With or without you vs One vs Stay vs Sometimes vs Moment!

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

BoyOnTheHorizon

Refugee
Joined
Aug 27, 2008
Messages
1,110
Location
Brazil
How could we rank these "superballads" from U2 against each other??

We could add All i want is you and So cruel...
 
One

and then all the rest

Edit: What, Stay is in the title???

STAY

and then all the rest
 
With or Without You
One
All I Want Is You
Stay


Thats not up for debate
 
So Cruel

Then there's the rest... cause I'm lazy and don't want to rank the rest right now. :wink:
 
I can't compare them as ballads, yeah, they're ballads, but that's the only thing they have in common, different styles, different vibes, different themes, this question, for me, is like if you ask me to compare, I don't know, a lemon and an umbrella. All I can say is that all of them have a very special place in my heart (well, MOS not still, but I think it will).
 
Of those songs in the thread title:

1. With Or Without You
2. Stay
3. Moment Of Surrender
=4,500,000. SYCMIOYO
=4,500,000. One
 
Stay - 10/10
All I Want Is You - 10/10
So Cruel - 10/10
One - 9/10
Moment of Surrender - 8/10
WOWY - 8/10
SYCMIOYO - 8/10

They're all great.
 
Im gonna sound like a d*ck here but in my opinion

WOWY is romantic for a couple
One is more a uniting song
Stay and Sometimes and Moment feel like broken up/self doubt/inspirational songs.


I know,

:D

BUT, if you want me to say which one I love the best? has to be Stay!
 
Back
Top Bottom