Someone was saying in another thread that there are multiple basslines/guitars being played (sorry if I am not too sure of the technical terms) so that it must have been being played from a cd?
Beach clip #1 - Moment of Surrender or NLOTH? *Discuss Clip 1 Here*
- Thread starter Hoodlem
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
Someone was saying in another thread that there are multiple basslines/guitars being played (sorry if I am not too sure of the technical terms) so that it must have been being played from a cd?
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
I think some of you are confusing clips...
the 3:15 clip is what some people are saying is "For Your Love" or "Surface of Your Love" (we still don't know for sure if he is saying "I am coming to the surface of your love" or "I am coming to the surface for your love"....a completely different song to any of the four ben clips that we have, and completely different to the 3:43 clip....
the 3:43 clip was recorded a few months ago, and that was believed to have been NLOTH, but we are not certain...
ben clip # 1 is either NLOTH or a song we have never heard before, but it contains the same outro as the 3:43 clip, and a similar "whoa whoa blah blah..." chanting chorus that we hear in the Lanois film clip (what we are hearing in ben clip # 1)...I originally thought the melody in the 3:43 clip at about 19 seconds was the same exact chanting melody as ben clip # 1, but Niceman seems pretty confident that they are just similar, but not the same....I'm still not sure, the quality is simply too poor
the 3:15 clip is what some people are saying is "For Your Love" or "Surface of Your Love" (we still don't know for sure if he is saying "I am coming to the surface of your love" or "I am coming to the surface for your love"....a completely different song to any of the four ben clips that we have, and completely different to the 3:43 clip....
the 3:43 clip was recorded a few months ago, and that was believed to have been NLOTH, but we are not certain...
ben clip # 1 is either NLOTH or a song we have never heard before, but it contains the same outro as the 3:43 clip, and a similar "whoa whoa blah blah..." chanting chorus that we hear in the Lanois film clip (what we are hearing in ben clip # 1)...I originally thought the melody in the 3:43 clip at about 19 seconds was the same exact chanting melody as ben clip # 1, but Niceman seems pretty confident that they are just similar, but not the same....I'm still not sure, the quality is simply too poor
mgokelly
The Fly
mgokelly
The Fly
I'm outta here folks it's getting late here in the middle of the Emerald Isle, all will become crystal clear in the coming weeks (Remember - everything you know is wrong!!!!!)
Someone posted them online, just do a search in Google for the bit in bold.
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
at the 39/40 mark...I really can't make out anything 
U2DMfan
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
I've made a new edited clip with a comparison between the two.
Lanois Movie Chant vs the 3:43 NLOTH Garbledshizz
3:43 sounds like "There is no...line on the horizon"
the chant is obviously "Oh oh oh"
They do sound similar though, I have them in stereo comparisons.
I almost wish I had never heard that 3:43 clip, it bugs the shit out of me.
I forgot to put the fucking solo in this clip but I've already encoded and uploaded.
Let's just assume it's the exact same thing, huh? 
Oh yeah, if you want to hear this, PM me for the link.
If you still haven't heard NLOTH in the 3:43 clip, you should get this one.
Lanois Movie Chant vs the 3:43 NLOTH Garbledshizz
3:43 sounds like "There is no...line on the horizon"
the chant is obviously "Oh oh oh"
They do sound similar though, I have them in stereo comparisons.
I almost wish I had never heard that 3:43 clip, it bugs the shit out of me.
I forgot to put the fucking solo in this clip but I've already encoded and uploaded.
Let's just assume it's the exact same thing, huh? Oh yeah, if you want to hear this, PM me for the link.
If you still haven't heard NLOTH in the 3:43 clip, you should get this one.
Zooropa man
Refugee
Listening more and more to Song1.... he is clearly saying "Suuurrendeeerrr!!" in there more then once. Its gotta be "MOS"
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
at what times do you think he is singing this?
Zooropa man
Refugee
It's around the 1:04 mark and then again at 1:21
OP
OP
Hoodlem
War Child
Zooropa man
Refugee
lol
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
well I went to those spots and I can hear that...but it's not clear enough...
basically, some think that clip 1 is NLOTH, others think it's MOS...and others think it isn't any of these
we really aren't getting anywhere....we're fumbling over possible lyrics when we really no nothing for certain...the 3:43 clip really through me off course...I'm not sure what to think anymore
Zooropa man
Refugee
I also think that it starts with, "baby don't go there...'' Just IMO
Zooropa man
Refugee
well I went to those spots and I can hear that...but it's not clear enough...
basically, some think that clip 1 is NLOTH, others think it's MOS...and others think it isn't any of these
we really aren't getting anywhere....we're fumbling over possible lyrics when we really no nothing for certain...the 3:43 clip really through me off course...I'm not sure what to think anymore
Can you email that 3:43 clip? I haven't heard it.
mr.mcphisto93@gmail.com
OP
OP
Hoodlem
War Child
well I went to those spots and I can hear that...but it's not clear enough...
basically, some think that clip 1 is NLOTH, others think it's MOS...and others think it isn't any of these
we really aren't getting anywhere....we're fumbling over possible lyrics when we really no nothing for certain...the 3:43 clip really through me off course...I'm not sure what to think anymore
The good news is that no matter which songs turn out to be what, they are all absolutely cracking tunes!
OP
OP
Hoodlem
War Child
What instrument is that at 2:36? Strings, horns, guitar? Whatever it is that little ascending note sequence is stunning and quite moving. I have it stuck in my head. And then of course the solo. Do I even need to comment on that?
Basically from 2:27 on is U2 taking it to a level that few if any other bands can do. This is what I've been missing.
Basically from 2:27 on is U2 taking it to a level that few if any other bands can do. This is what I've been missing.
quadcaster
Refugee
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2004
- Messages
- 1,700
Hey guys!
somehow i missed this 3:43 clip, could somebody please send it to me?
reavesy@hotmail.com
thanks
chris
somehow i missed this 3:43 clip, could somebody please send it to me?
reavesy@hotmail.com
thanks
chris
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
quadcaster
Refugee
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2004
- Messages
- 1,700
Got it, thanks rob!
just gonna listen to it...
just gonna listen to it...
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
your welcome
it's incredibly hard to make anything out in it.....but what we can make out more clearly is the guitar solo outro thing, and clip # 1 appears to have the same outro....but the songs are different...so they might've moved the outro to another song...or something, I dunno
quadcaster
Refugee
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2004
- Messages
- 1,700
your welcome
it's incredibly hard to make anything out in it.....but what we can make out more clearly is the guitar solo outro thing, and clip # 1 appears to have the same outro....but the songs are different...so they might've moved the outro to another song...or something, I dunno
well i downloaded it, but it isnt playing.......... i downloaded it twice and its not working :S
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
K I sent it a different way...check e mail
quadcaster
Refugee
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2004
- Messages
- 1,700
yeah still not working. i load it up in windows media player and it "plays" for a second or two, then stops.
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
hmm...try playing it through itunes
quadcaster
Refugee
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2004
- Messages
- 1,700
U2DMfan
Rock n' Roll Doggie VIP PASS
MrBTH
War Child
Yeah its a very Eno type sound - kinda synthetic but emotional at the same time... It'll probably get hammered for not being a "real" instrument when the real version comes out... Remember the hammering "Stuck..." got from many on here for daring to use synth horns at the climax of the song!!
Zooropa man
Refugee
sent....lemme know if it reaches you
Got it.
To me it sounds like two songs.... being played at the same time. Was this recorded before or after the Song1 and other clips?
Similar threads
- Locked
