up Comedy
10) White As Snow
11) Cedars Of Lebanon

 

[xtrmx]

Crazy Tonight still going strong for me, the normal lenght-single version made it even better. Magnificent is falling a bit, I think that song could have used a bit faster bpm.
NLOTH2 was fun for a bit, but I prefer lady with the spinning head over it.
I wish Fez was 3 mins long, Being born is aswell.

At release:

1) I'll go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight
(2) NLOTH2
2) Magnificent
3) Moment Of Surrender
4) Unknown Caller
5) No Line on the Horizon
6) Get On Your Boots
7) Cedars of lebanon
8) Stand up Comedy
9) Fez - Being Born
10) Breathe
11) White As Snow

At this moment:

1) I'll go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight +0
2) Fez - Being Born +7
3) Moment Of Surrender +0
4) Magnificent -2
5) Stand Up Comedy +3
6) Unknown Caller -2
7) Get On Your Boots -1
8) No Line on the Horizon -3
(9) NLOTH2 -7
9) Breathe +1
10) Cedars of Lebanon -3
11) White As Snow +0 I think this song will forever be my least favourite u2 song

 

[digitize]

1) Moment of Surrender
2) Unknown Caller
3) No Line On The Horizon
4) Crazy Tonight
5) Breathe
6) Magnificent
7) White As Snow
8) Boots
9) Fez-Being Born
10) Cedars
11) Stand Up Comedy

Now, I absolutely adore every song on this album, so SUC getting eleventh place doesn't make it the worst song on NLOTH so much as the eleventh-best song on NLOTH for me. It was incredibly difficult to rank all of these songs - I think every one of them would be in my U2 top fifty.

 

[An Cat Gav]

Mine is now:

1:Magnificent
2:FEZ Being Born
3.Get On Your Boots
4.No Line On The Horizon
5.Moment Of Surrender
6.Cedars Of Lebanon
7.IGCIIDGCT
8.Breathe
9.White As Snow

10.......Unknown Caller



11........................................Stand Up Comedy

I can't see this order changing too much. The songs I loved from day 1, I still love. The songs I wasn't that keen on, I now really don't like and that's UC and SUC. There's still some for UC as it seemed greatly improved live and it's opening minute is great, but I will never ever like SUC.

 

[mikal]

NLOTH
MOS
Fez-Being Born
UC
White As Snow
Magnificent
Breathe
Cedars Of Lebanon
Get On Your Boots
Stand Up Comedy
Crazy Tonight

 

[popacrobat]

Tough call for me.

Moment of Surrender
Breathe
No Line on the Horizon
Magnificent
Get on Your Boots
Unknown Caller
I'll Go Crazy
White as Snow
Fez- Being Born
Cedars of Lebanon
Stand up Comedy

I should add that I really like Stand up Comedy too. I like every song on this album and love half of it. good job U2.

 

[popacrobat]

Now, I absolutely adore every song on this album, so SUC getting eleventh place doesn't make it the worst song on NLOTH so much as the eleventh-best song on NLOTH for me.

yeah, i'm with you there.

 

[gvox]

Breathe
Unknown Caller
Magnificent
Moment Of Surrender
No Line on the Horizon
Crazy Tonight
Get on Your Boots
White as Snow
Cedars of Lebanon
Fez- Being Born
Stand up Comedy

 

[aptdot]

Unknown Caller
Magnificent
Breathe
Crazy Tonight
Stand Up Comedy
Moment of Surrender
White As Snow
Cedars of Lebanon
NLOTH
Fez
Boots