more info on deluxe edition of U218

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
andyuk said:


I would say ATYCLB is a big as ACHTUNG for big hit singles as you quoted 6 songs above and i named 6 for ATYCLB

lets do a one 4 one for hit singles on the 6 we named

The fly v BD winner = BD
MW v STUCK = MW
EBTTRT v Elevation = Elevation
ONE v Walk On = One
WGRYWH v Kite = Kite
UTEOTW v IALW = UTEOTW

Pretty close i reckon 3 each!

Looks like you edited your post. Let me respond to the second half!

The fly v BD winner = The Fly by a mile in quality, but we really should be putting the biggest hit against the biggest hit here.

MW v STUCK = MW
EBTTRT v Elevation = EBTTRT by a mile.
ONE v Walk On = One. Not a competition.
WGRYWH v Kite = Wild Horses.
UTEOTW v IALW = Tie. IALW is the best song on the album. But you know what? It wasn't a single!!!!! So really this comparision is meaningless....
 
Niceman said:


Looks like you edited your post. Let me respond to the second half!

The fly v BD winner = The Fly by a mile in quality, but we really should be putting the biggest hit against the biggest hit here.

MW v STUCK = MW
EBTTRT v Elevation = EBTTRT by a mile.
ONE v Walk On = One. Not a competition.
WGRYWH v Kite = Wild Horses.
UTEOTW v IALW = Tie. IALW is the best song on the album. But you know what? It wasn't a single!!!!! So really this comparision is meaningless....

We should be discussing;

One vs Beautiful Day - Tie.
Stuck in a Moment v Mysterious Ways - MW
Elevation v The Fly - The Fly
Walk On v (any track on Achtung) - NOT Walk On

Then Even Better than the Real Thing and Until the End of the World are thrown in on top, just for good measure!:)
 
Niceman said:


Looks like you edited your post. Let me respond to the second half!

The fly v BD winner = The Fly by a mile in quality, but we really should be putting the biggest hit against the biggest hit here.

MW v STUCK = MW
EBTTRT v Elevation = EBTTRT by a mile.
ONE v Walk On = One. Not a competition.
WGRYWH v Kite = Wild Horses.
UTEOTW v IALW = Tie. IALW is the best song on the album. But you know what? It wasn't a single!!!!! So really this comparision is meaningless....

i am extremely surprised that you class WGRYWH better than KITE?
 
well i suppose this is why U2 is so great! so many quality songs and albums that appeal to different people with different tastes!
 
Back
Top Bottom